Doctoral Thesis
Refine
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (5) (remove)
Language
- English (5) (remove)
Has Fulltext
- yes (5)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (5)
Keywords
Institute
Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) are rare but fatal neurodegenerative diseases affecting human and animals. The prion protein which is the causative agent, according to “protein-only” hypothesis misfold in to rogue amyloid conformer. Despite several years of studies, the atomic structural details of the rogue conformers have not been clearly understood. This study focused on developing an in-vitro conversion method, which allows us to monitor the transition from unfolded state of prion protein to fibril state. In order to reach maximal unfolded state, we have used 8 M urea as chemical denaturant, pH 2 and prion fragment 90-230 as the model. It has been demonstrated earlier that acidic pH and mild denaturant induce the fibril formation. The mechanism underlying the structural transition from monomeric state to polymeric form is largely unknown. We have confirmed by EM and AFM that fibrils are formed in our conditions, which resemble to naturally occurring fibrils in morphologies observed. The agitation accelerates the rate of fibril formation and, which allow us to do time-resolved NMR on these preparations. The conformational flexibility is inherent to amyloid fibrils and has been observed in our preparations. We aimed to map the important segment of prion protein, which forms the rigid core in its fibrillar structured form. Our time-resolved NMR studies allowed us to monitor the changes happening from unfolded state to fibrillar state. Analysis of data identified the segment between residues 145 to 223 forming the rigid core in these fibrils, which correspond to β strand 2, helix 2 and major part of helix 3 of native prion monomeric structure. Most of the point mutations which are associated with hereditary prion disease are part of rigid core, which undergo a refolding on fibril formation. The C-terminal residues from 224 to 230 displayed peak shifting and therefore, indicate the adaptation to a fibril specific conformation. The major part of N-terminal 90-144 segment, remains dynamic, which can be understood by their accessibility to amyloid specific antibodies. This provides novel structural insight to the amyloid formation from unfolded state of prion protein fragment 90-230, which represents the proteinase-K resistant part naturally occurring prions. Earlier studies have established the core to 160-220 where hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry or site-directed spin labeling EPR spectroscopy was used for analysis. Those studies have been initiated from either native-like or partially unfolded state of recombinant prion protein, and therefore, it is quite striking to find out that fibrils initiated from unfolded monomeric state share the same “amyloid core”. This structural insight has important implications for understanding the molecular basis of prion propagation.
This thesis describes the structural characterization of interactions between biological relevant ribonucleic acid biomacromolecules (RNAs) and selected ligands to optimize the methodologies for the design of pharmacological lead compounds. To achieve this aim, not only the structures of the RNA, the ligand and their complexes need to be known, but also information about the inherent dynamics, especially of the target RNA, are necessary. To determine the structure and dynamics of these molecules and their complexes, liquid state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) is a suitable and powerful method. The necessity for these investigations arises from the lack of knowledge in RNA-ligand interactions, e.g. for the development of new medicinal drugs targeting crucial RNA sequences. In the first chapters of this thesis (Chapters II to IV), an introduction into RNA research is given with a focus on RNA structural features (Chapter II), into the interacting molecules, the biology of the specific RNA targets and the further development of their ligands (Chapter III) and into the NMR theory and methodologies used within this thesis (Chapter IV). Chapter II begins with a description of RNA characteristics and functions, placing the focus on the increasing attention that these biomacromolecules have attracted in recent years due to their diverse biological functionalities. This is followed by a detailed description of general structural features of RNA molecules. The biological functions of the RNAs investigated in this thesis (Human immunodeficiency virus PSI- and TAR-RNA and Coxsackievirus B3 Stemloop D in the 5’-cloverleaf element), together with their known structural characteristics are introduced in Chapter III. Furthermore, a description of the investigated ligands is given, focusing on the methods how their affinity and specificity were determined. The introduction is completed in Chapter IV, where the relevant NMR theory and methodologies are explained. First, kinetics and thermodynamics of ligand binding are summarized from an NMR point of view. Subsequently, a detailed description of the resonance assignment procedures for RNAs and peptidic ligands is given. This procedure mainly concentrates on the assignment of the proton resonances, which are essential for the later structure calculation from NMR restraints. The procedure for NMR structure calculation of RNA and its complexes follows with a short introduction into the programs ARIA and HADDOCK. The final part of this chapter explains the relaxation theory and the methodology to extract dynamic information from autocorrelated relaxation rates via the model-free formalism. In the Chapters V to VII of this thesis, the original publications are included and grouped into three topics. Chapter V comprehends the publications on the investigations of HIV PSI-RNA and its hexapeptidic ligand. These three publications[1-3] focus on the characterization of the ligand and its binding properties, its structure and the optimization of its composition aiming to improve its usage for further spectroscopic investigations.
The focus of this thesis has been to further advance and develop existing NMR techniques for the study of protein folding. In order to do so, experimental as well as theoretical approaches have been pursued. From the theoretical side, a successful attempt to the development of a general theory for the treatment of residual dipolar couplings in the case of unfolded proteins has been undertaken. Information contained in residual dipolar couplings is especially valuable due to its long-range nature. The dynamic character of unfolded states of proteins, which may be composed of distinct subsets of conformations, renders reliable interpretation of data a non-trivial task. Statistical-coil-based approaches have been shown to be powerful in data interpretation. A consistent theory based on fundamental polymer physics, however, had not been presented so far. The herein presented model addresses this problem building on the original work by Annila and co-workers. In this work, several shortcomings have been identified. These shortcomings have been corrected here leading to a general approach for the treatment of residual dipolar couplings of unfolded proteins. More specifically, it is shown that, in the case of fully unfolded proteins aligned by a steric mechanism, basic dependencies of dipolar couplings such as on chain length and location with in the chain can be analysed in simple analytical terms. The main predictions of the model are compared to experimental data showing reasonable agreement. The presented mathematical framework is principally suited for various improvements which could include the treatment of long-range interactions and of the actual geometry of the given aligment medium. From the experimental side, bovine alpha-lactalbumin has been chosen as a model system for the development of improved time-resolved 1D NMR methods aiming at the observation of conformational transitions by kinetic means. The presented results show that high-quality data can now be obtained at protein concentrations as low as 100uM. Rate constants characterising distinct conformational transitions of up to 8/s have been measured. These are the fastest rate constants which have been reported so far for protein folding events. The NMR data supplemented by complementary biophysical data furthermore demonstrate that the folding of bovine alpha-lactalbumin is more complex than has been anticipated. All data are consistent with a triangular folding mechanism involving parallel pathways of folding for formation of the native state of the protein. Interestingly, such a folding mechanism has also been found for the highly structurally homologous protein lysoyzme from hen egg white. Evidence is presented that the guiding role of long-range interactions in the unfolded state of lysoyzme for mediating intersubdomain interactions during folding is replaced in the case of bovine alpha-lactalbumin by the Ca2+ binding site.
The formation and maintenance of a defined three-dimensional structure is a prerequisite for most proteins in order to fulfill their function in the native context. However, there are proteins, which are intrinsically unstructured and thus natively unfolded. In addition, the misfolding and aggregation of many proteins can lead to severe diseases. The investigation of non-native states of proteins significantly contributes to the understanding of protein folding and misfolding. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is the only known technique that can provide information on structure and dynamics of non-native states of proteins at atomic resolution. Unfolded and non-native states of proteins have to be treated as ensembles of rapidly interconverting conformers and their observed properties are ensemble and time averaged. In this thesis, hen egg white lysozyme (HEWL) and mutants thereof have been investigated by NMR spectroscopy. The reduction of its four disulfide bridges and the successive methylation of the cysteine residues renders HEWL permanently non-native (‘HEWL-SMe’). Alternatively, the exchange of the eight cysteines for alanines results in very similar states (‘all-Ala-HEWL’). Under these conditions, HEWL-SMe and all-Ala-HEWL do not resemble random coil conformations, but exhibit residual secondary and tertiary structure. The presence of hydrophobic clusters and long-range interactions around the proteins six tryptophan residues and the modulation of these properties by single-point mutants has been observed. For the NMR spectroscopic investigation, HEWL has been isotopically labelled in E. coli by expression into inclusion bodies. After purification, the 1HN, 15NH, 13Calpha, 13Cbeta, 13C’, 1Halpha and 1Hbeta resonances of HEWL-SMe and all-Ala-HEWL have been assigned almost completely using three-dimensional NMR experiments. The analysis of secondary chemical shifts revealed regions in the proteins sequence — particularly around the six tryptophan residues—with significantly populated alpha-helix like conformations. In order to further elucidate the influence of the tryptophan side chains, a set of two new pulse sequences has been developed that allowed for the successful assignment of the 13Cg, 15Ne and 1HNe resonances in these side chains. This knowledge was eventually exploited in the interpretation of two-dimensional 15N-1H photo-CIDNP spectra, which revealed a differential solvent accessibility of the tryptophan residues in all-Ala-HEWL but not in the single point mutant W62G-all-Ala-HEWL. In addition, heteronuclear R2 relaxation rates have been determined for the indole 15Ne nuclei of all-Ala-HEWL and W62G. While in the wild-type like all-Ala-HEWL, the rates are different among the six tryptophan residues, in W62G they are more uniform. Together with relaxation data from the amide backbone, these results indicate the significant destabilization of the hydrophobic clusters in the absence of W62. In contrast, in the W108G mutant the profile of the R2 relaxation rates was not found to be significantly altered. No evidence was found by R1rho relaxation rates and relaxation dispersion measurements for conformational exchange on slower (micro- to millisecond) timescales. Residual dipolar couplings have been determined for non-native HEWL in order to retrieve structural information of these states. The differences of the W62G and the wild-type like non-native HEWL is also picked up in NH-RDCs of these proteins aligned in polyacrylamide gels. Significant positive RDCs are observed in the regions of the hydrophobic clusters in all-Ala-HEWL, but to a much lesser degree in W62G. So far, all attempts to simulate RDCs from generated non-native ensembles failed even when including long-range contacts or specific phi/psi backbone angle propensities. However, the measured RDCs can be used to cross-validate structural ensembles of non-native HEWL generated by molecular dynamics simulations that are based on restraints from the other experimental data, such as the differential solvent accessibilities from the photo-CIDNP experiments and the data on the hydrophobic clustering gained from the combined mutational and relaxation studies. Finally, non-native HEWL has been investigated for the first time using two-dimensional NMR in organic solvents, which are able to induce secondary structures and ultimately lead to amyloid formation. Under these conditions severe line broadening was observed, which was attributed to exchange between different — mostly a-helical— conformations. In summary, in this thesis methods have been developed, optimized and successfully applied for the structural and dynamical characterization of non-native states of proteins and the effect of single-point mutants on the properties of such ensembles has been investigated. Data has been gained that can considerably contribute to the further elucidation of the nature of non-native states of HEWL by molecular dynamics simulations.
The following thesis is concerned with the elucidation of structural changes of RNA molecules during the time course of dynamic processes that are commonly denoted as folding reactions. In contrast to the field of protein folding, the concept of RNA folding comprises not only folding reactions itself but also refolding- or conformational switching- and assembly processes (see chapter III). The method in this thesis to monitor these diverse processes is high resolution liquid-state NMR spectroscopy. To understand the reactions is of considerable interest, because most biological active RNA molecules function by changing their conformation. This can be either an intrinsic property of their respective sequence or may happen in response to a cellular signal such as small molecular ligand binding (like in the aptamer and riboswitch case), protein or metal binding. The first part of the thesis (chapters II & III) provides a general overview over the field of RNA structure and RNA folding. The two chapters aim at introducing the reader into the current status of research in the field. Chapters II is structured such that primary structure is first described then secondary and tertiary structure elements of RNA structure. A special emphasis is given to bistable RNA systems that are functionally important and represent models to understand fundamental questions of RNA conformational switching. RNA folding in vitro as well as in vivo situations is discussed in Chapter III. The following chapters IV and V also belong to the introduction part and review critically the NMR methods that were used to understand the nature and the dynamics of the conformational/structural transitions in RNA. A general overview of NMR methods quantifying dynamics of biomolecules is provided in chapter IV. A detailed discussion of solvent exchange rates and time-resolved NMR, as the two major techniques used, follows. In the final chapter V of the first part the NMR parameters used in structure calculation and structure calculation itself are conferred. The second part of the thesis, which is the cumulative part, encompasses the conducted original work. Chapter VI reviews the general NMR techniques applied and explains their applicability in the field of RNA structural and biochemical studies in several model cases. Chapter VII describes the achievement of a complete resonance assignment of an RNA model molecule (14mer cUUCGg tetral-loop RNA) and introduces a new technique to assign quaternary carbon resonances of the nucleobases. Furthermore, it reports on a conformational analysis of the sugar backbone in this RNA hairpin molecule in conjunction with a parameterization of 1J scalar couplings. Achievements: • Establishment of two new NMR pulse-sequences facilitating the assignment of quaternary carbons in RNA nucleobases • First complete (99.5%) NMR resonance assignment of an RNA molecule (14mer) including 1H, 13C, 15N, 31P resonances • Description of RNA backbone conformation by a complete set of NMR parameters • Description of the backbone conformational dependence in RNA of new NMR parameters (1J scalar couplings) Chapters VII & VIII summarize the real-NMR studies that were conducted to elucidate the conformational switching events of several RNA systems. Chapter VIII gives an overview on the experiments that were accomplished on three different bistable RNAs. These molecules where chosen to be good model systems for RNA refolding reactions and so consequently served as reporters of conformational switching events of RNA secondary structure elements. Achievements: • First kinetic studies of RNA refolding reactions with atomic resolution by NMR • Application of [new] RT-NMR techniques either regarding the photolytic initiation of the reaction or regarding the readout of the reaction • Discovery of different RNA refolding mechanisms for different RNA molecules Deciphering of a general rule for RNA refolding methodology to conformational switching processes of RNA tertiary structure elements. The models for these processes were a) the guanine-dependent riboswitch RNA and b) the minimal hammerhead ribozyme. Achievements: • NMR spectroscopic assignment of imino-resonances of the hypoxanthine bound guanine-dependent riboswitch RNA • Application of RT-NMR techniques to monitor the ligand induced conformational switch of the aptamer domain of the guanine-dependent riboswitch RNA at atomic resolution • Translation of kinetic information into structural information • Deciphering a folding mechanism for the guanine riboswitch aptamer domain • Application of RT-NMR techniques to monitor the reaction of the catalytically active mHHR RNA at atomic resolution In the appendices the new NMR pulse-sequences and the experimental parameters are described, which are not explicitly treated in the respective manuscripts.