Refine
Year of publication
- 2015 (12) (remove)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (12)
Has Fulltext
- yes (12)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (12)
Keywords
- AlignMe (1)
- Alignment (1)
- Corynebakterium efficiens (1)
- Fettsäuresynthase Typ I (1)
- Kristallkeimbildung (1)
- Membrane Protein Alignments (1)
- Membrane Proteins (1)
- Röntgenkristallographie (1)
Institute
- Biochemie und Chemie (11)
- Pharmazie (2)
Die Biosynthese der Fettsäuren (FS) ist in Eukaryoten und Bakterien ein hochkonserviert zentraler Stoffwechselweg, der in zwei strukturell verschiedenen Systemen ausgeführt wird. Die meisten Bakterien, Parasiten, Pflanzen und Mitochondrien nutzen ein Fettsäuresesynthase Typ-II (FAS-II) System. Bei FAS II Systemen sind alle katalytischen Domänen separate lösliche Proteine. In Eukaryoten wie auch den Bakterien Corynebakteria, Mycobakteria, Nocardia (Klasse der CMN Bakterien) liegen die katalytischen Domänen fusioniert auf einer Polypeptidkette vor, die zu einem Multienzymkomplex der Fettsäuresynthase Typ I (FAS-I) assemblieren. Die Architektur der FAS-I zeigt große Unterschiede; die X förmige Säuger-FAS-I (Maier et al., 2006), sowie die fassartigen Enzyme der Pilz FAS-I (Jenni et al., 2007; Leibundgut et al., 2007; Lomakin et al., 2007; Johansson et al., 2008) und der bakteriellen FAS-I (Boehringer et al., 2013; Ciccarelli et al., 2013). Zwischen Pilz- und bakterieller FAS-I gibt es trotz des ähnlichen Aufbaus bedeutende Unterschiede. Mycobakterium tuberculosis, der Auslöser von Tuberkulose (TB), an der jährlich über eine Million Menschen weltweit sterben (WHO, 2014), synthetisiert durch eine Symbiose von FAS-I, FAS-II und der Polyketidsynthase-13 Mykolsäuren. Durch die Mykolsäuren ist M. tuberculosis resistent gegen äußere Einflüsse. FAS-I ist in die Synthese der Vorstufen der Mykolsäuren involviert. Sie stellt im Kampf gegen TB ein potentielles Inhibierungstarget dar.
Strukturell war die bakterielle FAS-I beim Beginn der vorliegenden Arbeit, nur durch negative-stain-Elektronenmikroskopie (EM) Aufnahmen aus dem Jahr 1982 charakterisiert (Morishima et al., 1982). In dieser Arbeit konnte die bakteriellen FAS I aus M. tuberculosis (MtFAS), sowie Corynebacterium ammoniagenes (CaFAS) und Corynebacterium efficiens (CeFAS) strukturell untersucht werden. Dies geschah mit den Methoden negative-stain-EM, Einzelmolekül-Cryo-EM (Cryo-EM), Cryo EM Tomographie (CET) und Röntgenkristallographie.
Anhand von CeFAS-Kristallen konnte erstmals durch Röntgenkristallographie die Struktur einer bakteriellen FAS-I bestimmt werden. Zudem wurde die hohe konformationelle Flexibilität der bakteriellen FAS-I mit mehreren Methoden gezeigt. Für die CaFAS konnte mit Cryo-EM initiale Prozesse der Proteinkristallbildung abgebildet werden.
Die 5-Lipoxygenase (5-LOX) stellt den Startpunkt des Leukotrienstoffwechsels dar, da sie Arachidonsäure (AA) über die 5(S)-Hydroperoxy-6-trans-8,11,14-cis-eicosatetraensäure (5-HpETE) in Leukotrien A4 (LTA4) umwandelt. 5-HpETE kann zum korrespondierenden Alkohol 5(S)-Hydroxy-6-trans-8,11,14-cis-eicosatetraensäure (5-HETE) reduziert werden. LTA4 dient als Zwischenprodukt für die Synthese von LTB4 und den Cysteinyl-gebundenden LTs LTC4, LTD4 und LTE4. LTs nehmen eine wichtige Funktion in der Immunabwehr ein, sind jedoch auch an einer Vielzahl von Krankheitsgeschehen wie z. B. Asthma bronchiale, Atherosklerose und einiger Tumorarten beteiligt. Die 5-LOX teilt sich in zwei Domänen auf: der reglatorischen, N-terminalen Domäne und der katalytischen, C-terminalen Domäne. Ihre Aktivität unterliegt einer komplexen allosterischen Regulation und kinetischen Besonderheiten wie einer Substratinhibition. In vielen Fällen ist die regulatorische PLAT-(Polycystin-1, Lipoxygenase, alpha-Toxin)-Domäne involviert. Sie ist essentiell an der Bindung von Calcium, Membranen und weiterer Faktoren wie dem Coactosin-like protein (CLP) und Dicer beteiligt. Auch eine zweite Bindungsstelle für das Substrat oder einen seiner Metaboliten wird dort vermutet. Letztlich bleibt jedoch die Regulation der 5-LOX-Aktivität durch die PLAT-Domäne unzureichend geklärt. Diese Tatsache und die fortwährende Suche nach neuen Ansatzpunkten für die 5-LOX-Inhibition bilden den Hintergrund, vor dem diese Arbeit angefertigt wurde.
Das Ziel lag in der Entwicklung einer stabilen, isolierten PLAT-Domäne und deren Charakterisierung. Es stellte sich jedoch heraus, dass sich die isolierte Domäne durch eine hohe thermische Instabilität und starke Aggregationsneigung auszeichnet. Mittels Mutationsstudien auf Basis der 5-LOX AS 1-115, verbunden mit Gelfiltrationsläufen zur Analyse der Proteinaggregation, wurde schließlich ein Konstrukt entwickelt, das in Konzentrationen < 0,5 mg/ml als Monomer vorlag: die sogenannte PLAT1-115 W75G. Ein Austausch des W75 in Glycin erhöhte ebenfalls die thermische Stabilität, so dass Versuche bei 20°C durchgeführt werden konnten. Zunächst wurden jedoch die grundlegenden Eigenschaften der Mutante untersucht. Dies umfasste die Beantwortung der Frage, ob auch die PLAT1-115 W75G Calcium bindet, sowie die Aufnahme eines Circulardichroismus-(CD)-Spektrums. Der erste Aspekt konnte mit mehreren Methoden bestätigt werden. Eine Calciumzugabe zum Laufpuffer 20 mM MOPS, 50 mM KCl pH 7,4 erhöhte konzentrationsabhängig das Elutionsvolumen der PLAT1-115 W75G auf der analytischen Gelfiltrationssäule – vermutlich durch den bekannten Einfluss von Calcium auf die Hydrophobizität der PLAT-Domäne. Zusätzlich wurde die Interaktion durch differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF) und Oberflächen-Plasmonen-Resonanz-Spektroskopie (SPR) nachgewiesen. Allerdings gelang aus verschiedenen Gründen keine Quantifizierung der Bindungsaffinität. Das CD-Spektrum bestätigte die Struktur der PLAT-Domäne als sogenanntes all-beta_protein und ermöglichte die Einordnung der PLAT1-115 W75G in die Gruppe der betaII-Proteine.
Ein weiterer Fokus dieser Arbeit lag auf der vermuteten allosterischen Fettsäurebindungsstelle in der PLAT-Domäne. Es wurde versucht, die Interaktion mittels SPR nachzuweisen. Zur Vorbereitung wurde im 5-LOX-Aktivitätstest und im DSF an der isolierten Domäne ein Detergens bestimmt, das einen möglichst geringen Einfluss auf das Protein ausübt. Dabei zeigte Octyl-beta-D-glucopyranosid (beta-OG) das vorteilhafteste Profil. Auf dieser Basis wurde die kritische Mizellbildungs-Konzentration (CMC) der AA und einiger HETEs in beta-OG-haltigen Puffern bestimmt. Die SPR-Studien ergaben jedoch keine reproduzierbaren Ergebnisse. In einem weiteren Schritt wurden die Substrathemmung des Gesamtproteins 5-LOX und der Einfluss von Calcium charakterisiert. Sowohl in Gegenwart von ~ 1 mM freiem Calcium als auch von 1 mM EDTA lag mit 20 µM AA die höchste Produktbildung nach 10-minütiger Reaktion vor. Das Detergens Tween20 (T20) hob in einer Konzentration unter seiner CMC (0,001 % m/V) in Anwesenheit von Calcium die Inhibition auf. Ohne Calcium zeigte sich auch in Gegenwart von T20 die bekannte Substratinhibition der 5-LOX einschließlich ihrer Maximalaktivität bei 20 µM AA. Diese Ergebnisse deuten darauf hin, dass Calcium eine Bindung der 5-LOX an eventuell vorhandene, negativ geladene Vesikel aus AA und Detergens vermitteln und dadurch die Substratinhibition aufheben kann. In Fällen, in denen die Substratinhibition vor dem Erreichen der AA-CMC auftritt, hat Calcium folglich keinen Einfluss.
Zuletzt wurde die Interaktion der PLAT1–115 W75G mit CLP und einem C-terminalen Fragment von Dicer untersucht. Im Crosslinking ließ sich nicht auf eine Interaktion der isolierten PLAT-Domäne mit CLP schließen. Dagegen ergaben Diamid-Crosslinking-Studien, dass die isolierte PLAT-Domäne in der Lage ist, das Dicer-Fragment zu binden. Dieses Ergebnis wurde im SPR bestätigt.
Ribosomes are the central cellular assembly lines for protein synthesis. To cope with the translational needs, a proliferating mammalian cell can produce up to 7500-ribosomes per minute. However, under growth limiting conditions, such as nutrient depletion, ribosome synthesis is rapidly shut down exemplifying the importance of a tight coordination between ribosome supply and cellular energy status. In addition to the quantitative regulation, a strict quality control of ribosome synthesis is equally important, because alterations in the composition or function of ribosomes can lead to a variety of pathologies. To cope with these challenges a highly regulated, multi-step pathway of ribosome biogenesis has evolved. In mammals this pathway generates the mature 80S ribosomes that comprise the large 60S and the small 40S subunits. Together they contain around 80 ribosomal proteins and the 28S, 18S, 5.8S and 5S rRNAs. The 28S, 5.8S and 5S rRNAs are assembled into the large subunit, while the 18S rRNA is part of the small subunit. The pathway of ribosome biogenesis is a multi-step cellular process, where specific stages occur in distinct subcellular compartments. Transcription of the 47S rRNA, which is the precursor for the 28S, 18S and 5.8S species, occurs in the nucleolus. Modification of distinct bases and early processing of this precursor also take place in the nucleolus. Subsequently, the 40S and 60S pre-ribosomes take separate maturation routes through the nucleoplasm before their export and final assembly in the cytoplasm. The various stages of preribosomal maturation require the constant and sequential action of a large number of non-ribosomal proteins, known as trans-acting factors. These factors coordinate the delicate remodeling of the pre-ribosomal intermediates and thereby ensure proper progression of the maturation process. The remodeling events largely depend on the dynamics of post-translational modifications, such as phosphorylation or SUMOylation. This requires that the enzymes controlling these modifications are properly targeted to their sites of activity as they fulfill their functions within specific compartments. Here we studied the regulatory principles that govern the subcellular partitioning of the SUMO-specific isopeptidase SENP3 and its associated factor PELP1. Previous work from our laboratory has delineated the importance of the SUMO system for proper ribosome biogenesis in mammalian cells. In particular, we have shown that SENP3 is critically involved in 28S rRNA formation, which is a key step for pre-60S subunit maturation. A critical involvement of SENP3 at this stage of the maturation process is in agreement with the observed enrichment of SENP3 in the nucleolus, since 28S rRNA processing is considered to occur in the nucleolus. Our subsequent work identified the nucleolar scaffold protein NPM1 and the ribosomal trans-acting factor PELP1 as bona fide substrates of SENP3. For both proteins we could demonstrate modification by SUMO2/3 and define SENP3 as the demodifying enzyme. Depletion of SENP3 enhanced the conjugation of SUMO to both proteins and concomitantly reduced conversion of the 32S pre-rRNA to the mature 28S rRNA. PELP1 is part of a larger protein complex consisting of the core components PELP1, TEX10 and WDR18. We could show that the balanced SUMOylation/deSUMOylation of PELP1 controls the nucleolar/nucleoplasmic distribution of this complex. Enhanced SUMOylation, which is observed in the absence of SENP3, triggers the nucleolar release of the complex suggesting that SENP3-mediated deSUMOylation controls the dynamics of nucleolar trans-acting factors. Based on these findings we first wanted to understand, in which cellular compartment(s) SENP3 exerts its function on 28S maturation. Next, we wanted to tackle the question how the subcellular distribution of SENP3 is controlled. Finally
we addressed the question how the SUMOylation of PELP1 determines the subnuclear distribution of the PELP1 complex. This work initially revealed that the nucleolar localization of SENP3 is crucial for proper 28S rRNA formation and 60S ribosome maturation. Importantly, we could demonstrate that the nucleolar compartmentalization of SENP3 depends on its direct physical interaction with NPM1. Further, we could show that the amino-terminal region of SENP3 is necessary for its binding to NPM1 and nucleolar recruitment. Strikingly, this interaction requires the phosphorylation of SENP3, which is brought about by the mTOR kinase. By in-vitro kinase assays and mass-spectrometric approaches we identified five serine/threonine residues within the amino-terminal region of SENP3 that are targeted by mTOR (S/T 25, 26, 141, 142, 143). We could further demonstrate by mutagenesis that these sites in SENP3 are in fact critical for the phospho-dependent binding of SENP3 to NPM1 and its nucleolar recruitment.
Consistent with these data, we found that chemical inhibitors of the mTOR kinase trigger the nucleolar release of SENP3 and impair its interaction with NPM1. Strikingly, this goes along with severe 28S rRNA maturation defects demonstrating the physiological importance of mTOR signaling in the regulation SENP3 function and rRNA processing. By specifically depleting components of the either mTORC1 or mTORC2, we could attribute the observed effects to signaling by mTORC1 rather than mTORC2. In an attempt to find the negative regulators of SENP3 phosphorylation, we identified PP1-γ as the candidate phosphatase in this pathway. We found a strong physical interaction of SENP3 with PP1-γ and observed a loss of SENP3 nucleolar localization upon ectopic expression of PP1-γ. Thus we could define mTOR/PP1-γ mediated phosphorylation/dephosphorylation of SENP3 as an important
mechanism in the control of ribosome maturation. Given that mTOR activity is controlled by nutrient availability, SENP3 functions as a sensor that couples ribosome synthesis with nutrient availability. The second part of this work delineated the role of SUMOylated PELP1 in nucleoplasmic partitioning of the SENP3-PELP1 complex. It was revealed that the AAA-ATPase MDN1 binds preferentially to SUMO modified PELP1 and likely segregates SUMOylated PELP1 from nucleolar pre-60S particles. We initially found that the PELP1 complex associates with MDN1, a factor known to be involved in the 28S rRNA maturation. Notably, depletion of MDN1 led to an enhanced accumulation of the PELP1 complex in the nucleolus and a strong association of PELP1 with pre-60S particles, suggesting that MDN1 is required for the release of this complex from the pre-ribosomes. Intriguingly, the interaction of PELP1 with MDN1 requires SUMO2/3 and SUMOylated PELP1 shows enhanced binding to MDN1 when compared to unmodified PELP1. Taken together this work provides new insights in the control of the SENP3-PELP1 complex dynamics. We could define several layers for the coordinated spatial regulation of SENP3 and the PELP1 complex. This work therefore underscores the crucial importance of dynamic post-translational modifications for the control of ribosome maturation.
Resistance in glucocorticoid-induced apoptosis is associated with poor prognosis for long term survival in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). As Smac mimetics have been shown to reactivate apoptosis by antagonizing Inhibitor of Apoptosis (IAP) proteins, we investigate the potential of the Smac mimetic BV6 to overcome glucocorticoid-resistance in ALL. This study shows that BV6 synergistically cooperates with glucocorticoids to trigger apoptosis and to suppress clonogenic growth of pediatric ALL cells. Of note, the BV6/glucocorticoid combination treatment also induces cell death in cells having defects in the apoptotic signaling cascade by inducing a switch from apoptotic to necroptotic cell death. The clinical relevance of our novel combination treatment is underscored by parallel experiments in primary pediatric ALL samples, in which glucocorticoids and BV6 act together to induce cell death in a synergistic manner. Importantly, the addition of BV6 enhances the anti-leukemic effects of glucocorticoids in an in vivo mouse model of pediatric ALL without causing substantial side effects, highlighting the potency of a BV6/glucocorticoid combination treatment. In contrast, BV6 does not increase cytotoxicity of glucocorticoids against several non-malignant cell types of the lympho-hematopoietic system. Furthermore, we have identified the novel underlying mechanism of BV6/glucocorticoid-induced apoptosis by showing that BV6 and glucocorticoids synergistically act together to promote assembly of the ripoptosome, a RIP1/FADD/caspase-8-containing cell death complex. Ripoptosome assembly is critically required for BV6/Dexamethasone-induced cell death, since genetic silencing of its members, i.e. RIP1, reduces ROS production, caspase activation and most importantly cell death induction. BV6/glucocorticoid combination treatment promotes ripoptosome assembly by inhibition of both of its negative regulators, IAP proteins and cFLIP. Thus, we identify that BV6 and glucocorticoids cooperate together to reduce cIAP1, cIAP2 and XIAP protein levels and cFLIP expression. Ripoptosome formation occurs independently of autocrine/paracrine loops of death receptor ligands, since blocking antibodies for TNFα, TRAIL or CD95L or genetic silencing of their corresponding receptors fail to rescue BV6/glucocorticoid-induced cell death. In summary, this study shows that the Smac mimetic BV6 sensitizes for glucocorticoid-induced apoptosis by promoting ripoptosome assembly with important implications for the treatment of childhood ALL.
Small molecule inhibitors sensitize neuroblastoma cells for chemotherapeutic drug-induced apoptosis
(2015)
Neuroblastoma (NB) is one of the most common solid extracranial pediatric tumors, deriving from undifferentiated cells of the peripheral nervous system. It accounts for approximately 10% of all childhood cancers. High stage tumors usually show poor prognosis despite aggressive treatment such as radiotherapy or chemotherapy. Therefore, it is of utmost importance to find novel treatment strategies in order to improve existing chemotherapy protocols. Combination treatment offers advantages, as chemotherapeutic drugs can be applied in low and subtoxic doses, reducing possible side-effects. Here, we report in a two-part study that small molecule inhibitors (SMI), namely BI 2536, a PLK1 inhibitor and BV6, a SMAC mimetic (SM), sensitize neuroblastoma cells for chemotherapeutic drug-induced cell death. By using i) BI 2536 in combination with vinca alkaloids and ii) BV6 in combination with either doxorubicin or vinca alkaloids, we show that cell death is synergistically enhanced compared to monotherapy. Furthermore, combination treatment significantly reduces survival of NB cells in long-term assays, compared to single treatment. We identify that vinca alkaloid/SMI combinations induce mitotic arrest, as shown by phosphorylation of histone H3, which results in the induction of intrinsic apoptosis and inhibition of CDK1 by RO-3306 could abolish these findings. Mechanistically, upon vinca alkaloid/SMI-induced mitotic arrest, anti-apoptotic BCL-2 proteins such as MCL-1, BCL-2 or BCL-XL are degraded or inactivated by phosphorylation, which induces the activation of the proapoptotic BCL-2 family proteins BAX and BAK. The importance of the mitochondrial apoptosis pathway in vinca alkaloid/SMI-induced cell death was further highlighted by the fact that ectopic expression of BCL-2 inhibits vinca alkaloid/SMI-induced DNA fragmentation and BAK- and caspase-activation. In contrast to the vinca alkaloid/SMI cotreatment, DOX/SMI (DOX/BV6)-induced apoptosis only partially involves the mitochondrial pathway. Instead, we clarify that RIP1 is required for DOX/BV6-induced apoptosis, as pharmacological and genetic inhibition of RIP1 rescues from apoptosis induction. Although it has been shown in previous studies that SM-treatment (e.g. BV6) can induce the NF-κB pathway and auto-/paracrine TNFα production through cIAP1/2 depletion, DOX/BV6-induced apoptosis is completely independent of NF-κB activation in our setting, despite fast cIAP1 depletion. This conclusion is based on the fact that inhibition of the NF-κB pathway by exogenously expressed dominant-negative IκBα as well as application of a TNFα blocking antibody does not reduce DOX/BV6-induced cell death. In summary, we unravel two new promising treatment strategies for neuroblastoma patients by using a combination treatment of two different small molecule inhibitors, combined with well-characterized chemotherapeutic agents. Furthermore we give detailed insights into cell death pathways induced by these combination treatments, in which mitochondria and RIP1 have a differential role in chemotherapeutic drug-induced apoptosis.
Structural characterization of stressosome complexes by single-particle cryo-electron microscopy
(2015)
The stressosome is a Mega Dalton macromolecular complex involved in stress adaptation in bacteria. Stressosomes are considered as stress signaling hubs. They are able to perceive a variety of different stress stimuli and transduce them into one single cellular answer, which is the initialization of a transcriptional up-regulation of hundreds of different genes encoding for universal but also very specific stress response proteins.
The stressosome of Bacillus subtilis became a prime example for this intriguing stress-triggered transcriptional regulation when its architecture was determined by Single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) in 2008. In Gram-positive Bacillus species, the stressosome complex senses changes in salt concentration, ethanol content, blue-light, heat or acid stress contributing to the general stress response by activation of the alternative σB factor. σB is a transcriptional promoter that initiates the transcription of over 150 general stress genes, e.g., genes that encode osmolyte transporters to counteract osmotic and chill stress. The B. subtilis stressosome (stressosome_Bc) is composed of multiple copies of the 3 proteins: RsbR, RsbS and RsbT. These three Rsb proteins (Regulator of Sigma B) are found clustered in one operon forming the conserved RST module. RsbS and RsbR are scaffold proteins comprising a STAS domain, respectively. Because these domains are dominantly associated to sulfate transporters and anti-sigma antagonist they were named STAS domains, however, they were also identified in other sensor proteins. In the stressosome they form the internal ball-shaped core, while the N-terminal globin-fold sensor domain of RsbR, protruding to the outside, facilitates stress sensing. It is assumed that the stress signal is transduced to the stressosome core via the STAS domain resulting in conformational changes of the core. These changes affect the binding of the third protein, RsbT, a serin-threonine kinase. As a direct consequence of stress sensing the RsbT kinase is released from the complex to start an activation cascade involving the stepwise activation of RsbU, V, W, and X, which are all part of the same operon, and finally of σB. In Bacillus species, several RsbR orthologs were identified varying mainly in the sequence of the N-terminal sensor domains. It is assumed that the stressosome_Bc assembles with a still unknown combination of RsbR orthologs allowing for the broad spectrum of stress stimuli that can be processed in vivo. The pathogenic bacteria Listeria monocytogenes is a close relative of Bacillus. Its potent stress response allows Listeria to survive the harsh environmental conditions during host infection and therefore the stress regulation machinery is contributing heavily to the virulence of this pathogen. In Listeria the Rsb operon is conserved and highly homologous to the Bacillus one. In the frame of this thesis, the in vitro assembly of Listeria innocua stressosomes was shown for the first time by Single-particle (SP) negative stain EM. Moreover, binding of Listeria RsbT to the assembled RsbR-RsbS complex was demonstrated biochemically.
Despite the conservation of the RST-module the entire Rsb operon is not conserved in the bacterial kingdom suggesting that signal transduction and regulation of gene expression might occur by very different mechanisms in stressosomes of different species. We have focused here on a stressosome type from the Gram-negative pathogen Vibrio vulnificus that is quite distinct from the Bacillus ones with respect to (1) the missing conservation of the Rsb operon, (2) the role of RsbT, (3) the activation of a different transcriptional promoter, and (4) the absence of additional RsbR orthologs. Interestingly, there is only one RsbR protein encoded in the genome. This one contains a Haem-group in its N-terminal domain being oxygen sensitive. It is assumed that the Vibrio stressosome perceive only oxidative stress and that regulation occurs via a diguanylate cyclase with a GAF domain that synthesizes the second messenger c-di-GMP from GTP.
We have started a structure determination of the Vibrio vulnificus stressosome by SP cryo-EM to elucidate the differences in the molecular mechanism of stress sensing in divers stressosome types. A 3D map of the oxidized (activated) Vibrio vulnificus stressosome was determined to 7.6 Å resolution revealing an increased flexibility of both the core and the N-terminal sensor domains in comparison to the Bacillus stressosome suggesting that our structure has trapped for the first time an active state of a stressosome complex. A 3D map of the stressosome core to 7 Å resolution allowed fitting of a homology model of the Vibrio stressosome based on the Bacillus stressosome as template. The conformational changes could be attributed to the entire core, which was confirmed by MD simulations.
Membrane proteins are biological macromolecules that are located in a cell’s membrane and are responsible for essential functions within an organism, which makes them to prominent drug targets. The extraction of membrane proteins from the hydrophobic membrane bilayer to determine high-resolution crystal structures is a difficult task and only 2% of all solved proteins structures are membrane proteins. Computational methods may help to gain deeper insights into membrane protein structures and their functions. This study will give an overview of such computational methods on a representative set of membrane proteins and will provide ideas for future computational and experimental research on membrane proteins.
In a first step (chapter 2), I updated an earlier, manually-curated data set of homologous membrane proteins (HOMEP) to more recent versions in 2010 (HOMEP2) and 2013 (HOMEP3) using an automated clustering approach. High-resolution structures of membrane proteins listed in the PDB_TM database were structurally aligned and subsequently clustered using structural similarity scores. Both data sets were used as a standard gold reference set for subsequent work.
Subsequently, I have updated and applied the sequence alignment program AlignMe to determine protein descriptors that are suitable for detecting evolutionary relationship between homologous a-helical membrane proteins. Single input descriptors were tested alone and in combination with each other in different modes of AlignMe by optimizing gap penalties on the HOMEP2 data set. Most accurate alignments and homology models on the HOMEP2 data set were observed when using position-specific substitution information (P), secondary structure propensities (S) and transmembrane propensities (T) in the AlignMe PST mode. An evaluation on an independent reference set of membrane protein sequence alignments from the BAliBASE collection showed that different modes of AlignMe are suitable for different sequence similarity levels. The AlignMe PST mode improved the alignment accuracy significantly for distantly related proteins, whereas for closely-related proteins from the BAliBASE set the AlignMe PS mode was more suitable. This work was published in March 2013 in PLOS ONE. In order to allow also an easier usage of the AlignMe program, I have implemented a web server of AlignMe (chapter 4) that provides the optimized settings and gap penalties for the AlignMe P, PS and PST modes. A comparison to other recent alignment web server shows that the alignments of AlignMe are similar or even more accurate than those of other methods, especially for very distantly related proteins for which the inclusion of membrane protein information has been shown to be suitable. This work was published in the NAR web server issue in July 2014.
Although membrane-specific information has been shown to be suitable for aligning distantly related membrane proteins on a sequence level, such information was not incorporated into structural alignment programs making it unclear which method is the most suitable for aligning membrane proteins. Thus, I compared 13 widely-used pairwise structural alignment methods on an updated reference set of homologous membrane protein structures (HOMEP3) and evaluated their accuracy by building models based on the underlying sequence alignments and used scoring functions (e.g., AL4 or CAD-score) to rate the model accuracy (chapter 5). The analysis showed that fragment-based approaches such as FR-TM-align are the most useful for aligning structures of membrane proteins that have undergone large conformational changes whereas rigid approaches were more suitable for proteins that were solved in the same or a similar state. However, no method showed a significant higher accuracy than any other. Additionally, all methods lack a measure to rate the reliability of the accuracy for a specific position within a structure alignment. In order to solve these problems, I propose a consensus-type approach that combines alignments from four different methods, namely FR-TM-align, DaliLite, MATT and FATCAT and assigns a confidence value to each position of the alignment that describes the agreement between the methods. This work has been published 2015 in the journal “PROTEINS: structure, function and bioinformatics”.
Consensus alignments were then generated for each pair of proteins of the HOMEP3 data set and subsequently analyzed for single evolutionary events within membrane spanning segments and for irregular structures (e.g., 310- and p-helices) (chapter 6). Interestingly, single insertions and deletions could be observed with the help of consensus alignments in the conserved membrane-spanning segments of membrane proteins in four protein families. The detection of such single InDels might help to identify crucial residues for a proteins function.
Necroptosis is a programmed cell death pathway that is implicated in a variety of human diseases. In recent years, increasing knowledge has been gained on the necroptotic signaling cascade. Nevertheless, the role of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in necroptosis is still ambiguous. In this study, we reveal that ROS critically regulate BV6/TNFα-induced necroptotic signaling in FADD-deficient Jurkat cells and in zVAD-treated MV4-11 cells. We show that several ROS scavengers such as butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA), N-acetylcysteine (NAC), α-tocopherol (αToc) and ethyl pyruvate (EP) significantly reduce ROS production and BV6/TNFα–induced cell death. Importantly, ROS are produced prior to cell death induction and promote the assembly of the Receptor-interacting protein kinase (RIP)1/RIP3 necrosome complex via a potential positive feedback loop since on the one hand radical scavengers diminish RIP1/RIP3 necrosome formation and since on the other hand RIP1 or RIP3 silencing attenuates ROS production. Furthermore, the deubiquitinase CYLD contributes to BV6/TNFα-induced ROS generation, necrosome assembly and cell death since CYLD knockdown attenuates all these events. Of note, knockdown of the downstream effector protein mixed lineage kinase domain like (MLKL) only partly reduces BV6/TNFα-triggered ROS production and cell death and does not affect necrosome formation. Contrary to expectations, the MLKL inhibitor Necrosulfonamide (NSA) not only decreases BV6/TNFα-stimulated ROS production and cell death but also attenuates RIP1/RIP3 necrosome assembly pointing to additional and MLKL-independent anti-necroptotic effects of NSA. Interestingly, silencing of the potential necroptotic excecutors mitochondrial proteins phosphoglycerate mutase family member 5 (PGAM5) or Dynamin-related protein 1 (Drp1) does not affect BV6/TNFα-induced cell death. Consistently, mitochondrial perturbations are not implicated in BV6/TNFα-induced cell death since mitochondrial membrane potential and respiration remain stable along with to BV6/TNFα-triggered necroptosis induction. Interference with the mitochondrial potential by depolarizing agents such as FCCP reduces BV6/TNFα-induced necroptosis indicating that proper mitochondrial function or a well-defined redox status is required for necroptotic cell death execution. This study demonstrates that ROS are critically involved in BV6/TNFα-induced necroptosis and thus provides novel insights into the redox regulation of necroptotic signaling.
During my thesis, I worked on two different membrane proteins. One is a bacterial secondary transporter and the second is a human mitochondrial calcium channel.
The first part of my thesis involves the structural and biochemical characterization of an L-carnitine/ γ-butyrobetaine antiporter from bacteria called CaiT. The aim of the project was to understand the Na+ independence of CaiT and to determine the crystal structures of CaiT in different conformations to expand the mechanistic understanding of substrate/ product antiport in CaiT.
The study revealed how a positively charged amino acid side chain (arginine 262) in CaiT could structurally and functionally mimic a sodium ion. Additionally, various crystal structures of CaiT obtained in this study demonstrate that the central substrate-binding site is highly dynamic and can accommodate the substrate in various orientations.
In the second part of my thesis, I was able to optimize the expression and purification conditions for the human mitochondrial calcium uniporter or the MCU. Understanding how this channel functions can help us unravel the mechanism of calcium uptake by mitochondria. Secondary structure prediction analysis in combination with mass spectrometry of degraded MCU products obtained during the purification of the full-length protein led to the identification of a stable MCU construct. This study resulted in the successful purification of milligram quantities of stable MCU protein for the first time. Further optimization may be required to obtain more homogenous protein that is amenable for crystallization.
Small molecule drug discovery is strongly supported by biophysical data. In the reach of this thesis, cell free protein expression was used to produce human target proteins for ligand binding assays using Surface Plasmon Resonance spectroscopy (SPR). In the second step the binding and interaction characteristics of small molecules and fragments were analyzed using Nuclear Magnetic Resonance spectroscopy (NMR).
The first target protein was the human acid sensing channel 1 (ASIC1a). ASIC1a was expressed in a cell free expression system based on E.coli lysate. To optimize the expression, several parameters including fusion tags, ion concentrations and different hydrophobic environments were tested.
The adaption of the folding environment for ASIC1a needed more optimization, because it is a very challenging target to express in an in vitro system. Three different expression modes were employed to find a suitable folding environment.
SPR binding studies with ASIC1a were performed with chicken ASIC1a expressed in insect cells. The immobilization of cASIC1a and the used buffer conditions were tested using Psalmotoxin 1, a naturally occurring peptide venom which binds strong to the trimeric form of ASIC1a. Compound characterization experiments were performed with a variety of different ligands including amiloride, a general blocker of the whole ENaC protein family. None of the used ligands showed titration curves that would match a simple 1:1 binding model. The experiments either show no binding signal or signal that could be interpreted as unspecific binding. Even amiloride that should be binding the protein shows no signals that fit a simple binding model.
Another target protein that was investigated is the soluble prolyl cis/trans isomerase Cyclophilin D (or peptidyl prolyl isomerase F – PPIF). This protein is involved in the regulation of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore and therefore a potential drug target to treat neurodegenerative diseases. Small molecule binding was tested with CypD using SPR. Following the kinetic analysis of small molecule ligands, the binding position of different binding fragments was analyzed. These fragments originated from a SPR based fragment screen and gave no co-crystal structures with CypD. Therefore NMR was used to investigate the binding position of these fragments. An analysis of the chemical shift perturbations upon ligand addition revealed that the NMR analysis was in line with the results gathered by x-ray crystallography. The fragments with unknown binding position however, all bind to a specific patch slightly outside the binding pocket.
The ligand CL1 showed a special behavior in the NMR experiments. Upon addition to CypD, it produced large shifts on many signals of the protein, accompanied by a severe line broadening. The shift perturbations were so numerous and large that the spectrum had to be reassigned in complex with the ligand. Triple selective labeling was applied to allow a fast and nearly complete signal assignment. The possibility to use highly sophisticated labeling schemes, is one of the advantages of cell free protein expression. After the assignment of the complex spectrum, the chemical shift perturbations were analyzed and quantified. The residues showing the strongest CSPs are also identified in the crystal structure to be involved in the binding of CL1, giving a consistent picture. The numerous and large shift perturbations, produced by CL1 led to the assumption, that the ligand induces a conformational change in CypD, which is not represented in the co-crystal structure. This conformational change was characterized by a NMR based structure determination. CypD apo yielded a defined bundle, whose folded regions overlap well with the corresponding crystal structure.
For the calculation of the CypD-CL1 complex structure, the sidechain resonances were assigned using an automated assignment approach with the software FLYA. The calculation of the CypD-CL1 complex structure did not result in a defined bundle. While parts of the protein converge in a well folded state, the region around the active site shows no defined folding. Careful analysis of the structure calculation suggests that the problems during structure calculation did not originate from an incorrect resonance assignment, but rather from a lack of NOE crosspeaks. This might be due to a broadening of the corresponding NOE crosspeaks or the coexistence of many different conformations. This leads to the conclusion, that the protein conformation is not defined by the NMR data and could be in a dynamic interchange between multiple structures.
This hypothesis is supported by other observations. The line broadening of the signals in the complex is pronounced in the area around the active site and the substrate binding pocket, hinting to a connection between catalytic activity and protein dynamics. In addition many NMR signals are sensitive to changes in the measurement field strength and the temperature. This field dependent signal splitting suggests dynamic conformational changes in the protein between at least two different conformations on a millisecond timescale.
The current working model is that CL1 binds to CypD and induces the catalytic cycle and the connected conformational changes in CypD. As a result the proline like moiety in CL1 is constantly switching between the cis and the trans conformation. Due to the high affinity of CL1, the inhibitor does not leave the binding pocket after successful catalysis, but stays bound in the pocket stimulating further catalytic cycles. These findings as well as the working model are well in line with data published for Cyclophilin A, another member of the cyclophilin family, thereby supporting the model.