Refine
Year of publication
- 2010 (2) (remove)
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (1)
- magisterthesis (1)
Has Fulltext
- yes (2)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (2)
Institute
- Extern (1)
- Katholische Theologie (1)
In this retrospective study, case records of clinical forensic examinations and respective investigation records of the police and the public prosecutor’s (state attorney) office along with the resulting verdicts were examined in terms of type and site of injury found and extent of agreement or discrepancy between the story given by the accused party and the medical conclusions drawn from the injury pattern. Particular attention was focussed on the relevance of the expert opinion for the legal assessment through case-specific analysis of the respective verdicts. A total of 118 cases originating from the scope of the Institute of Forensic Medicine, Goethe-University Frankfurt/Main (2002 – 2005) were examined. These included bodily injury, child abuse, sexual compulsion, self-mutilation and injury patterns of individuals under suspicion of attempted or completed manslaughter/homicide. As compared to former studies, the results of this analysis were additionally correlated with the investigation records of the public prosecutor’s office (state attorney) to elucidate the importance of the forensic findings for police investigation and legal evaluation. The forensic examination involved 19 accused and 99 victims. As for the gender distribution of the victims, 51 females and 48 males were encountered. Slight female preponderance was seen in cases of sexual compulsion. The group of accused individuals consisted of 16 males and 3 females. Injuries due to blunt force impact, in particular hematomas involving skull and trunk, dominated as diagnostic findings in cases of bodily injury, sexual offenses and child abuse. In cases with suspected self-mutilation and in examinations of accused perpetrators of manslaughter/homicide scratches and lacerations prevailed. Correlating injury patterns and police inquiries, conclusions drawn from medical findings and results of police investigations were in good agreement in 46 % of the cases, but showed major discrepancies in another 25 %. In the remaining 29 % of the cases, the injury pattern did not allow for a definite expert opinion on the mode of infliction. Nevertheless, a detailed documentation of the medical findings proved to be of substantial value for police investigations. 39 % of the cases resulted in a final verdict, whilst in 59 % of the cases the charge was dismissed. Especially in the ladder forensic expert opinion was of considerable importance, since forensic assessment of injuries could either not be attributed to a certain perpetrator or contributed to the exoneration of the accused. In 2 % the judicial assessment was not available. In 82 % of the cases of child abuse the proceedings were stopped, e.g. since maltreatment could not be assigned to a particular perpetrator. In these cases, it became obvious, that forensic examination and assessment alone does not suffice, but has to be embedded in police investigations to achieve optimal results. Medical conclusions by forensic experts were – almost without any exception – considered in legal assessment and differentiatedly taken into account when weighing the sentence, thus reflecting the objectivity and neutrality of the medical assessment. In synopsis, albeit evidential value of forensic examination is assessed to be high optimal clarification of a case requires integration into the complete spectrum of investigations performed in a case.