Refine
Document Type
- Article (5)
- Doctoral Thesis (1)
Language
- English (6)
Has Fulltext
- yes (6)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (6)
Institute
Global analysis of halogenated trace gases in the UTLS: from long-lived to short-lived substances
(2023)
In this dissertation, the distribution of chlorinated and brominated substances in the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere is investigated. These substances contribute significantly to the catalytic decomposition of ozone and are involved in the recurrent formation of the polar ozone hole in the Antarctic winter and spring. The Montreal Protocol, a multilateral environmental treaty to protect the ozone layer, has successfully reduced emissions of long-lived chlorine- and bromine-containing substances. Short-lived chlorinated and brominated substances, some of which are natural and anthropogenic in origin, are not regulated by the Montreal Protocol and it can be assumed that their relative contribution to the stratospheric halogen budget will increase, while the contribution of long-lived compounds will steadily decrease. The distribution of long- and short-lived halogenated substances are part of current research. For the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere, the very short-lived substances are particularly important. The lower stratosphere needs special investigation in this respect, since its composition is influenced by different transport processes. The influences on ozone trends in the lower stratosphere are subject to great uncertainties. Especially in the Southern Hemisphere, the number of observations is very limited.
In this work, the GhOST (Gas chromatograph for Observational Studies using Tracers) instrument was used during the SouthTRAC measurement campaign on the German HALO (High Altitude and LOng range) research aircraft, providing observations of halogenated hydrocarbons in Antarctic late winter to early spring 2019, a generally poorly sampled region. The polar vortex was, compared to previous years, significantly weaker and shifted towards the eastern South Pacific and South America. From the airborne measurements of chlorinated source gases, inorganic chlorine (the sum of active chlorine and reservoir gases; Cly) could be inferred with the result that Cly within the vortex increased up to 1687 ± 19 ppt at 385 K potential temperature, accounting for about 50 % of the total chlorine within the vortex and only 15 % of the total chlorine in the southern mid-latitudes. A comparison with the Northern Hemisphere could be made using the PGS measurement campaign in the Arctic winter 2015/2016. Under comparable conditions (season and distance from the tropopause), only 40 % of the total chlorine was in the inorganic form within the Arctic polar vortex and about 20 % was found in the mid-latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere. In addition, about 540 ppt more Cly was present in the Antarctic vortex than in the Arctic vortex, exceeding the annual variations previously reported for Antarctica.
The mean age of air plays an essential role in the derivation of Cly via the organic source gases, as was done in this work. A new method for determining the mean age of air from observational data has been introduced that accounts for extra-tropical input to the stratosphere in addition to tropical input. This new method was compared with the previously used method, which considered only the tropical input. The new method shows more realistic values especially near the tropopause. On average, the air of the lower stratosphere in the Northern Hemisphere was older than in the Southern Hemisphere by about 0.5 ± 0.3 years. About 65 K above the tropopause, the pattern changed with older air in the mid-latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere, but older air in high latitudes of the Southern Hemisphere, which implies differences in the strength and isolation of the respective polar vortex as well as the wave forcing in the shallow branch of the Brewer-Dobson circulation of the respective hemisphere. This is in good agreement with the distribution of Cly. The difference in the lower stratosphere was not clearly evident with the old method and it can be assumed that investigations of the differences in Cly of Northern and Southern Hemisphere will benefit from the new method.
Finally, the global and seasonal distribution of the two most important representatives of the short-lived brominated substances, CH2Br2 and CHBr3, was investigated. For this purpose, two additional HALO measurement campaigns have been used, the 2012 TACTS measurement campaign and the 2017 WISE measurement campaign, as well as the HIAPER Pole-to-Pole Observations (HIPPO) and Atmospheric Tomography (ATom) measurement campaigns. Observations of CH2Br2 show a pronounced seasonality in the free and upper troposphere of both hemispheres with slightly larger values in the Northern Hemisphere. CHBr3, on the other hand, shows a generally higher variability and lower seasonality with larger mixing ratios at mid and high latitudes in the northern hemispheric winter and autumn. A comparison of the lower stratosphere is limited to autumn and spring of both hemispheres due to the limited data basis of the observations. The distributions in each spring are similar (less than 0.1 ppt differences for e.g., CH2Br2). In hemispheric autumn, larger differences are evident with substantially smaller mixing ratios in the southern hemispheric lower stratosphere. This suggests that the transport processes of the two hemispheres may be different and implies that the input of tropospheric air (flushing) to the Northern Hemisphere lowest stratosphere is more efficient than in the Southern Hemisphere. Vertical profiles of CH2Br2 and CHBr3 in the mid-latitudes of both hemispheres and resulting vertical gradients support this conjecture. However, the Southern Hemisphere data set is insufficient to quantify this difference and further measurements are needed.
In late 2013, a whole air flask collection programme was started at Taunus Observatory (TO) in central Germany. Being a rural site in close proximity to the Rhine–Main area, Taunus Observatory allows assessment of emissions from a densely populated region. Owing to its altitude of 825 m, the site also regularly experiences background conditions, especially when air masses approach from north-westerly directions. With a large footprint area mainly covering central Europe north of the Alps, halocarbon measurements at the site have the potential to improve the database for estimation of regional and total European halogenated greenhouse gas emissions. Flask samples are collected weekly for offline analysis using a GC/MS system simultaneously employing a quadrupole as well as a time-of-flight mass spectrometer. As background reference, additional samples are collected approximately once every 2 weeks at the Mace Head Atmospheric Research Station (MHD) when air masses approach from the site's clean air sector. Thus the time series at TO can be linked to the in situ AGAGE measurements and the NOAA flask sampling programme at MHD. An iterative baseline identification procedure separates polluted samples from baseline data. While there is good agreement of baseline mixing ratios between TO and MHD, with a larger variability of mixing ratios at the continental site, measurements at TO are regularly influenced by elevated halocarbon mixing ratios. Here, first time series are presented for CFC-11, CFC-12, HCFC-22, HFC-134a, HFC-227ea, HFC-245fa, and dichloromethane. While atmospheric mixing ratios of the chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) decrease, they increase for the hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) and the hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs). Small unexpected differences between CFC-11 and CFC-12 are found with regard to frequency and relative enhancement of high mixing ratio events and seasonality, although production and use of both compounds are strictly regulated by the Montreal Protocol, and therefore a similar decrease in atmospheric mixing ratios should occur. Dichloromethane, a solvent about which recently concerns have been raised regarding its growing influence on stratospheric ozone depletion, does not show a significant trend with regard to both baseline mixing ratios and the occurrence of pollution events at Taunus Observatory for the time period covered, indicating stable emissions in the regions that influence the site. An analysis of trajectories from the Hybrid Single Particle Lagrangian Integrated Trajectory (HYSPLIT) model reveals differences in halocarbon mixing ranges depending on air mass origin.
In late 2013, a whole air flask collection program started at the Taunus Observatory (TO) in central Germany. Being a rural site in close vicinity to the densely populated Rhein-Main area, Taunus Observatory allows to assess local and regional emissions. Owed to its altitude of 825 m, the site also regularly experiences background conditions, especially when air masses approach from north-westerly directions. With a large footprint area mainly covering central Europe north of the Alps, halocarbon measurements at the site have the potential to improve the data base for estimation of regional and total European halogenated greenhouse gas emissions. Flask samples are collected weekly for offline analysis using a GC-MS system employing a quadrupole as well as a time-of-flight mass spectrometer. As background reference, additional samples are collected approximately bi-weekly at the Mace Head Atmospheric Research Station (MHD) when air masses approach from the site’s clean air sector. Thus the TO time series can be linked to the in-situ AGAGE measurements and the NOAA flask sampling program at MHD. An iterative baseline identification procedure separates polluted samples from baseline data. While there is good agreement of baseline mixing ratios between TO and MHD, with a larger variability of mixing ratios at the continental site, measurements at TO are regularly influenced by elevated halocarbon mixing ratios. Here, first time series are presented for CFC-11, CFC-12, HCFC-22, HFC-134a, HFC-227ea, HFC-245fa, and dichloromethane. While atmospheric mixing ratios of the CFCs decrease, they increase for the HCFC and the HFCs. Small unexpected differences between CFC-11 and CFC-12 are found with regard to the occurrence of high mixing ratio events and seasonality, although production and use of both compounds are strictly regulated by the Montreal Protocol, and therefore a similar decrease of atmospheric mixing ratios should occur. Dichloromethane, a solvent about which recently concerns have risen regarding its growing influence on stratospheric ozone depletion, does not show a significant trend with regard to both, baseline mixing ratios and the occurrence of pollution events at Taunus Observatory for the time period covered, indicating stable emissions in the regions that influence the site. An analysis of HYSPLIT trajectories reveals differences in halocarbon mixing ranges depending on air mass origin.
Stratospheric inorganic chlorine (Cly) is predominantly released from long-lived chlorinated source gases and, to a small extent, very short-lived chlorinated substances. Cly includes the reservoir species (HCl and ClONO2) and active chlorine species (i.e., ClOx). The active chlorine species drive catalytic cycles that deplete ozone in the polar winter stratosphere. This work presents calculations of inorganic chlorine (Cly) derived from chlorinated source gas measurements on board the High Altitude and Long Range Research Aircraft (HALO) during the Southern Hemisphere Transport, Dynamic and Chemistry (SouthTRAC) campaign in austral late winter and early spring 2019. Results are compared to Cly in the Northern Hemisphere derived from measurements of the POLSTRACC-GW-LCYCLE-SALSA (PGS) campaign in the Arctic winter of 2015/2016. A scaled correlation was used for PGS data, since not all source gases were measured. Using the SouthTRAC data, Cly from a scaled correlation was compared to directly determined Cly and agreed well. An air mass classification based on in situ N2O measurements allocates the measurements to the vortex, the vortex boundary region, and midlatitudes. Although the Antarctic vortex was weakened in 2019 compared to previous years, Cly reached 1687±19 ppt at 385 K; therefore, up to around 50 % of total chlorine was found in inorganic form inside the Antarctic vortex, whereas only 15 % of total chlorine was found in inorganic form in the southern midlatitudes. In contrast, only 40 % of total chlorine was found in inorganic form in the Arctic vortex during PGS, and roughly 20 % was found in inorganic form in the northern midlatitudes. Differences inside the two vortices reach as much as 540 ppt, with more Cly in the Antarctic vortex in 2019 than in the Arctic vortex in 2016 (at comparable distance to the local tropopause). To our knowledge, this is the first comparison of inorganic chlorine within the Antarctic and Arctic polar vortices. Based on the results of these two campaigns, the differences in Cly inside the two vortices are substantial and larger than the inter-annual variations previously reported for the Antarctic.
Stratospheric inorganic chlorine (Cly) is predominantly released from long-lived chlorinated source gases and, to a small extent, very short-lived chlorinated substances. Cly includes the reservoir species (HCl and ClONO2) and active chlorine species (i.e., ClOx). The active chlorine species drive catalytic cycles that deplete ozone in the polar winter stratosphere. This work presents calculations of inorganic chlorine (Cly) derived from chlorinated source gas measurements on board the High Altitude and Long Range Research Aircraft (HALO) during the Southern Hemisphere Transport, Dynamic and Chemistry (SouthTRAC) campaign in austral late winter and early spring 2019. Results are compared to Cly in the Northern Hemisphere derived from measurements of the POLSTRACC-GW-LCYCLE-SALSA (PGS) campaign in the Arctic winter of 2015/2016. A scaled correlation was used for PGS data, since not all source gases were measured. Using the SouthTRAC data, Cly from a scaled correlation was compared to directly determined Cly and agreed well. An air mass classification based on in situ N2O measurements allocates the measurements to the vortex, the vortex boundary region, and midlatitudes. Although the Antarctic vortex was weakened in 2019 compared to previous years, Cly reached 1687±19 ppt at 385 K; therefore, up to around 50 % of total chlorine was found in inorganic form inside the Antarctic vortex, whereas only 15 % of total chlorine was found in inorganic form in the southern midlatitudes. In contrast, only 40 % of total chlorine was found in inorganic form in the Arctic vortex during PGS, and roughly 20 % was found in inorganic form in the northern midlatitudes. Differences inside the two vortices reach as much as 540 ppt, with more Cly in the Antarctic vortex in 2019 than in the Arctic vortex in 2016 (at comparable distance to the local tropopause). To our knowledge, this is the first comparison of inorganic chlorine within the Antarctic and Arctic polar vortices. Based on the results of these two campaigns, the differences in Cly inside the two vortices are substantial and larger than the inter-annual variations previously reported for the Antarctic.
Production and use of many synthetic halogenated trace gases are regulated internationally due to their contribution to stratospheric ozone depletion or climate change. In many applications they have been replaced by shorter-lived compounds, which have become measurable in the atmosphere as emissions increased. Non-target monitoring of trace gases rather than targeted measurements of well-known substances is needed to keep up with such changes in the atmospheric composition. We regularly deploy gas chromatography (GC) coupled to time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOF-MS) for analysis of flask air samples and in situ measurements at the Taunus Observatory, a site in central Germany. TOF-MS acquires data over a continuous mass range that enables a retrospective analysis of the dataset, which can be considered a type of digital air archive. This archive can be used if new substances come into use and their mass spectrometric fingerprint is identified. However, quantifying new replacement halocarbons can be challenging, as mole fractions are generally low, requiring high measurement precision and low detection limits. In addition, calibration can be demanding, as calibration gases may not contain sufficiently high amounts of newly measured substances or the amounts in the calibration gas may have not been quantified. This paper presents an indirect data evaluation approach for TOF-MS data, where the calibration is linked to another compound which could be quantified in the calibration gas. We also present an approach to evaluate the quality of the indirect calibration method, select periods of stable instrument performance and determine well suited reference compounds. The method is applied to three short-lived synthetic halocarbons: HFO-1234yf, HFO-1234ze(E), and HCFO-1233zd(E). They represent replacements for longer-lived hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) and exhibit increasing mole fractions in the atmosphere.
The indirectly calibrated results are compared to directly calibrated measurements using data from TOF-MS canister sample analysis and TOF-MS in situ measurements, which are available for some periods of our dataset. The application of the indirect calibration method on several test cases can result in uncertainties of around 6 % to 11 %. For hydro(chloro-)fluoroolefines (denoted H(C)FOs), uncertainties up to 23 % are achieved. The indirectly calculated mole fractions of the investigated H(C)FOs at Taunus Observatory range between measured mole fractions at urban Dübendorf and Jungfraujoch stations in Switzerland.