Refine
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (4)
Language
- English (4)
Has Fulltext
- yes (4)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (4)
Keywords
- Biomineralization (1)
- Carbonate (1)
- Carbonated apatite (1)
- Clumped isotopes (1)
- Middle Miocene (1)
- clumped isotopes (1)
Institute
During this study clumped isotope analysis of carbonates was established at the Goethe University of Frankfurt, Germany. Therefore, preparation protocols and analytical parameters were elaborated to obtain precise and accurate Δ47 data. Briefly, analyte CO2 was cleaned cryogenically using glass extraction lines to remove traces of water that enable re-equilibration of C–O bonds in the gases. Furthermore, analyte CO2 was passed through a gas chromatograph (GC) to clean it from contaminants that produce isobaric interferences with m/z 47. Initially, phosphoric acid digestions of carbonates was conducted at 25 °C in McCrea-type reaction vessels. Afterwards samples were reacted at 90 °C using a common acid bath. Mass spectrometric analyses were performed using a MAT 253 equipped with a dual inlet system. Δ47 values were directly projected to the absolute scale using CO2 gases equilibrated at distinct temperatures.
In cooperation with Stefano Bernasconi and his research group at ETH Zurich we studied the non-linearity that occurs for the measurement of m/z 47. This effect results from secondary electrons created by the m/z 44 beam. These electrons cause a negative background on the m/z 47 collector. A correction procedure was proposed that relies on the determination of the negative background on the m/z 47 Faraday cup. This approach might reduce time-consuming analyses of heated gases which were used so far to account for the observed non-linearity. However, the suggested correction of the negative background on the m/z 47 cup is only applicable if the slit width of the m/z 44 beam is significantly wider than that of the m/z 47 beam.
This thesis, furthermore, presents a comparison of the different phosphoric acid digestion techniques which are commonly used for carbonate clumped isotope analysis. For calcitic and aragonitic material digested at 25 °C in McCrea-type vessels we observed that the sample size has an effect on Δ47 data: higher mean Δ47 values and a larger scatter of data were received for samples <7 mg than for larger aliquots. For carbonate samples digested at 90 °C in a common acid bath no sample size effect was determined. We assume that secondary re-equilibration of CO2 with water preferentially occurs at 25 °C producing the observed differences. However, a sample size effect can be avoided if reaction temperature is increased to 90 °C.
In order to make carbonate Δ47 data obtained from acid digestions at 90 °C comparable to Δ47 data received from reactions at 25 °C the difference of the acid fractionation factores (Δ47*25-90) between both temperatures has to be known. For the determination of the Δ47*25-90 value we have considered Δ47 data made at 25 °C from samples >7 mg only. For calicte and aragonite we obtained differences in fractionation factores of 0.075‰ and 0.066‰, respectively. These Δ47*25-90 values are coincident with the theoretical prediction of 0.069‰ proposed for calcite (Guo et al., 2009).
Moreover, this dissertation comprises a calibration study of the clumped isotope thermometer based on various natural calcites that grew between 9 and 38 °C. The samples include a brachiopod shell, a bivalve shell, an eggshell of an ostrich and foraminifera tests which formed from distinct biomineralizing processes. Furthermore we included an authigenic carbonate crystallized from biological-induced precipitation. The following linear relationship between 1/T2 and Δ47 was determined (with Δ47 in ‰ and T in K):
Δ47 = 0.0327 (± 0.0026) x 106 / T2 + 0.3030 (± 0.0308) (R2 = 0.9915)
This equation differs from the pioneering Ghosh et al. (2006a) calibration. However, our regression line is statistically indistinguishable from that of Henkes et al. (2013) which is based on aragonitic mollusks and calcitic brachiopod shells. Both studies have in common that calibration data were, at first, directly referenced to the absolute scale. In addition, both datasets rely on similar digestion techniques. Furthermore, the two calibrations are conform with the theoretical prediction of Guo et al. (2009).
The calcite calibration of the clumped isotope paleothermometer received in this study was applied to Δ47 data measured for Silurian brachiopods shells from Gotland/Sweden. Prior to isotopic analysis the fossils were intensively investigated for their preservation state (CL, SEM, trace elements). The lowest T(Δ47) values of ca. 28 to 33 °C were estimated from ultrastructurally well-preserved regions of some shells. For these samples also the lowest δ18Ow values of Silurian seawater were determined. These estimates of ca. −1‰ confirm the assumption that the δ18O value of the Silurian ocean was buffered to (0 ± 1)‰.
Nevertheless, most studied shells were characterized by a patchwork of pristine and altered shell portions resulting in elevated T(Δ47) values which plot mostly between 40 and 60 °C. Our results indicate that the clumped isotopic composition of the shells were altered at low water-rock ratios, not affecting the δ18O values. Δ47 and δ18O data of associated diagenetic phases (sparitic and micritic phases of the inner fillings of the fossils) provide evidence that the sparitic cements grew during several diagenetic events which occurred at different temperatures in fluid-buffered systems. We, furthermore, conclude that the micritic phases lithified at a very early diagenetic stage with the δ18O values being most probably close to a Silurian seawater composition
This Ph.D. thesis demonstrates i) the highly precise performance of refined and new analytical setups for clumped isotope analysis (Δ47 and Δ48) and ii) the applicability of clumped isotope analyses to biogenic and abiogenic carbonated apatite (Δ47) and abiogenic carbonates (Δ47 and Δ48) for research related to paleothermophysiology and paleoclimatology, whereas the overall analytical precision has been increased.
A comprehensive Δ47 dataset with 122 replicate analyses is provided from which the temperature dependence of Δ47 for (bio)apatite (Δ47-1/T2) is calculated between 1 °C and 80 °C. The temperature dependence of oxygen isotope equilibrium fractionation between carbonated synthetic apatite and water (1,000ln(αCHAP-H2O)) is experimentally determined. When applied to tooth enameloid from a modern Greenland shark (Somniosus microcephalus), a Late Miocene megatooth shark (Carcharodon megalodon), and an Upper Cretaceous Tyrannosaurus rex, reconstructed Δ47-based temperatures and δ18OH2O are in line with previously published data.
An analytical setup for highly precise clumped isotope analysis is described that allows for the simultaneous measurement of ∆47 and ∆48 in CO2 with external reproducibilities close to the respective shot-noise limits. The analyte gases originate from pure carbonates that were digested in hypersaturated orthophosphoric acid and purified using a fully automated device. Δ47 data sets with 117 replicate analyses in total on 22 pedogenic carbonate nodules from two Spanish Middle Miocene sections reveal the continental Southern European thermal structure during the end of the Middle Miocene Climatic Optimum (MCO) and the complete Middle Miocene Climatic Transition (MMCT; from 15.33 to 12.98 Ma).
Cenozoic lignite deposits are widespread across Europe, Asia, America, Australia, and Indonesia. These deposits were the subject of numerous studies on changes in regional/global paleoclimates, paleobotany, paleoenvironment, and basin evolutions, which led to the formation of these lignites. In some of these Cenozoic lignite deposit basins, a succession of pale and dark lignite layers has been described in the Miocene Lower Rhine Basin in Germany, the Oligo-Miocene Gippsland Basin in southeastern Australia, and several Mio-Pliocene basins in southwestern China. Furthermore, pale and dark lithotypes in lignite seams also have been found in some Pliocene lignite deposit basins from Slovenia, Serbia, and Poland. The widespread cyclic occurrence of pale and dark layers in lignite basins might represent alternating depositional conditions related to the changes in plant communities, the regional/global climate, the tectonic setting, the Asian monsoon, and orbital periodicity during peat formation. ...
During my PhD, I was applying the clumped isotope technique to modern brachiopods and fossil belemnites, and I conducted methodological work. Carbonate clumped isotope thermometry is a tool to reconstruct carbonate precipitation temperatures. In contrast to oxygen isotope thermometry, i.e., the δ18O-thermometer, the carbonate clumped isotope thermometer does not require an estimate for the oxygen isotope composition of the seawater, as it considers the fractionation of isotopes exclusively amongst carbonate isotopologues. The ∆47 value of a carbonate expresses the abundance of the 13C–18O bond bearing carbonate isotopologue, within the carbonate, relative to its random distribution. In thermodynamic equilibrium, the ∆47 value of a given carbonate is solely a function of the carbonate precipitation temperature. However, kinetic isotope fractionations, i.e., vital effects, driven by diffusion, pH or incomplete oxygen isotope exchange between water and dissolved inorganic carbonate species can cause the carbonate to be precipitated with isotopic compositions that are offset from those predicted for thermodynamic equilibrium.
Brachiopods serve as important geochemical archives of past climate conditions. To investigate the nature and significance of kinetic controls on brachiopod shell δ18O and ∆47 values, in collaboration with the BASE-LiNE Earth ITN, I analysed the bulk and clumped isotope compositions of eighteen modern brachiopod shells, collected from different geographic locations and water depths that cover a substantial range of growth temperatures. Growth temperatures and seawater δ18O values for each brachiopod were independently determined. Most of the analysed brachiopods exhibit combined offsets from clumped and oxygen isotope equilibrium, and there is a significant negative correlation between the offset values. The observed correlation slope between offset ∆47 and offset δ18O point to the importance of kinetic effects associated with Knudsen diffusion and incomplete hydration and hydroxylation of CO2 (aq), occurring during biomineralisation. The correlations between the growth rates of the analysed brachiopods and both the offset ∆47 and the offset δ18O values provide further arguments for the presence of kinetic effects. In conclusion, the oxygen and clumped isotope composition of modern brachiopod shells are affected by growth rate-induced kinetic effects that hinder their use for palaeoceanography.