Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (24)
Has Fulltext
- yes (24)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (24)
Keywords
- EPR (2)
- PELDOR (2)
- Aptamere (1)
- Conformational Dynamics (1)
- DEER (1)
- DNS (1)
- Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (1)
- Elektronenspinresonanz (1)
- Elektronenspinresonanzspektroskopie (1)
- Multi-domain proteins (1)
Institute
Structural biology often employs a combination of experimental and computational approaches to unravel the structure-function paradigm of biological macromolecules. This thesis aims to approach this combination by the application of Pulsed Electron-Electron Double Resonance (PELDOR/DEER) spectroscopy and structural modelling. In this respect, PELDOR spectroscopy in combination with site-directed spin labelling (SDSL) of proteins is frequently used to gain distance restraints in the range from 1.8 to 8 nm. The inter-spin distance and the flexibility of the spin labelled protein domains are encoded in the oscillation and the dampening of the PELDOR signal. The intrinsic flexibility of the commonly used MTSSL (1-Oxyl-2,2,5,5-tetramethylpyrroline-3-methyl) spin label itself can be an obstacle for structural modelling if the flexibility of the label is large compared to the flexibility of the protein domains. In this thesis the investigation of two multi-domain proteins by the 4-pulse PELDOR sequence is presented. At first, the N-terminal polypeptide transport-associated (POTRA) domains of anaOmp85, a rigid three domain protein, giving well-defined PELDOR distance restraints, is investigated. The experimental restraints are used for structure refinement of the X-ray structure and reveal a strong impact of the intrinsic flexibility of MTSSL on the accuracy of structural refinement. The second example, K48-linked diubiquitin, is a highly flexible multi-domain protein on which the flexibility of MTSSL is of minor impact on structural modelling. In this case, the distance restraints are utilized to determine conformational ensembles. Due to the high intrinsic flexibility already characterizing diubiquitin the recently developed 7-pulse Carr-Purcell (CP) PELDOR sequence was applied to investigate longer ubiquitin chains. This sequence enables to measure dipolar oscillations with an extended time window, allowing a good separation between inter- and intramolecular contributions even for long distance and broad conformational distributions, thereby providing an increased accuracy of the obtained distance distributions.
Functional dynamics of ribonucleic acids : development and application of spectroscopic tools
(2016)
Im Rahmen der vorliegenden Dissertation wird der Aufbau eines zeitaufgelösten Fluorimeters, die photophysikalische Grundcharakterisierung der drei 2-(Pyrenylethinyl)-Adenosine (PyAs) und das Wechselwirkungsgeflecht des tetracyclinbindenden Aptamers (TC-Aptamer) mit seinem Liganden Tetracycyclin (TC) und Mg2+ dargestellt.
Das zeitaufgelöste Fluorimeter basiert auf der experimentellen Technik des zeitkorrelierten Einzelphotonenzählens. Es verfügt über zwei Anregungsquellen: gepulste UV-LEDs und einen frequenzverdoppelten titandotierten Saphirlaser. Diese Quellen Decken einen Wellenlängenbereich von (310 - 550) nm ab. Das Spektrometer kann unter günstigen Umständen eine Zeitauflösung von 50 ps erreichen bei einer zeitlichen Messungenauigkeit von weniger als 0,02 %.
Die Leistungsfähigkeit des Aufbaus wird anhand einer umfangreichen Studie an den drei PyAs demonstriert.
Die drei PyAs 2-(1-Pyrenylethinyl)-Adenosine (1PyA), 2-(2-Pyrenylethinyl)-Adenosine (2PyA) und 2-(4-Pyrenylethinyl)-Adenosine (4PyA) sind eine Gruppe fluoreszierender RNA-Nukleosidanaloga, welche die Gesamtheit aller möglichen Konfigurations-isomere der Grundverbindung PyA umfassen. Ihre zeitabhängigen Fluoreszenzzerfallseigenschaften werden ergänzt von stationären Absorptions- und Fluoreszenzspektren, ultraschneller transienter Absorptionsspektroskopie und quantenchemischen Rechnungen. Die Fluoreszenz von 1PyA und 4PyA gehorchen der Regel von Kasha, wohingegen 2PyA einen triexponentiellen Zerfall mit ausgeprägter Abhängigkeit von der Anregungswellenlänge zeigt. Die transienten Absorptionsspektren aller drei Isomere weisen im gesamten Spektrum dominante, wenig strukturierte Absorptionsbanden des ersten angeregten Zustands auf, welche im nahen UV in unterschiedlichem Maße vom Grundzustandsbleichen und stimulierter Emission überlagert werden. 2PyA zeigt eine deutlich ausgeprägte Signatur für eine interne Umwandlung hin zum S1, wenn es in höhere angeregte Zustände angeregt wird.
Das Fluoreszenzverhalten von 2PyA wird mithilfe eines lokal angeregten (LE) und zweier intramolekularer Ladungstransferzustände, von denen einer der koplanaren Orientierung von Pyren und Adenin (MICT) und der andere einer um 90 ° verdrehten Orientierung (TICT) entspricht. Der LE-Zustand ist hierbei verknüpft mit dem S2 von 2PyA, welcher einer rein pyrenlokalisierten Anregung entspricht. Dieser Zustand existiert so in 1PyA und 4PyA nicht. Der verdrehte TICT-Zustand ist nur in 2PyA bevölkerbar, weil für 2PyA die Barriere zur Bildung von Rotameren am niedrigsten ist und das Molekül nach Anregung daher in diese Geometrie kommen kann und dann durch die stärkere elektrostatische Anziehung stabilisiert wird. 1PyA und 4PyA emittieren hingegen nur aus dem MICT-Zustand.
Die Komplexbildung des TC-Aptamers mit seinem Liganden TC in Lösung wird empfindlich beeinflusst durch die-Konzentration von Magnesiumkationen. Dies wird untersucht durch Bindungs- und Faltungs- und Denaturierungsstudien mit verschiedenen Mg- und Harnstoffkonzentrationen. Als experimentelle Observable dienen hierbei die konformationsabhängige Nukleobasenabsorption und ihr Zirkulardichroismus im fernen UV, die Fluoreszenz des Liganden TC und die freiwerdende Wärme der exothermen Bindungsreaktion des Aptamers mit Mg in An- und Abwesenheit von TC.
Ohne Mg ist eine Interaktion des TC-Aptamers mit TC nicht nachweisbar. Dies liegt daran, dass Mg die notwendige elektrostatische Abschirmung der negativen elektrischen Ladung am RNA-Rückgrat zur Verfügung stellt. Die Abschirmung erlaubt es dem Aptamer kompakte Strukturen mit tertiären Kontakten auszubilden. Wenn die Mg-Konzentration die Faltung des Aptamers vollständig unterstützt (> 1 mM), so befindet sich das Aptamer weitgehend in einer vorgefalteten Konformation, welche der bindungskompetenten stark ähnelt. In diesem Zustand kann das Aptamer seinen Liganden extrem schnell, nämlich annähernd diffusionslimitiert binden. Unter diesen Bedingungen hat TC kaum Einfluss auf die Konformation seines Aptamers.
Bei physiologischen Mg-Konzentrationen (0,2 - 0,8 mM) kann das Aptamer kompakte Konformationen mit tertiären Strukturen einnehmen. Diejenige Konformation, welche der bindenden sehr stark ähnelt, dominiert das konformationelle Gleichgewicht jedoch noch nicht vollständig, es ist lediglich eine Konformation von vielen möglichen. Daher eröffnen physiologische Mg-Konzentrationen dem TC-Aptamer Teile des Konformationsraumes, welche andernfalls nicht zugänglich wären und TC stabilisiert selektiv die native Konformation. Diese konformationelle Verschiebung liefert kann hierbei zur robusten Signalgebung für die Funktion als Riboschalter dienen.
Pulsed dipolar (PD) EPR spectroscopy is an established and reliable tool for the investigation of biomolecules. In terms of long distance and orientation measurements, it is one of the leading methods and further fields of application are constantly being explored. The distances that can be detected with PD EPR also correspond to the range in which almost all important biomolecule interactions occur. In the transition from in vitro spectroscopy to in-cell spectroscopy, the power of PD EPR spectroscopy is particularly evident. It is non-invasive, more sensitive than NMR, and does not exhibit background signals from diamagnetic molecules. In particular, the absence of background signals is of great importance given the high density of molecules within cellular environment. However, like any other spectroscopic method, PD EPR has certain limitations. Owing to the intrinsically fast electron spin echo dephasing at higher temperature, these experiments are commonly carried out in frozen solutions at about 50 K. This temperature is far away from the physiological conditions and the freezing additives used, e.g. glycols, can further influence the structure. To enable measurements with and within living organisms, it is therefore necessary to ascend from the cold depths of the frozen state. At the same time, one has to adapt the spin tags for the desired application. Established nitroxides commonly used for EPR studies are typically susceptible to reduction. Thus, for studies under physiological conditions, e.g. in the cell, one has to fight against the reductive environment in the cell and somehow protect the spin labels. Initial published in-cell experiments within the research group and investigations of homogeneously distributed labeled double-stranded (ds) ‐DNA samples in solid matrices showed promising results and enabled pulsed measurement in the temperature range of 50‐ 295 K. It could also be demonstrated that spherical shielded nitroxides have a significantly longer life span in cellular environments than non-protected ones and first nuclear acids were measured in cell. Based on these results, we have gone further to overcome the standing limitations and developed the use of PD EPR spectroscopy. This work addresses these challenges with the overall goal of advancing the applications of PD EPR spectroscopy for studying biomolecules under physiological conditions.
We have focused on four different approaches. The results of these studies were published in various publications. They are presented and discussed together with further studies and put into the context of research conducted before and after the authors' publications.
In approach 1, we fought against the two main obstacles for using pulsed dipolar spectroscopy at ambient conditions – minimizing phase memory time T2 and averaging of the anisotropic dipolar coupling by rotational diffusion. We focused on an immobilization approach, while using rigid spin labels at same time. Besidesto the distance information, the incorporated rigid spin labels will give additional angular constrains and information about the molecular dynamics.
In approach 2, we focused on the on-site and on-demand formation of nitroxide spin labels using light-sensitive alkyl protection groups. This a very mild and efficient procedure that will hardly interfere with sensitive functional groups present in oligonucleotides or peptides. By establishing this method and using coumarin protecting groups plus two-photon excitation, this property may offer the potential to generate spin labels with very high levels of spatial and temporal resolution.
For approach 3, we used paramagnetic Gd3+ -ions as intrinsically stable labels, which are not reducible within a cellular environment. Easy to mix and bound to encodable lanthanide binding tags within the molecule Interleucin 1β, we were able to measure distances between two tags with PELDOR spectroscopy. We tested the extent to which this system is suitable for in-cell measurements.
Finally, we focus on methods for easier labeling by using non-covalentlabeling techniques. One of these is the novel nitroxide G´ for site-directed spin labeling of nucleic acids, especially for RNA. This spin label is sterically hindered, easy to build and binding occurs in seconds by simply mixing the spin label with the target. For large RNAs, another easy-to-mix and noncovalent spin-labeling strategy will be experimentally accompanied and presented.
The approaches and results described here are intended to demonstrate that the study of the biological functions of biomolecules under physiological conditions by pulsed EPR spectroscopy is feasible and operational. In combination, they will enable the life sciences to make further and faster progress in the search for the molecular master plan.
Pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR), also called Double Electron-Electron Resonance, (DEER) is a pulsed EPR technique that can provide structural information of biomolecules, such as proteins or nucleic acids, complementary to other structure determination methods by measuring long distances (from 1.5 up to 10 nm) between two paramagnetic labels. Incorporation of the rigid Ç-label pairwise into DNA or RNA molecules enables the determination not only of the distance but also of the mutual orientation between the two Ç-labels by multi-frequency orientation-selective PELDOR data (X-, Q- and G-band frequencies). Thus, information about the orientation of secondary structure elements of nucleic acids can be revealed and used as additional angular information for structure determination. Since Ç does not have motion independent from the helix where it resides, the conformational flexibility of the nucleic acid molecule can be directly determined. This thesis demonstrates the advancement of PELDOR spectroscopy, beyond its original scope of distance measurements, to determine the mutual orientation between two rigid spin labels towards the characterization of the conformational space sampled by highly flexible nucleic acid molecules. Applications of the methodology are shown on two systems: a three-way junction, namely a cocaine aptamer in its bound-state, and a two-way junction, namely a bent DNA.
More in detail, the conformational changes of the cocaine aptamer upon cocaine binding were investigated by analysis of the distance distributions. The cocaine-bound and the unbound states could be differentiated by their conformational flexibility, which decreases in the presence of the ligand. Moreover, the obtained distance distributions revealed a small change in the mean distance between the two spin labels upon cocaine binding. This indicates a ligand-induced conformational change, which presumably originates at the junction where cocaine is known to bind. The investigation of the relative orientation between the two spin-labeled helices of the aptamer revealed further structural insights into the conformational dynamics of the cocaine-bound state. The angular information from the orientation-selective PELDOR data and the a priori knowledge about the secondary structure of the aptamer were helpful in obtaining a molecular model describing its global folding and flexibility. In spite of a large flexible aptamer, the kink angle between the Ç-labeled helices was found to be rather well-defined.
As for the bent DNA molecule, a two-step protocol was proposed to investigate the conformational flexibility. In the first step, a database with all the possible conformers was created, using available restraints from NMR and distance restraints derived from PELDOR. In a second step, a weighted ensemble of these conformers fitting the multi-frequency PELDOR data was built. The uniqueness of the obtained structural ensemble was checked by validation against an independent PELDOR data set recorded at a higher magnetic field strength. In addition, the kink and twist angle pairs were determined and the resulting structural ensemble was compared with the conformational space deduced both from FRET experiments and from the structure determined by the NMR restraints alone.
Overall, this thesis underlines the potential of using PELDOR spectroscopy combined with rigid spin labels in the context of structure determination of nucleic acids in order to determine the relative orientation between two helices, the conformational flexibility and the conformational changes of nucleic acid molecules upon ligand binding.
Metal ions as novel polarizing agents for dynamic nuclear polarization enhanced NMR spectroscopy
(2017)
High-spin complexes of Gd(III) and Mn(II) were introduced as polarizing agents (PAs) for solid-state dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) in 2011. This dissertation was undertaken in 2013, with the intention of exploring these PAs further. Major goals of this work were to understand their DNP mechanism(s) and explore their application in biomolecular research. This cumulative thesis details the methods, advantages, and practical implications of using high-spin PAs for MAS DNP. Data from electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and NMR spectroscopy are discussed for a complete understanding of DNP mechanisms.
Out of the two main mechanisms − solid effect (SE) and cross effect (CE − active under experimental conditions of solid-state DNP, commonly used nitroxide PAs evoke CE owing to their broad EPR spectra. On the other hand, DNP mechanisms evoked by high-spin metal ions seem non-trivial due to additional features (originating from spin-orbit coupling or zero field splitting) in their EPR spectra. The features of the EPR signal generally influence the shape of enhancement profiles. Therefore, the metal ion with a simpler EPR signal i.e., Gd(III) , is chosen as the starting point for the investigation of DNP mechanisms. Varying concentrations (2, 10, 20 mM) of a water-soluble and stable complex Gd-DOTA was dissolved as the PA in a glycerol-water solution of 13C,15N - urea. Field profiles of DNP enhancement on each nuclear type (1H, 13C, and 15N) establishes SE as the active DNP mechanism at the smallest PA concentration (2 mM). This confirms the theoretical predictions that narrow line width of the Gd(III) EPR signal arising from the central transition (CT, ms = -1/2 +1/2) allows for resolved SE DNP. However, that is no longer the case at higher PA concentrations of 10 and 20 mM. At higher Gd(III) concentrations, the CE mechanism contributes significantly and varies with nuclear Larmor frequency (ωn) of the concerned nuclei. The enhancement maxima shifts towards the EPR resonance as the contribution from CE increases. This shift is evident in the field profiles of 15N and 13C, whereas that of 1H is least influenced. This observation can be explained by combining theoretical estimates with the experimental data; the CE is evoked by increased dipolar coupling (Dee) – a prerequisite for CE – between neighboring Gd(III) spins as the statistical inter-spin distance shortens at elevated concentrations. This finding is important because the knowledge of active DNP mechanisms is essential for accurate interpretation of results from DNP experiments.
From the experiments on Gd-DOTA it becomes clear that concentration, inter-spin distances, and hence induced Dee are intertwined. In order to explicitly address the influence of inter-spin distances on DNP mechanisms we started a collaboration with the group of Adelheid Godt (Bielefeld). In this collaborative project, bis-complexes of the type Gd(III)-spacer-Gd(III) with variable spacer lengths were investigated. These PAs provided an excellent model system where the influence of only inter-spin distances can be determined for a fixed Gd(III) concentration. A small PA concentration of 4 mM is used to ensure absence of significant inter-molecular dipolar interactions. A mono-Gd complex of similar geometry and chemistry is taken as a reference for SE DNP.
The mono-Gd complex yields enhancements arising from SE as expected from negligible inter-molecular Dee. The contribution of CE increases as the inter-spin distances between Gd(III) ions become shorter going from 3.4 nm 2.1 nm 1.4 nm 1.2 nm due to corresponding increase in Dee. The extent of CE on ωn follows the same trend as for Gd-DOTA. Highest CE contribution is observed on nuclei with the smallest ωn 15N because smaller ωn approaches the width of the EPR signal, this is an additional requirement for CE DNP.
The field position for maximum DNP enhancement corresponding to Gd-DOTA, is used for DNP experiments on Ubiquitin with an attached Gd-tag as PA. The success of DNP on this sample illustrates the possibility of site-directed DNP with metal ions tags as PAs. As a perspective Gd-tags can be used to examine change in conformation of a protein that would give higher enhancements due to CE if two Gd(III) labeled domains are closer in space. In a separate project, Mn(II) (s=5/2) bound to the divalent site of a hammerhead ribozyme was used as a PA which resulted in the first demonstration of intra-complex DNP using an intrinsically bound metal ion PA.
Transport mechanism of a multidrug resistance protein investigated by pulsed EPR spectroscopy
(2019)
In human several diseases result from malfunctions of ATP-binding cassette (ABC) systems, which form one of the largest transport system superfamily. Many ABC exporters contain asymmetric nucleotide-binding sites (NBSs) and some of them are inhibited by the transported substrate.1 For the active transport of diverse chemically substrates across biological membranes, ABC transport complexes use the energy of ATP binding and subsequent hydrolysis. In this thesis, the heterodimeric ABC exporter TmrAB2,3 from Thermus thermophilus, a functional homolog of the human antigen translocation complex TAP, was investigated by using pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR/DEER) spectroscopy. In the presence of ATP, TmrAB exists in an equilibrium between inward- and outward-facing conformations. This equilibrium can be modulated by changing the ATP concentration, showing asymmetric behaviour in the open-to-close equilibrium between the consensus and the degenerate NBSs. At the degenerate NBS the closed conformation is more preferred and closure of one of the NBSs is sufficient to open the periplasmic gate at the transmembrane domain (TMD).3 By determining the temperature dependence of this conformational equilibrium, the thermodynamics of the energy coupling during ATP-induced conformational changes in TmrAB were investigated. The results demonstrate that ATP-binding alone drives the global conformational switching to the outward-facing state and allows the determination of the entropy and enthalpy changes for this step. With this knowledge, the Gibbs free energy of this ATP induced transition was calculated. Furthermore, an excess of substrate, meaning trans-inhibition of the transporter is resulting mechanistically in a reverse transition from the outward-facing state to an occluded conformation predominantly.3 This work unravels the central role of the reversible conformational equilibrium in the function and regulation of an ABC exporter. For the first time it is shown that the conformational thermodynamics of a large membrane protein complex can be investigated. The presented experiments give new possibilities to investigate other related medically important transporters with asymmetric NBSs or other similar protein complexes.
Die Lebensfunktion der Zelle beruht unter anderem auf der Funktion und Wechselwirkung der Nukleinsäuren DNA (2’-Desoxyribonukleinsäure) und RNA (Ribonukleinsäure). Mit Hilfe von PDS (engl. ’pulsed dipolare spectroscopy’)-Techniken, basierend auf der EPR (engl. ’electron paramagnetic resonance’)-Spektroskopie, können Abstände in einem Bereich von 2-10 nm zwischen zwei markierten Positionen einer Nukleinsäure bestimmt werden. Daneben kann mit der Abstandsverteilung auf die Flexibilität des Moleküls geschlossen werden. Durch PDS-Messungen eröffnet sich die Möglichkeit, Bewegungen und Zustandsänderungen zu untersuchen. Die Messungen beruhen auf der dipolaren Kopplung von Radikalen (Spinlabel). Da die gemessenen dipolaren Kopplungen eine anisotrope Wechselwirkung sind, können an starren Systemen neben den Abstandsinformationen auch die Orientierungen der beiden Spinlabel zueinander bestimmt werden. Diese zusätzliche Information ermöglicht es, mittels orientierungsselektiver PDS-Messungen noch genauer die Geometrie und Flexibilität des Systems zu untersuchen. Klassischerweise werden alle Messungen mit der Doppelfrequenztechnik PELDOR (engl. ’pulsed electron-electron double resonance’) durchgeführt. Einzelfrequenzmethoden basieren dagegen auf Breitbandanregung, die mit den technischen Gegebenheiten l nge nicht möglich war. Eine solche Sequenz ist 2D-SIFTER.ImmRahmen dieser Arbeit von PELDOR ausgehende, weiterentwickelte Simulationsprozedur etabliert. Eine große Herausforderung ist die eindeutige Interpretation der sensitiven orientierungsselektiven PELDOR-Messungen. Sie mittels MD (Moleküldynamik)-Simulationen zu beschreiben war bisher nur qualitativ möglich. Allerdings wurden mehrere neue Kraftfelder publiziert. Mit einem quantitativen Vergleich mit orientierungsselektiven PELDOR-Daten kann sichergestellt werden, dass die Flexibilität des Systems durch Kraftfelder richtig beschrieben ist. PELDOR-Zeitspuren, gemessen bei Raumtemperatur und 50 K, unterscheiden sich besonders in ihrer Dämpfung. Der physikalische Unterschied beider Messungen konnte durch MD-Simulationen qualitativ nachvollzogen worden. Eine Schwierigkeit für speziell orientierungsselektive PELDOR-Messungen ist die aufwendige Synthese von mit dem starren Ç-Label markierten Nukleinsäuren. Als Alternative wurde in der Sigurdsson-Gruppe das halbstarre IMU-Label entwickelt. Die Analyse der orientierungsselektiven Daten ergab ein klares Bild der Dynamik dieses Labels. Ein weiterer interessanter Spinlabel ist der `G. Dieser Label ist nicht kovalent gebunden, sondern interkaliert in eine Stelle der Nukleinsäure, in der eine Guanin- Base fehlt. MD-Simulationen im quantitativen Vergleich mit orientierungsselektiven PELDOR-Messungen an verschiedenen Magnetfeldern haben eine hohe Übereinstimmung. Dabei konnte gezeigt werden, dass der Label, interkaliert in eine dsDNA, flippen kann, was zu einer Ausmittelung der Anisotropie führt, allerdings zu keiner Verbreiterung der Abstandsverteilung. Dagegen wird in der dsRNA dieses Flippen um die Einfachbindung sterisch gehindert, so dass neben dem Abstand auch die Orientierung des Labels bestimmt werden kann. Kurze dsRNA-Bausteine tendieren dazu, Oligomere zu bilden, was zu Multispineffekten führte. Zusätzlich beeinflusst diese Aggregation die Dynamik der einzelnen RNAs. Daher musste dieses ’end-to-end’-Stacking verhindert werden. Eine Nukleobasean einem Ende der dsRNA führt zu einer Dimerisierung, während eine Nukleobase an beiden Seiten dieses Stacking vollständig verhindert. Messungen mit unterschiedlichen Salzkonzentrationen konnten zusätzlich zeigen, dass die Interaktion zweier dsRNAs bei höheren Salzkonzentrationen zunimmt.
Pulsed electron–electron double resonance (PELDOR) spectroscopy is a powerful tool for measuring nanometer distances in spin-labeled systems and recently is increasingly applied to membrane proteins. However, after reconstitution of labeled proteins into liposomes, spin labels often exhibit a much faster transversal relaxation (Tm) than in detergent micelles, thus limiting application of the method in lipid bilayers. In the first part of the thesis, optimization of transversal relaxation in phospholipid membranes was systematically investigated by use of spin-labeled derivatives of stearic acid and phosphatidylcholine as well as spin-labeled derivatives of the channel-forming peptide gramicidin A under the conditions typically employed for PELDOR distance measurements. Our results clearly show that dephasing due to instantaneous diffusion that depends on dipolar interaction among electron spins is an important contributor to the fast echo decay in cases of high local concentrations of spin labels in membranes. The main difference between spin labels in detergent micelles and membranes is their local concentration. Consequently, avoiding spin aggregation and suppressing instantaneous diffusion is the key step for maximizing PELDOR sensitivity in lipid membranes. Even though proton spin diffusion is an important relaxation mechanism, only in samples with low local concentrations does deuteration of acyl chains and buffer significantly prolong Tm. In these cases, values of up to 7 μs have been achieved. Furthermore, our study revealed that membrane composition and labeling position in the membrane can also affect Tm, either by promoting the segregation of spin-labeled species or by altering their exposure to matrix protons. Effects of other experimental parameters including temperature (<50 K), presence of oxygen, and cryoprotectant type are negligible under our experimental conditions.
In the second part of the thesis, inhomogeneous distribution of spin-labels in detergent micelles has been studied. A common approach in PELDOR is measuring the distance between two covalently attached spin labels in a macromolecule or singly-labeled components of an oligomer. This situation has been described as a spin-cluster. The PELDOR signal, however, does not only contain the desired dipolar coupling between the spin-labels of the molecule or cluster under study. In samples of finite concentration the dipolar coupling between the spin-labels of the randomly distributed molecules or spin-clusters also contributes significantly. In homogeneous frozen solutions or lipid vesicle membranes this second contribution can be considered to be an exponential or stretched exponential decay, respectively. In this study, it is shown that this assumption is not valid in detergent micelles. Spin-labeled fatty acids that are randomly partitioned into different detergent micelles give rise to PELDOR time traces which clearly deviate from stretched exponential decays. As a main conclusion a PELDOR signal deviating from a stretched exponential decay does not necessarily prove the observation of specific distance information on the molecule or cluster. These results are important for the interpretation of PELDOR experiments on membrane proteins or lipophilic peptides solubilized in detergent micelles or small vesicles, which often do not show pronounced dipolar oscillations in their time traces.
In the third part, PELDOR has been utilized to study the structural flexibility of the Toc34 GTPase homodimer, a preprotein receptor of the translocon of the outer envelope of chloroplasts (TOC). Toc34 belongs to GAD subfamily of G-proteins that are regulated and activated by nucleotide-dependent dimerization. However, the function of Toc34 dimerization is not yet fully understood. Previous structural investigations of the Toc34 dimer yielded only marginal structural changes in response to different nucleotide loads. PELDOR revealed a nucleotide-dependent transition of the dimer flexibility from a tight GDP to a flexible GTP-loaded state. Substrate-binding stabilizes the dimer in the transition state mimicked by GDP-AlFx, but induces an opening in the GDP or GTP-loaded state. Thus, the structural dynamics of bona fide GTPases induced by GTP hydrolysis is replaced by substrate-dependent dimer flexibility, which represents the regulatory mode for dimerizing GTPases.
In the fourth part of the thesis, conformational flexibility and relative orientation of the N-terminal POTRA domains of a cyanobacterial Omp85 from Anabaena sp. PCC 7120, a key component of the outer membrane protein assembly machinery, were investigated by PELDOR spectroscopy. Membrane proteins of the Omp85-TpsB superfamily are composed of a C-terminal β-barrel and a different number of N-terminal POTRA domains, three in the case of cyanobacterial Omp85. It has been suggested that the N-terminal POTRA domains (P1 and P2) might have functions in substrate recognition. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations predicted a fixed orientation for P2 and P3 and a flexible hinge between P1 and P2. The PELDOR distances measured between the P2 and P3 POTRA domains are in good agreement with the structure determined by X-ray, and compatible with the MD simulations suggesting a fixed orientation between these domains. PELDOR constraints between the P1 and P2 POTRA domains imply a rather rigid structure with a slightly different relative orientation of these domains compared with the X-ray structure. Moreover, the large mobility predicted from MD is not observed in the frozen solution. The PELDOR results further highlight the restricted relative orientation of the POTRA domains of the Omp85-TpsB proteins as a conserved characteristic feature that might be important for the processive sliding of the unfolded substrate towards the membrane.
An application of EPR spectroscopy that is becoming increasingly important is the measurement of distances between electron spins. Several EPR methods have been developed for this purpose, all based on measuring the dipolar coupling between two spins. Due to the specific nature of the sample, we applied dipolar relaxation enhancement measurements to study the geometry of a protein-protein complex. The paramagnetic centers in question had EPR spectra that were too broad and had such short relaxation time that they could not be studied using the more straightforward PELDOR technique. EPR spectral resolution can be increased appreciably by measuring at a frequency higher than conventional X-band (9 GHz) frequency. The spectra of many paramagnetic species can only be resolved at frequencies higher than 90 GHz. For accurate measurement of the orientation of the vector between two dipolar coupled spins with respect to the g-tensors of the spins, high spectral resolution is required. We therefore performed our EPR measurements at G-band (180 GHz) frequency. Dipolar relaxation measurements were applied to study the complex that is formed by the two electron-transfer proteins cytochrome c and cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) from the soil bacterium Paracoccus denitrificans. We were able to detect dipolar relaxation enhancement due to complex formation of soluble subunit II of P.d. CcO (CcOII) with two substrate cytochromes, which was practically absent in a mixture of CcOII with the negative control protein cytochrome c1. This complex formation was characterized by a pronounced temperature dependence that could be simulated using a home-written computer program. The G-band EPR measurements could not be simulated with a single complex geometry. This provided evidence for the hypothesis that electron-transfer protein complexes are short-lived and highly dynamic; they do not seem to form one specific electron-transfer conformation, but rather move around on each other’s binding surfaces and transfer an electron as soon as the distance between donor and acceptor is short enough. As a test of our simulation program, we also applied dipolar relaxation measurements to specially synthesized organic molecules that contained a nitroxide radical and a metal center. The transverse relaxation of Cu2+-OEP-TPA was compared to the relaxation of Ni2+-OEP-TPA at temperatures between 20 and 120 K. In this temperature range, the nitroxide relaxation was enhanced due to the presence of Cu2+, but not by Ni2+. Similarly, relaxation enhancement was found in the nitroxide-Mn2+ pair in Mn2+-terpyridine-TPA with respect to the terpyridine-TPA ligand. Due to the fast T2 relaxation of the nitroxide radical at high temperatures, the measurements were all performed in the low-temperature regime where the T1 relaxation rate of the metal ion was smaller than the dipolar coupling frequency. In this region, no structural information about the molecule can be deduced, since the dipolar relaxation enhancement is only determined by the T1 of the metal ion. The dipolar relaxation measurements we performed at high field indicated a difference in relaxation times between X-band and G-band frequencies. Extensive T1 - measurements of different paramagnetic centers (CuA, Cu2+) confirmed a strong dependence of T1 on magnetic field in the temperature range where the direct process is the dominating T1 relaxation process. This dependence is very strong (factor of 103 with respect to X-band), but does not follow the B04 dependence predicted in literature. The T1 relaxation of low-spin iron in cytochrome c at high magnetic field, estimated from dipolar relaxation data, is also in agreement with a larger contribution by the direct process (factor of 104). Dipolar relaxation enhancement was found to be a technique that is useful for measuring distances between paramagnetic centers, but only for systems where several important conditions are met, such as: the system exists in one certain static geometry, and the relaxation rate of the fast-relaxing spin is faster than the dipolar coupling frequency within the accessible temperature range. Additionally, it is a great advantage for the analysis of dipolar relaxation data if the procedure of dividing the relaxation trace of the dipolar-coupled slow-relaxing spin by the relaxation trace of the slow-relaxing spin in absence of dipolar coupling can be applied. Another useful application of dipolar relaxation enhancement measurements is the measurement of T1 relaxation of extremely fast-relaxing spins, or spins that are otherwise difficult to detect.
The mitochondrial respiratory chain consists of NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (Complex-I), succinate:ubiquinone reductase (Complex-II), ubiquinol:cytochrome c reductase (Complex-III), cytochrome c oxidase (Complex-IV) and cytochrome c as an electron mediator between Complex-III and Complex-IV. Paracoccus denitrificans membranes were used as a model system for the association of the mitochondrial respiratory chain. More than 50 years ago, a model was given for a supercomplex assembly formed by stable associations between these complexes. This model gradually shifted by the model of random diffusion given by Hackenbrock et al. 1986 Different independent approaches were used to further analyze this situation in a native membrane environment, thus avoiding any perturbation caused by detergent solubilization: (a) measuring the distance and orientation of the different complexes by multi-frequency EPR Spectroscopy we started to analyze simple system, the interaction between CuA fragment derived from P. denitrificans and various c type cytochrome by Pulsed X band and G band (180 GHz) EPR. Partner proteins for the CuA (excess negative surface charge) were (i) horse heart cytochrome c which contain a large number of positive charges in heme crevice,(ii) the cytochrome c552 soluble fragment (physiological electron donor and have positive charges), and as a control (iii) the cytochrome c1 soluble fragment (negative surface potential, derived from bc1 complex) The measurements were performed at several magnetic field positions varying temperature between 5 to 30 K. Both the X band and the high-field measurements show the existence of a strong relaxation enhancement of the CuA by the specific binding of the P. denitrificans cytochrome c552 and horse heart cytochrome c. This relaxation enhancement is dependent on temperature and provides information about the distance and relative orientation of the two interacting spins within this protein-protein complex. (b) For quantitative information about lateral diffusion of cytochrome c oxidase in the native membrane Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy (FCS) was used. In this experiment, diffusion coefficients for oxidase differ in the case of supercomplex for wild type membrane and for two deletion mutants lacking either Complex-I or Complex-III. (c) The optical absorption spectroscopy at microsecond level resolution was tried for the translational mobility of oxidase in membrane vesicles. Due to the presence of different hemes in the native membrane, carbon monoxide (CO) used as a probe for the experiment. The optimization of the experimental conditions were carried out to get the optimal signal.