Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (119) (remove)
Language
- English (119) (remove)
Has Fulltext
- yes (119)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (119)
Keywords
- Resistenz (3)
- Cytologie (2)
- Histologie (2)
- Immunchemie (2)
- Immunologie (2)
- Immunsystem (2)
- Kardiovaskuläre Krankheit (2)
- Leukozyt (2)
- Lymphozyt (2)
- fMRI (2)
Institute
- Medizin (119) (remove)
Abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) is the most common type of aortic aneurysm, which is defined as a dilation of the abdominal aorta over 3.0 cm or more. Surgical repair is the golden standard for the treatment of AAA, in which open surgical repair (OSR) and endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) are the main approaches. Technically speaking, the lesion segment of aueurysm is completely replaced by a graft during OSR, while in EVAR, the lesion is insulated by a stentgraft. EVAR is a less invasive treatment than OSR and shows a lower early mortality rate, although the long-term advantages of EVAR over OSR remain inconclusive.
Endoleak, especially the type II endoleak (T2EL), is a common complication after EVAR. According to research, 16-28% of the patients develop a T2EL after EVAR, and it accounts for nearly three in four of all types of endoleaks. Around 30-50% of the T2EL resolved spontaneously during the follow-up, however, it still causes a secondary intervention in many patients. Therefore, it is critical to monitor endoleaks after repair.
Patent aortic branches in the stent-overlapped area and vasa vasorum have been identified as potential sources of blood flow in T2EL. However, the mechanisms of biological changes or remodeling of the aneurysm sac after the repair are still not clear, but they have been considered to play an important role in the development of endoleaks. Unfortunately, it is impossible to obtain a tissue sample of the aortic wall in patients who underwent EVAR.
MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are a class of small single-stranded non-coding RNAs that inhibit the expression of target message RNA (mRNA). miR-29b/29c, miR-155, and miR-15a are miRNAs associated with regulating extracellular matrix (ECM) components, inflammation, and proliferation, respectively. All four miRNAs have been identified as biomarkers of AAA, not only in aneurysm tissue but also extracellular as circulating miRNAs. However, it is still unknown whether they can reflect the biological changes after AAA repair. Thus, we conducted a prospective study to investigate the changes in expression of circulating miR-29b, miR-29c, miR-155, and miR-15a before (T0), 3 days (T1), and 3 months (T2) after AAA repair.
A total of 39 patients were recruited for this study, 17 of whom were repaired by OSR and 22 of whom were repaired by EVAR. Four patients failed the T2 follow-up due to the Covid-19 pandemic. No significant changes were found in the expression of miR-29b, miR-29c, miR-155, and miR-15a. There were also no obvious differences between OSR and EVAR. However, the T1 expression of miR-15a was significantly lower in patients without endoleak after EVAR than in those who developed endoleak after EVAR and those who were repaired by OSR. Unfortunately, these differences did not persist to the T2 follow-up, and no other differences were found among these patients.
In summary, miR-15a is a miRNA that significantly changes in AAA patients. This study demonstrates that the expression of circulating miR-15a is lower in patients without endoleak three days after EVAR, compared to those who had endoleak after EVAR and those who underwent OSR. The results suggest that miR-15a might be involved in the early aortic remodeling after EVAR as an indicator of endoleak.
Type 1 diabetes (T1D) is precipitated by the autoimmune destruction of the insulin-producing beta-cells in the pancreatic islets of Langerhans. Chemokines have been identified as major conductors of the islet infiltration by autoaggressive leukocytes, including antigen-presenting cells and islet autoantigen-specific T cells. We have previously generated a roadmap of the gene expression in the islet microenvironment during T1D in a mouse model and found that most of the chemokine axes are chronically upregulated during T1D. We focused our attention on CXCL10/CXCR3, CCL5/CCR5, CXCL16/CCR6, CX3CL1/CX3CR1, and XCL1/XCR1. First, we found that the absence of CCR6 and of CX3CR1 diminished T1D incidence in a mouse model for T1D. Further, the XCL1/XCR1 chemokine axis is of particular interest, since XCR1 is exclusively expressed on convention dendritic cells type 1 (cDC1) that excel by their high capacity for T cell activation. Here we demonstrate that cDC1 expressing XCR1 are present in and around the islets of patients with T1D and of islet-autoantibody positive individuals. Further, in an inducible mouse model for T1D, we show that XCL1 plays an important role in the attraction of highly potent dendritic cells expressing XCR1 to the islets. XCL1-deficient mice display a diminished infiltration of XCR1+ cDC1 and subsequently also a reduced magnitude and activity of islet autoantigen-specific T cells. XCR1-deficient mice display a reduced magnitude and activity of islet autoantigen-specific T cells. A 3D-visualization of the entire pancreas reveals that both XCL1-deficient mice and XCR1-deficient mice indeed maintain most of their functional islets after induction of the disease. Thus, the absence of XCL1 results in a profound decrease in T1D incidence. The XCR1-deficiency also reduces T1D incidence, even if in a less drastic way compared to XCL1-deficiency. An interference with the XCL1/XCR1 chemokine axis might constitute a novel target for the therapy for T1D.
Aim: The cytochrome P450 reductase (POR) along with the cytochrome P450 enzymes (CYP) are responsible for the metabolism of a multitude of metabolites important for the maintenance of tissue function. Defects in this system have been associated with cardiovascular diseases. These enzymes are known to produce vasoactive lipids that modulate vascular tone. The aim of this study was to identify the consequence of a loss in endothelial POR for vascular function.
Methods and Results: To identify the endothelial contribution of the POR/CYP450 system to vascular function, we generated an endothelial-specific, tamoxifen-inducible POR knockout mouse (ecPOR-/-). Under basal condition ecPOR-/- already exhibited endothelial dysfunction in aorta and mesenteric vessels (acetylcholine-dependent relaxation, LogEC50 -7.6M for CTR vs. -7.2M for ecPOR-/- in aorta) and lower nitric oxide levels in the plasma (CTR: 236.8 ±77.4; ecPOR-/- 182.8 ±34.1 nmol/L). This dysfunction was coupled to attenuated eNOS function detected by the heavy arginine assay and decreased eNOS phosphorylation on S1177. Furthermore, insulin-induced phosphorylation of the eNOS activator, AKT, was also attenuated in the aorta from ecPOR-/- mice as compared to control mice. CYP450-dependent EET production was lower in plasma, lung and aorta of ecPOR-/- mice and this was accompanied with increased levels of vasoconstriction prostanoids (lipidomics of aorta, plasma and lung freshly isolated from CTR and ecPOR-/- mice). MACE-RNAseq from these aortas also showed a significant increase in genes annotated to eicosanoid production. In an in vivo angiotensin II model, acute deletion of POR increased the blood pressure as measured by telemetry and tail cuff (137.4 ± 15.9 mmHg in WT; 152.1 ± 7.154 mmHg in ecPOR-/-). In a rescue experiment using the NSAID naproxen, the increase in blood pressure induced by deletion of endothelial POR was abolished.
Conclusion: Collectively, in endothelial cells POR regulates eNOS activity and orchestrates the metabolic fate of arachidonic acid towards the vessel dilating EETs and away from deleterious prostanoids. In the absence of POR this endothelial regulation is compromised leading to vascular dysfunction.
Molecular oxygen (O2) is essential for numerous metabolic processes. Not surprisingly, hypoxia and the resulting adaptations play a pivotal role in pathophysiology, e.g., in cancer or in inflammatory diseases. Of note, myeloid cells are known to accumulate in hypoxic regions such as tumor cores or rheumatoid arthritis joints and may contribute to disease progression. While most studies so far concentrated on transcriptional adaptation by the hypoxia-inducible factors (HIF) 1 and 2 under short term hypoxia, prolonged oxygen deprivation and alternative post-transcriptional regulation are rather poorly investigated.
Consequently, the aim of the study was to generate a comprehensive overview of mRNA de novo synthesis and degradation and its contribution to total mRNA changes in monocytic cells in the course of hypoxia.
To this end, I used thiol-linked alkylation for the metabolic sequencing of RNA (SLAM-Seq) to characterize RNA dynamics under hypoxia. Specifically, I labeled monocytic THP-1 cells under normoxia (N), acute hypoxia (AH; 8 h 1% O2), or chronic hypoxia (CH; 72 h 1% O2) with 4-thiouridine (4sU), which allows for transcriptome-wide identification of de novo synthesized mRNAs and estimation of their half-lives. Total mRNA expression analyses revealed that most changes occurred under CH. Considering that HIF accumulation and resulting transcriptional regulation was shown to decline again under CH, I further analyzed the impact of RNA stability on gene expression. I observed a global reduction in RNA half-lives under hypoxia, indicative for the attenuation of energy-consuming protein synthesis upon oxygen deprivation. Moreover, I observed a subgroup of hypoxic destabilized transcripts with resulting decreased mRNA expression under CH, which consisted of 59 nuclear-encoded mitochondrial mRNAs. This might prevent futile production of new mitochondria under conditions, where mitochondria are even actively degraded to prevent production of detrimental reactive oxygen species.
While stability-regulated transcripts were mainly destabilized under hypoxia, the vast majority of differentially de novo synthesized transcripts were upregulated.
Functional analyses revealed not only hypoxia, but also cholesterol homeostasis and inflammatory response as top enriched terms, corroborating findings on total mRNA level. Focusing on hypoxia-altered cholesterol metabolism, I observed an 9 accumulation of early and a decrease in late cholesterol precursors, which are separated by several oxygen-dependent enzymatic steps. Although total cholesterol levels were only slightly reduced, my data indicate locally lowered endoplasmic reticulum (ER) cholesterol levels under hypoxia, which cause feedback activation of the ER cholesterol-sensing transcription factor sterol regulatory element-binding protein 2 (SREBP2) and induction of cholesterol biosynthesis enzymes. Interestingly, a broad range of interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs), mainly known for their antiviral function, was also induced under hypoxia with similar kinetics as SREBP2 targets, suggesting an immunometabolic crosstalk. While the availability of certain cholesterol biosynthesis intermediates as well as a direct involvement of SREBP2 seemed rather unlikely to cause hypoxic ISG induction, changes in intracellular cholesterol distribution appeared crucial for the hypoxic induction of chemokine-ISGs. Mechanistically, I found that MyD88-dependent toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) signaling contributes to enhanced hypoxic ISG induction, likely sensitized by changes in cholesterol dynamics. Importantly, hypoxia amplified induction of chemokine-ISGs in monocytes upon treatment with severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus type 2 (SARS-CoV-2) spike protein via TLR4 similarly as after addition of infectious virus, which might contribute to systemic inflammation in hypoxemic patients with severe coronavirus disease-2019 (COVID-19).
Taken together, I comprehensively analyzed RNA dynamics in hypoxic monocytes. Specifically, I identified RNA stability as a modulating mechanism to limit production of mitochondria under oxygen-restricted conditions. Moreover, I characterized the immunometabolic crosstalk between disturbed cholesterol homeostasis and spontaneous induction of interferon (IFN)-signaling in hypoxic monocytes, which might contribute to systemic inflammation in severe cases of COVID-19.
Tinnitus is a symptom experienced by most people at least once in their lifetime. In most documented cases, a new onset of chronic tinnitus can be chronologically correlated with hearing loss. However, tinnitus can also occur in people with (apparently) normal hearing and remains without a traceable preceding cause. Despite the frequency of occurrence of tinnitus, the pathophysiological mechanisms are still not fully understood. A currently proposed hypothesis focuses on a "hidden" hearing loss called synaptopathy as a pathomechanism of tinnitus in normal hearing subjects. In the present study, the objective was to test whether finestructure audiometry or measurement of otoacoustic emissions can reveal possibly overlooked hearing impairment in presumed normalhearing individuals with chronic tinnitus. Thus, a hearing loss not audiologically detectable by the usual methods would supplement or replace the presumed synaptopathic pathomechanism. Another objective was to attempt to replicate the existing findings of another research group on synaptopathy as cause for tinnitus in normal hearing people. Schaette and McAlpine (2011) were able to demonstrate a significant difference in wave I amplitudes between groups of normal hearing subjects with and without chronic tinnitus by deriving clickevoked auditory brainstem potentials, thus supporting the hypothesis of synaptopathy18.
For the present study, a cohort of normal-hearing subjects consisting of a group of tinnitus subjects (N = 15) and a control group (N = 14) was tested. Manual puretone audiometry with 11 test frequencies was conducted to determine hearing performance. Inclusion criteria were defined as air conducted hearing thresholds of 10 dB HL or lower. A deviation at a test frequency of 15 dB HL or less was tolerated. Data of tinnitus characteristics, such as pitch and intensity, were collected by presentation and matching of comparative tones, quality and subjective disturbance by questionnaire. Furthermore, data was obtained from both test groups by Békésy gliding frequency audiometry (794 test frequencies), as well as DPOAE measurement (36 test frequencies) and auditory brainstem response (ABR) audiometry (derivation of early auditory evoked potentials). The results showed a correlation of the determined tinnitus comparison pitch with the frequency location of the largest deviation (impairment) from the normal hearing curve in the Békésy gliding frequency audiometry (p = 0.032). All further analyses of the finestructure hearing curve (steepness of hearing loss, slope, number of hearing loss dips) showed no statistically significant relationship between the morphology of the fine-structure hearing curve and tinnitus characteristics. Finestructure measurement revealed areas of hearing loss that were not mapped in manual puretone audiometry. These "undetected" hearing losses would have led to the exclusion of 12 of 29 subjects (41.4 %) if the finestructure hearing curve had been used as an inclusion criterion. A direct comparison of the mean finestructure hearing curves of both test groups showed a statistically significant better mean hearing performance of the tinnitus group (p < 0.05) in 3 different test frequency ranges (1.5 kHz, 3 kHz, 7 kHz) with a maximum of 4 dB HL. Analy-sis of the mean amplitudes of wave I of the ABRs showed, contrary to expectation, a weak trend toward higher amplitudes in the tinnitus group (p = 0.06). According to Schaette and McAlpine (2011), synaptopathy pathogenesis should have resulted in an opposite trend, i.e., a decrease in wave I amplitude in the tinnitus group. As a secondary finding, a weak trend between wave I amplitude and subjectively perceived disturbance of tinnitus was demonstrated (p = 0.06). Statistical analysis of the parameters determined from the DPOAE measurements did not reveal any significant differences between the tinnitus group and control group. Direct comparison of the DPOAE and finestructure hearing curves, revealed a significant difference in the differences of the frequencyspecific measurements around 2.4 kHz (p = 0.007).
The results of the study suggest that in previous studies with supposedly normal hearing tinnitus subjects there were unrecognized hearing losses that either went unrecognized by the screening by manual puretone audiometry, or subjects with previously aboveaverage hearing experienced a subtle spontaneous decrease in their hearing as tinnitus pathogenesis. This assumption is also supported by the fact that there is a significant correlation between the frequency range of the greatest hearing loss in the finestructure hearing curves and the tinnitus frequency.
The suspected pathomechanism of synaptopathy in "normal hearing" subjects with tinnitus could not be confirmed. The correlation between wave I amplitudes and subjectively perceived disturbance by tinnitus, indicated by the data of this study, should be investigated in more detail in future studies. Further research with more accurate measurement methods and larger subject groups is needed to clarify the hypothesis "Genesis of chronic subjective tinnitus without hearing loss".
The impact of the Covid-19 pandemic called for rapid responses in face of unprecedented challenges. In this context, earning more about the causative agent SARS-CoV-2 becomes imperative. Therefore, clinical virus isolates were studied with focus on infectivity, replication kinetic, and caspase activity.
Firstly, clinical specimens collected from patients were tested for infectivity in cell culture. Combined with polymerase chain reaction results, a formula predicting infectivity in cell culture based on abundance of viral RNA was developed. Additionally, analysis of different specimen types, sources, and material, elucidate the question of infectivity. Here, infectivity was demonstrated in specimens derived from different parts of the respiratory tract, including specimens collected from deceased persons. A protocol for virus isolation on human airway epithelium in air-liquid interface culture was established.
Secondly, replication kinetics of 20 clinical isolates were compared, including a subset of seven sequenced isolates. All isolates replicated in the colon epithelial cell culture model. Within the subset, differences between isolates carrying the D614G amino acid exchange and with original spike protein were observed.
Lastly, elevated caspase activity was demonstrated in two cell culture models including human airway epithelium in air-liquid interface culture.
Subsequently, caspase inhibition by small-molecule compound Emricasan and its effects on the cytopathic effect observed in cell culture were studied. Here, increased cell survival in a colon epithelial cell line was shown with unimpaired virus replication. Elevated caspase activity was identified as early marker of infection and validated by testing across 20 clinical virus isolates.
This study offers information on infectivity that can help shape the understanding of transmission risk. As such, parts of the data collected here were used for validation of rapid antigen tests. The insights gained by studying caspase activity contributed in part to the development of a drug screening method by Bojkova et al.,41 thus aiding routine laboratory workflow. It was demonstrated that Emricasan exhibits no antiviral effect, while the finding of increased cell survival in cell culture could give rise to further research on prevention of tissue damage.
IL-38 is the latest discovered cytokine of the IL-1 family and has been added to the IL-36 subfamily. Since its discovery in 2001, increasing evidence suggests predominantly anti-inflammatory properties of IL-38, which are most likely exerted through three potential receptors, the IL-1 Receptor 1 (IL-1R1), IL-36 Receptor (IL-36R) and the IL-1 Receptor Accessory Protein Like 1 (IL-1RAPL1). However, to this date detailed knowledge of IL-38 functioning remains to be examined. Importantly, how IL-38 is processed, secreted from cells and the exact mechanisms of target receptor binding and intracellular signaling are not fully understood. Further, IL-38 has been associated with regulatory functions in autoimmune diseases like systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and psoriasis. At the same time however, connections between B cells as indispensable part of immunity and IL-38 remain rare.
In this study we examined the influence of IL-38 in peripheral human blood B cells differentiating into antibody secreting cells using a three-step in vitro differentiation process. We first show that all potential IL-38 binding receptors are present on peripheral blood B cells on a gene expression level and remain detectable throughout B cell differentiation. Next, while B cells treated with exogenous IL-38 depict no differences in early B cell activation markers, the process of B cell differentiation revealed significant alterations in B cell phenotype created by IL-38 treatment. Predominantly on day 7 of the differentiation process, IL-38 treated B cells showed significantly reduced CD38 expression which depicts an important step in development towards plasma cells. We hypothesize that IL-38 acts antagonistically on the IL-1R1 pathway reducing Nuclear factor kappa B (NFκB) expression and consequently decreasing CD38 expression. Further IL-38 reduced early antibody production while increasing IgM secretion at the end stages of differentiation. Next, we repeated the differentiation assays under the influence of additional IL-21 stimulation to further enhance plasma cell development. In these experiments, the impact of IL-38 on B cell differentiation and immunoglobulin production were reduced, indicating a comparatively moderate relevance of IL-38 for B cell differentiation. We then examined how proliferation and cell death were impacted by exogenous IL-38 during B cell differentiation. IL-38 treatment alone significantly reduced B cell survival which was further augmented by IL-21 stimulation. We conclude that IL-38 and IL-21 act synergistically in promoting B cell apoptosis, also depicting an anti-inflammatory property of IL-38. Finally, using a siRNA we successfully performed an IL-38 knockdown experiment of human blood B cells reducing IL-38 expression to 44% measured on day 4 of B cell differentiation. In these experiments we observed reversed tendencies of CD38 expression compared to exogenous IL-38 treatment. Here, IL-38 knockdown cells showed increased CD38 expression indicating endogenous regulatory properties of IL-38 in B cell differentiation.
Our project, for the first time proves direct effects of IL-38 on human B cells. The results support previous research of IL-38 to act anti-inflammatory as it seems to modulate B cell differentiation, survival, and immunoglobulin production in a down-regulatory manner. These findings pave way for more detailed research on the connection between B cell homoeostasis and IL-38 function.
Facial expression recognition is linked to clinical and neurofunctional differences in autism
(2022)
Background: Difficulties in social communication are a defining clinical feature of autism. However, the underlying neurobiological heterogeneity has impeded targeted therapies, and requires new approaches to identifying clinically relevant bio-behavioural subgroups. In the largest autism cohort to date, we comprehensively examined difficulties in facial expression recognition, a key process in social communication, as a bio-behavioural stratification biomarker, and validated them against clinical features and neurofunctional responses.
Methods: Between 255 and 488 participants aged 6-30 years with autism, typical development and/or mild intellectual disability completed the Karolinska Directed Emotional Faces task, the Reading the Mind in the Eyes Task and/or the Films Expression Task. We first examined mean-group differences on each test. Then we used a novel intersection approach that compares two centroid and connectivity-based clustering methods to derive subgroups based on the combined performance across the three tasks. Measures and subgroups were then related to clinical features and neurofunctional differences measured using fMRI during a fearful face-matching task.
Results: We found significant mean-group differences on each expression recognition test. However, cluster analyses showed that these were driven by a low-performing autistic subgroup (~30% of autistic individuals who performed below 2SDs of the neurotypical mean on at least one test), while a larger subgroup (~70%) performed within 1SD on at least 2 tests. The low-performing subgroup also had on average significantly more social-communication difficulties and lower activation in the amygdala and fusiform gyrus than the high-performing subgroup.
Limitations: Findings of autism expression recognition subgroups and their characteristics require independent replication. This is currently not possible, as there is no other existing data set that includes all relevant measures. However, we demonstrated high internal robustness (91.6%) of findings between two clustering methods with fundamentally different assumptions, which is a critical pre-condition for independent replication.
Conclusions: We identified a subgroup of autistic individuals with expression recognition difficulties and showed that this related to clinical and neurobiological characteristics. If replicated, expression recognition may serve as bio-behavioural stratification biomarker and aid in the development of targeted interventions for a subgroup of autistic individuals.
G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) comprise the largest transmembrane receptor family encoded in the human genome. GPCRs mediate the effect of a wide diversity of stimuli including light, odorants, ions, lipids, small peptides, and hormones. GPR182 is a GPCR for which no endogenous ligand has been identified yet. In the absence of an identified ligand, GPR182 remained poorly understood, and its biological functions had remained elusive. The presented work shows that GPR182 is highly and specifically expressed in microvascular endothelial cells. Phylogenetically, GPR182 is closely related to the atypical chemokine receptor 3 (ACKR3). Here, I show that GPR182 binds the chemokines CXCL10, -12 and -13. Similarly to other so-called atypical chemokine receptors, GPR182 is not coupled to G-proteins but is rather constitutively internalized following β-arrestin 2 recruitment. Consistent with potential scavenger functions, we detected increased concentration of the chemokines which bind the receptor in the plasma of Gpr182 deficient mice. Finally, we show that GPR182 plays an essential role in maintaining hematopoietic stem cells within the bone marrow niche. In summary, the data indicate that GPR182 is a novel member of the group of atypical chemokine receptors, which plays an important role in the chemokine/chemokine receptor network.
The Nodular lymphocyte-predominant Hodgkin lymphoma (NLPHL) as well as the T-cell/histiocyte-rich large B-cell lymphoma (THRLBCL) are rare types of malignant lymphomas. Both NLPHL and THRLBCL are frequently observed in middle-aged men with THRLBCL presenting frequently with an advanced Ann-Arbor stage with B-symptoms and associated with more aggressive courses.3 However, due to the limited number of tumor cells in the tissue of both NLPHL and THRLBCL, limited numbers of studies have been conducted on these lymphomas and current results are mainly based on general molecular genetic studies.
In order to obtain a better understanding for these disease forms as well as possible changes in their nuclear and cytoplasmatic sizes, the following study relied on the comparison of the different NLPHL forms and THRLBCL in terms of nuclear size and nuclear volume. This was carried out using both 2D and 3D analysis. During the 2D analysis of nuclear size and nuclear volume no significant differences could be presented between those groups. However, the 3D analysis of NLPHL and THRLBCL pointed out a slightly enlarged nuclear volume in THRLBCL. Furthermore, the analysis indicated a significantly increased cytoplasmatic size of THRLBCL compared to NLPHL forms. Nevertheless, differences occurred not only between the tumor cells of both disease forms, but also the T cells presented a larger nuclear volume in THRLBCL. B cells, which were considered as the control group, did not demonstrate any significant differences between the different groups. The presented results suggest an increased activity of T cells in THRLBCL, which is most likely to be interpreted as a response against the surrounding tumor cells and probably limits the proliferation of the tumor cells. Based on these results, the importance of 3D analysis is also evident due to the fact that it is clearly superior to 2D analysis. For a better understanding of both disease forms, it is therefore recommended to use the 3D technique in combination with molecular genetic analysis in future research.