Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (32)
Has Fulltext
- yes (32)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (32)
Keywords
- Cytochromoxidase (2)
- Protonentransfer (2)
- Absorptionsspektroskopie (1)
- AlignMe (1)
- Alignment (1)
- Arzneimitteldesingn (1)
- Arzneimittelentwicklung (1)
- Atemwege (1)
- Bioenergetik (1)
- Cardiolipin (1)
Institute
- Biochemie und Chemie (22)
- Biochemie, Chemie und Pharmazie (5)
- Biowissenschaften (2)
- Physik (2)
- MPI für Biophysik (1)
- Pharmazie (1)
This work presents a biochemical, functional and structural characterization of Aquifex aeolicus F1FO ATP synthase obtained using both a native form (AAF1FO) and a heterologous form (EAF1FO) of this enzyme.
F1FO ATP synthases catalyze the synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate driven by ion motive forces across the membrane and therefore play a key cellular function. Because of their central role in supporting life, F1FO ATP synthases are ubiquitous and have been remarkably conserved throughout evolution. For their biological importance, F1FO ATP synthases have been extensively studied for many decades and many of them were characterized from both a functional and a structural standpoint. However, important properties of ATP synthases – specifically properties pertaining to their membrane embedded subunits – have yet to be determined and no structures are available to date for the intact enzyme complex. Therefore, F1FO ATP synthases are still a major focus of research worldwide. Our research group had previously reported an initial characterization of AAF1FO and had indicated that this enzyme presents unique features, i.e. a bent central stalk and a putatively heterodimeric peripheral stalk. Based on such a characterization, this enzyme revealed promising for structural and functional studies on ATP synthases and became the focus of this doctoral thesis. Two different lines of research were followed in this work.
First, the characterization of AAF1FO was extended by bioinformatic, biochemical and enzymatic analyses. The work on AAF1FO led to the identification of a new detergent that maintains a higher homogeneity and integrity of the complex, namely the detergent trans-4-(trans-4’-propylcyclohexyl)cyclohexyl-α-D-maltoside (α-PCC). The characterization of AAF1FO in this new detergent showed that AAF1FO is a proton-dependent, not a sodium ion-dependent ATP synthase and that its ATP hydrolysis mechanism needs to be triggered and activated by high temperatures, possibly inducing a conformational switch in subunit γ. Moreover, this approach suggested that AAF1FO may present unusual features in its membrane subunits, i.e. short N-terminal segments in subunits a and c with implications for the membrane insertion mechanism of these subunits.
Investigating on these unique features of A. aeolicus F1FO ATP synthase could not be done using A. aeolicus cells, because these require a harsh and dangerous environment for growth and they are inaccessible to genetic manipulations. Therefore, a second approach was pursued, in which an expression system was created to produce the enzyme in the heterologous host E. coli. This second approach was experimentally challenging, because A. aeolicus F1FO ATP synthase is a 500-kDa multimeric membrane enzyme with a complicated and still not entirely determined stoichiometry and because its encoding genes are scattered throughout A. aeolicus genome, rather than being organized in one single operon. However, an artificial operon suitable for expression was created in this work and led to the successful production of an active and fully assembled form of Aquifex aeolicus F1FO ATP synthase. Such artificial operon was created using a stepwise approach, in which we expressed and studied first individual subunits, then subcomplexes, and finally the entire F1FO ATP synthase complex. We confirmed experimentally that subunits b1 and b2 form a heterodimeric subcomplex in the E. coli membranes, which is a unique case among ATP synthases of non-photosynthetic organisms. Moreover, we determined that the b1b2 subcomplex is sufficient to recruit the soluble F1 subcomplex to the membranes, without requiring the presence of the other membrane subunits a and c. The latter subunits can be produced in our expression system only when the whole ATP synthase is expressed, but not in isolation nor in the context of smaller FO subcomplexes. These observations led us to propose a novel mechanism for the assembly of ATP synthases, in which first the F1 subcomplex attaches to the membrane via subunit b1b2, and then cring and subunits a assemble to complete the FO subcomplex. Furthermore, we could purify the heterologous ATP synthase (EAF1FO) to homogeneity by chromatography and electro-elution. Enzymatic assays showed that the purified form of EAF1FO is as active as AAF1FO. Peptide mass fingerprinting showed that EAF1FO is composed of the same subunits as AAF1FO and all soluble and membrane subunits could be identified. Finally, single-particle electron microscopy analysis revealed that the structure of EAF1FO is identical to that of AAF1FO. Therefore, the EAF1FO expression system serves as a reliable platform for investigating on properties of AAF1FO.
Specifically, in this work, EAF1FO was used to study the membrane insertion mechanism of rotary subunit c. Subunits c possess different lengths and levels of hydrophobicity across species and by analyzing their N-terminal variability, four phylogenetic groups of subunits c were distinguished (groups 1 to 4). As a member of group 2, the subunit c from A. aeolicus F1FO ATP synthase is characterized by an N-terminal segment that functions as a signal peptide with SRP recognition features, a unique case for bacterial F1FO ATP synthases. By accurately designing mutants of EAF1FO, we determined that such a signal peptide is strictly necessary for membrane insertion of subunit c and we concluded that A. aeolicus subunit c inserts into E. coli membranes using a different pathway than E. coli subunit c. Such a property may be common to other ATP synthases from extremophilic organisms, which all cluster in the same phylogenetic group.
In conclusion, the successful production of the fully assembled and active F1FO ATP synthase from A. aeolicus in E. coli reported in this work provides a novel genetic system to study A. aeolicus F1FO ATP synthase. To a broader extent, it will also serve in the future as a solid reference for designing strategies aimed at producing large multi-subunit complexes with complicated stoichiometry.
The electron transport chain (ETC) is used by cells to create an electrochemical proton gradient which can be used by the ATP synthase to produce ATP. ETC, also called respiratory chain, is formed in mitochondria by four complexes (complex I-IV) and mediated by two electron carriers: cytochrome c and ubiquinone. Electrons are passed from one complex to another in a series of redox reactions coupling proton pumping from the negative (N) side of the membrane to the positive (P) side. Complex I can introduce electrons into the ETC by oxidizing NADH to NAD+ and reducing quinone (Q) to quinol (QH2). The process accomplishes pumping of four protons across the membrane. Complex II is another electrons entry point. It catalyzes the oxidation of succinate to fumarate while reducing Q to QH2. Complex III, also called cytochrome bc1 complex, can transfer the electrons from QH2 to cytochrome c and couple to proton pumping. In complex III the Q-cycle contributes four proton translocations: two protons are required for the reduction of one quinone to a quinol and two protons are released to the P side. Complex IV (cytochrome c oxidase), the terminal complex of the ETC, catalyzes the electron transfer to oxygen and pumps four protons to the P side. Structures of ETC complexes are available. However, the structure of a hyperthermophilic cytochrome bc1 complex has not been elucidated till now. Additionally, the dimeric crystal structure of cytochrome c oxidase from bovine has been discussed controversially.
To build up a functional complex, cofactors are required. The active site of A- and B-type cytochrome c oxidases contain the high spin heme a which is synthesized by the integral membrane protein heme A synthase (HAS). HAS can form homooligomeric complexes and its oligomerization is essential for the biological function of HAS. HAS is evolutionarily conserved among prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Despite its importance, little is known about the detailed structural properties of HAS oligomers.
During my PhD studies, I focused on the cytochrome c oxidase (AaCcO), the cytochrome bc1 complex (Aabc1) and the heme A synthase (AaHAS) from Aquifex aeolicus. This organism is one of the most hyperthermophilic ones and can live at extremely high temperatures, even up to 95 °C. Respiratory chain complexes provide energy for the metabolism of organisms, and their structures have been studied extensively in the past few years. However, there has been a lack of atomic structures of complexes from hyperthermophilic and ancient bacteria, so little is known about the mechanism of these macromolecular machines under hyperthermophilic conditions. Therefore, my PhD studies had four main objectives: 1) to structurally and functionally characterize AaCcO, 2) to reveal the mechanism of Aabc1 thermal stability based on its structure, 3) to determine the oligomerization of AaHAS, 4) to provide valuable insights into the relationship between function and oligomerization of AaHAS.
1) Structure of AaCcO
Heme-copper oxidases (HCOs) catalyze the oxygen reduction reaction being the terminal enzymes in the plasma membranes in many prokaryotes or of the aerobic respiratory chain in the inner mitochondrial membrane. By coupling this exothermic reaction to proton pumping across the membrane to the P side, they contribute to the establishment of an electrochemical proton gradient. The energy in the proton electrochemical proton gradient is used by the ATP synthase to generate ATP. HCOs are classified into three major families: A, B and C, based on phylogenetic comparisons. The well-studied aa3-type cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans (P. denitrificans) represents A-family HCOs. So far, the only available structure of the ba3-type cytochrome c oxidase from Thermus thermophilus represents the B-family of HCOs. This family contains a number of bacterial and archaeal oxidases. The C-family contains only cbb3-type cytochrome c oxidases.
The AaCcO is one of the ba3-type cytochrome c oxidases. Based on the genomic DNA sequence analysis, it has been revealed that A. aeolicus possesses two operons coding for cytochrome c oxidases (two different subunit I genes, two different subunit II genes and one subunit III gene). So far, only subunits CoxB2 and CoxA2 were identified. The presence of the additional subunit IIa was reported in 2012. Moreover, a previous paper reported that AaCcO can use horse heart cytochrome c and decylubiquinol as electron donors and the typical cytochrome c oxidase inhibitor cyanide does not block the reaction completely.
In the course of my PhD studies, I performed heterologous expression of AaCcO in Pseudomonas stutzeri (P. stutzeri) and co-expression with AsHAS in Escherichia coli, respectively. The subcomplex CoxA2 and CoxB2 can be purified from P. stutzeri, however, it lacks heme A. Additionally, a protocol for the heterologous production of cytochrome c555 from A. aeolicus was established. In parallel, I also purified the AaCcO from native membranes according to previously reported methods with some modifications. The activity of AaCcO with its native substrate, cytochrome c555, was 14 times higher than with horse heart cytochrome c.
To enable a detailed investigation and comparison of AaCcO and other cytochrome c oxidases, the cryo-EM structure of AaCcO was determined to 3.4 Å resolution. It shows that the three subunits CoxA2, CoxB2, and IIa are tightly bound together to form a dimer in the membrane. Surprisingly, CoxA2 contains two additional TMHs (TMH13 and TMH14) to enhance the protein stability. The cofactors heme a3, heme b, CuA and CuB are also identified. Interestingly, two molecules of 1,4-naphthoquinone and cardiolipin were observed in the dimer interface. Based on the structure analysis, the AaCcO possesses only the K-pathway for proton delivery to the active site and proton pumping.
...
The members of the multidrug/oligosaccharidyl-lipid/polysaccharide (MOP) transporter superfamily mediate export of a wealth of molecules of physiological and pharmacological importance. According to the Transporter Classification Database (TCDB), the MOP superfamily is mainly categorized into six distantly related families functionally characterized families: the multidrug and toxic compound extrusion (MATE), the polysaccharide transporter (PST), the oligosaccharidyl-lipid flippase (OLF), the mouse virulence factor (MVF) the agrocin 84 antibiotic exporter (AgnG), and the progressive ankylosis (Ank) family. Among these, the multidrug resistance MATE family transporters are most ubiquitous, being present in all domains of life: Archaea, Bacteria and Eukarya. As secondary active transporters, they utilize transmembrane electrochemical ion gradients of Na+ and/or H+ in order to drive the efflux of xenobiotics or cytotoxic metabolic waste products with specificity mainly for polyaromatic and cationic substrates. Active efflux of drugs and toxic compounds carried out by multidrug transporters is one of the strategies developed by bacterial pathogens to confer multidrug resistance. MATE proteins provide resistance to, e.g., fluoroquinolone, aminoglycoside antibiotics, and anticancer chemotherapeutical agents, thus serving as promising pharmacological targets for tackling a severe global health issue. Based on their amino acid sequence similarity, the MATE family members are classified into the NorM, the DNA-damage-inducible protein F (DinF), and the eukaryotic subfamilies. Structural information on the alternate conformational states and knowledge of the detailed mechanism of the MATE transport are of great importance for the structure-aided drug design. Over the past decade, the crystal structures of representative members of the NorM, DinF and eukaryotic subfamilies have been presented. They all share similar overall architecture comprising 12 transmembrane helices (TMs) divided into two domains, the N-terminal domain (TMs 1-6) and the C-terminal domain (TMs 7-12), connected by a cytoplasmic loop between TM6 and TM7 (Fig. II.1). Since all available MATE family structures are known only in V-shaped outward-facing states with the central binding cavity open towards the extracellular side, a detailed understanding of the complete transport cycle has remained elusive. In order to elucidate the underlying steps of the MATE transport mechanism, structures of distinct intermediates, particularly inward-facing conformation, are required.In my PhD project, structural and functional studies have been performed on a MATE family (DinF subfamily) transporter, PfMATE, from the hyperthermophilic and anaerobic archaeon Pyrococcus furiosus. This protein was produced homologously in Pyrococcus furiosus as well as heterologously in Escherichia coli, and used for the subsequent purification and crystallization trials by the vapor diffusion (VD) and lipidic cubic phase (LCP) method. To the best of my knowledge, PfMATE is the first example of a successful homologous production of a membrane protein in P. furiosus. Due to the very low final amount of the purified protein from the native source, the heterologously produced PfMATE samples were typically used for the extensive structural studies. Crystal structures of PfMATE have been previously determined in an outward-facing conformation in two distinct states (bent and straight) defined on the arrangement of TM1. A pH dependent conformational transition of this helix regulated by the protonation state of the conserved aspartate residue Asp41 was proposed. However, it has been discussed controversially, leading to the hypothesis about TM1 bending to be rather affected by interactions with exogenous lipids (monoolein) present under the crystallization conditions. Based on these open questions, an experimental approach to investigate the role of lipids as structural and functional modulators of PfMATE has been taken in the course of my PhD project. The interplay between membrane proteins and lipids can affect membrane protein topology, structure and function. Considering differences between archaeal and bacterial lipid composition, cultivation of P. furiosus cells and extraction of its lipids was followed by the mass spectrometry (MS) based lipidomics for identification of individual lipid species in the archaeal extract. In order to assess the effects of lipids on PfMATE, different lipid molecules were used for co-purification and co-crystallization trials. This dissertation presents a workflow leading to the structure determination of a MATE transporter in the long sought-after inward-facing state, which has been achieved upon purification and crystallization of the heterologously produced PfMATE in the presence of lipids from its native source P. furiosus. Also, the PfMATE outward-facing state obtained from the crystals grown at the acidic pH conditions sheds light on the previously proposed pH-dependent structural alterations within TM1. It is interesting to note that the inward and outward-facing states of PfMATE were obtained from the crystals grown under similar conditions, but in the presence and absence of native lipids, respectively. This observation supports the hypothesis about physiologically relevant lipids to act as conformational modulators or/and a new class of substrates, expanding the substrate spectrum of the MATE family transporters. Comparative analysis of two PfMATE states reveals that transition from the outward to the inward-facing state involves rigid body movements of TMs 2-6 and 8-12 to form an inverted V, facilitated by a loose binding of TMs 1 and 7 to their respective bundles and their conformational flexibility. Local fluctuations within TM1 in the inward-facing structure, including bending and unwinding in the intracellular half of the helix, invoke its highly flexible nature, which is suitable for ion and substrate gating.
...
Heme-copper oxidases (HCOs) are the terminal enzymes of the aerobic respiratory chain in the inner mitochondrial membrane or the plasma membrane in many prokaryotes. These multi-subunit membrane protein complexes catalyze the reduction of oxygen to water, coupling this exothermic reaction to the establishment of an electrochemical proton gradient across the membrane in which they are embedded. The energy stored in the electrochemical proton gradient is used e.g. by the FOF1-ATP synthase to generate ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate. The superfamily of HCOs is phylogenetically classified into three major families: A, B and C. The A-family HCOs, represented by the well-studied aa3-type cytochrome c oxidases (aa3-CcOs), are found in mitochondria and many bacteria. The B-family of HCOs contains a number of bacterial and archaeal oxidases. The C-family comprises only the cbb3-type cytochrome c oxidase (cbb3-CcO) and is most distantly related to the mitochondrial respiratory oxidases.
The cytochrome bc1 complex or ubiquinol:cytochrome c oxidoreductase (QCR) catalyses electron transfer from ubiquinol to cytochrome c in respiration and photosynthesis coupled to a vectorial proton transport across the membrane, in which the enzyme resides. In both bacteria and eukaryotic organisms, QCR participates in supramolecular assembly of membrane proteins that comprise the respiratory or photosynthetic chain. In the present work, proton transfer pathways, substrate binding and the supramolecular assembly of the respiratory chain in yeast were probed by structure-based site-directed mutagenesis and characterization of the variants. Both active sites centre P, the place of quinol oxidation, and centre N, where quinone reduction takes place, lack direct access to the bulk solvent necessary for proton release and uptake. Based on the X-ray structure, proton transfer pathways were postulated. Analysis at centre P showed, that E272 and Y132 of cytochrome b are important for QCR catalysis as indicated by increased superoxide production and lowered Cyc1p reductase activity in these variants. Pre-steady state heme reduction kinetics in combination with stigmatellin resistance indicated that charge and length of the side chain at position 272 are crucial for efficient docking of the ISP to form the enzyme substrate complex and for electron bifurcation at centre P. Variants of Y312 and F129, both residues of cytochrome b, showed an increased Km indicating participation of these residues in coordination of ubiquinol or the possible intermediate semiquinone anion radical. F129 proved to be crucial for a functional Q-cycle as indicated by respiratory negative growth phenotype and a lowered H+/e- stoichiometry of F129 variants. At centre N, the postulated CL/K and E/R proton transfer pathways are located at opposite sites of the bound ubiquinone. Variants in the surface residues R218 (cytochrome b) and E52 (Qcr7) of the E/R pathway and E82 (Qcr7) of the CL/K pathway showed instability upon purification indicating an important role of these residues for QCR integrity. The slowed down centre N reduction kinetics in H85 (CL/K), R218 and N208 (both E/R) variant was attributed to a destabilised semiquinone anion consistent with the observed decreased sensitivity towards the site-specific inhibitor antimycin and an increased Km. Variants of residues of both pathway, E82Q and R218M, exhibited a decreased H+/e- stoichiometry indicating a crucial role of both residue for maintaining a working Q-cycle and supporting the proposed protonation of the substrate via the Cl/K and the E/R pathway. Long-range interaction between centre N and centre P were observed by altered reduction kinetics of the high potential chain and increased superoxide production in the centre N variants. The role of the cation-pi-interaction between F230 of Cyt1p and R19 of cytochrome c in binding of the redox carrier to QCR was analysed. In F230L hydrophobic interaction were partially lost as was deduced from the ionic strength dependence of Cyc1p reductase activity and Cycp1 binding, as detected by ionic strength sensitive Kd and Km for Cyc1p. The decreased enzymatic rate of F230W could be explained by a disturbed binding of Cyc1p to the variant enzyme. F230 may influence the heme mid point potential and thereby the electron transfer rate to Cyc1p. Reduction of Cobp via both centre P and centre N was disturbed suggesting an interaction between high and low potential chain. Supramolecular association between QCR and cytochrome c oxidase (COX) in yeast mitochondria was probed by affinity chromatography of a his-tagged QCR in the presence of the mild detergent digitonin. In comparison to purification with laurylmaltoside, the presence of both QCR and COX subunits was detected in the elution fractions by SDS-PAGE, Cyc1p reductase and TMPD oxidase activity assays and immunoblot analysis. The CL-dependent formation of the supercomplex between QCR and COX was analysed by replacement variants in the CL-binding site of QCR in CL containing and CL free environment. With an increasing number of replacements of the three lysines the CL-binding pocket supercomplex formation was not abolished, when CL is present as shown by BN-PAGE analysis. This was supported by the synergetic decrease in enzyme activity for both enzymes upon increased number of replacements. In the CL-free environment, no supracomplex formation was observed for a wildtype CL binding site. By replacements of two lysines in the CL-binding pocket, supercomplex formation could be recovered as revealed by BN-PAGE. This indicates, that CL may serve as a charge neutralizer for the lysines near the presumed interaction domain between complex III and complex IV. The obtained results for centre P provide new information of residues critical for stabilisation of ubiquinol and controlling electron short circuit reactions. The observations for centre N variants clearly support the proposed two proton transfer pathways and the role of the bound phospholipids in centre N kinetics. Variants in the Cyc1p binding site suggest a role for F230 both in Cyc1p binding and electron transfer. Clear interaction between the high and low potential chain in both Cyt1p and centre N variants strongly support long-range interactions in the complex. Studies on the supramolecular association of complex III and complex IV indicate a new role of Cl in stabilising a supracomplex.
Membrane proteins play vital role in a variety of cellular processes, such as signal transduction, transport and recognition. In turn they are involved in numerous human diseases and currently represent one of the most prevalent drug targets. A comprehensive understanding of the mechanisms mediated by membrane proteins requires information about their structures at near-atomic resolution, although structural studies of membrane proteins remain behind those of soluble proteins. A bottleneck in the study of membrane proteins resides in the difficulties that are encountered during their high-level production in cell based systems. However, many toxic effects attributed to the over production of membrane proteins are eliminated by cell-free expression, as viable host cells are no longer required. Therefore, the objective of this study was to obtain adequate amounts of selected membrane transport proteins for their structural studies using a cell-free expression system. For the establishment of the cell-free system for membrane proteins, the transporters YbgR and YiiP from Salmonella typhimurium LT2, PF0558 and PF1373 from Pyrococcus furiosus, from the cation diffusion family (CDF), BetP from Corynebacterium glutamicum from the betaine/carnitine/choline transporter (BCCT) family and Aq-2030 from Aquifex aeolicus VF5 from the monovalent cation/proton antiporter-2 (CPA2) family were selected. An Escherichia coli S-30 extract based cellfree system was established by generating the best expression constructs of the target proteins, preparing T7 RNA polymerase and an S-30 extract with high translation efficiency. The functionality of the S-30 extract was shown by the cell-free expression of correctly folded Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP). Essential factors of the cell-free system such as the Mg2+ concentration, the bacterial S-30 extract proportion in the reaction mixture and the time-course of cell-free reactions have been optimized. For the cell-free production of membrane proteins in soluble form, the possibility to supplement cell-free reactions with detergents was explored. A wide range of non-ionic or zwitterionic detergents, were found to be compatible with cell-free synthesis, while ionic detergents and non-ionic detergents at high concentrations had an inhibitory effect. Moreover, high concentrations of polyoxyethylene-alkyl-ethers (Brij) detergents were found to have enhancing effect on the production levels as well as on the solubility of cell-free produced proteins. As membrane proteins tend to misfold and aggregate in a membrane-free translation system, the possibility to supplement the cell-free reactions with inner membrane vesicles (IMVs) to obtain correctly folded target transport proteins was explored. All the target proteins were successfully produced in the batch cell-free reactions and were found to be incorporated in the IMVs. A continuous exchange cell-free (CECF) system was established, where consumable substrates (amino acids, nucleotides and energy regenerating compounds) were supplied to the cell-free reaction mixture through a dialysis membrane, which in consequence resulted in high-level production of target proteins compared to the batch system. The osmosensing and osmoregulated sodium-coupled symporter BetP from C. glutamicum was chosen for the large scale production in CECF set-up. The protein is easily produced in E. coli and is functional as assayed by its transport activity, after purification and reconstitution in liposomes. It is therefore possible to compare in-vivo and cell-free production. High-level cell-free production of BetP was achieved in CECF mode in different forms: (i) as precipitate, (ii) as soluble form in detergent, and (iii) incorporated in IMVs. Cell-free production of BetP resulted in the yield of about 0.5 mg of purified BetP from 1 ml of CECF reaction. The yield of purified BetP was increased to 1.6 fold by addition of 1% polyoxyethylene-(20)-cetyl-ether (Brij58) detergent in the reaction mixture. Moreover, the high level cell-free production of BetP (0.5 mg purified BetP/ml reaction mixture) incorporated in IMVs was shown for the first time in this work.However, it was observed that oligomerization of BetP was not efficient in the cell-free system. Factors that can promote the folding of membrane proteins such as lipids and chaperones were investigated. Addition of lipids and molecular chaperone GroE facilitated correct folding of BetP resulting in increased yield and stability of cell-free produced BetP. The results obtained indicate that most of the cell-free produced BetP exists in functional oligomeric form. The possibility of obtaining milligram amounts of BetP, a 12 trans-membrane protein from the cell-free reactions holds promise for structural and functional studies of other membrane proteins. In any case, the strategies adapted in this study should prove extremely valuable for the production of membrane proteins in the E. coli cell-free expression system.
Membrane proteins are biological macromolecules that are located in a cell’s membrane and are responsible for essential functions within an organism, which makes them to prominent drug targets. The extraction of membrane proteins from the hydrophobic membrane bilayer to determine high-resolution crystal structures is a difficult task and only 2% of all solved proteins structures are membrane proteins. Computational methods may help to gain deeper insights into membrane protein structures and their functions. This study will give an overview of such computational methods on a representative set of membrane proteins and will provide ideas for future computational and experimental research on membrane proteins.
In a first step (chapter 2), I updated an earlier, manually-curated data set of homologous membrane proteins (HOMEP) to more recent versions in 2010 (HOMEP2) and 2013 (HOMEP3) using an automated clustering approach. High-resolution structures of membrane proteins listed in the PDB_TM database were structurally aligned and subsequently clustered using structural similarity scores. Both data sets were used as a standard gold reference set for subsequent work.
Subsequently, I have updated and applied the sequence alignment program AlignMe to determine protein descriptors that are suitable for detecting evolutionary relationship between homologous a-helical membrane proteins. Single input descriptors were tested alone and in combination with each other in different modes of AlignMe by optimizing gap penalties on the HOMEP2 data set. Most accurate alignments and homology models on the HOMEP2 data set were observed when using position-specific substitution information (P), secondary structure propensities (S) and transmembrane propensities (T) in the AlignMe PST mode. An evaluation on an independent reference set of membrane protein sequence alignments from the BAliBASE collection showed that different modes of AlignMe are suitable for different sequence similarity levels. The AlignMe PST mode improved the alignment accuracy significantly for distantly related proteins, whereas for closely-related proteins from the BAliBASE set the AlignMe PS mode was more suitable. This work was published in March 2013 in PLOS ONE. In order to allow also an easier usage of the AlignMe program, I have implemented a web server of AlignMe (chapter 4) that provides the optimized settings and gap penalties for the AlignMe P, PS and PST modes. A comparison to other recent alignment web server shows that the alignments of AlignMe are similar or even more accurate than those of other methods, especially for very distantly related proteins for which the inclusion of membrane protein information has been shown to be suitable. This work was published in the NAR web server issue in July 2014.
Although membrane-specific information has been shown to be suitable for aligning distantly related membrane proteins on a sequence level, such information was not incorporated into structural alignment programs making it unclear which method is the most suitable for aligning membrane proteins. Thus, I compared 13 widely-used pairwise structural alignment methods on an updated reference set of homologous membrane protein structures (HOMEP3) and evaluated their accuracy by building models based on the underlying sequence alignments and used scoring functions (e.g., AL4 or CAD-score) to rate the model accuracy (chapter 5). The analysis showed that fragment-based approaches such as FR-TM-align are the most useful for aligning structures of membrane proteins that have undergone large conformational changes whereas rigid approaches were more suitable for proteins that were solved in the same or a similar state. However, no method showed a significant higher accuracy than any other. Additionally, all methods lack a measure to rate the reliability of the accuracy for a specific position within a structure alignment. In order to solve these problems, I propose a consensus-type approach that combines alignments from four different methods, namely FR-TM-align, DaliLite, MATT and FATCAT and assigns a confidence value to each position of the alignment that describes the agreement between the methods. This work has been published 2015 in the journal “PROTEINS: structure, function and bioinformatics”.
Consensus alignments were then generated for each pair of proteins of the HOMEP3 data set and subsequently analyzed for single evolutionary events within membrane spanning segments and for irregular structures (e.g., 310- and p-helices) (chapter 6). Interestingly, single insertions and deletions could be observed with the help of consensus alignments in the conserved membrane-spanning segments of membrane proteins in four protein families. The detection of such single InDels might help to identify crucial residues for a proteins function.
G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) comprise the largest superfamily of cell surface receptors and possess a signature motif of seven transmembrane helices. The endothelin B (ETB) receptor is a member of rhodopsin like GPCR family. It plays an important role in vasodilation and is found in the membranes of the endothelial cells enveloping blood vessels. Knowledge of the three-dimensional structure of G-protein coupled receptors in general would significantly add to our understanding of their molecular mechanisms and would be useful in the search for new specific drugs. However, three-dimensional structural analysis will require milligram quantities of pure and homogeneous protein. This dissertation is a study of the production, biochemical characterization and preliminary structural studies of the human ETB G-protein coupled receptor. The present work aimed at elucidating the structure and mechanistic details of function of the receptor by using a combination of X-ray crystallographic and NMR methods for collecting structural data. To obtain homogenous and monodisperse receptor protein preparation for structural and functional studies, we implemented the baculovirus expression system for the production of ETB receptor for the present work. The two step affinity purification ensured capture of full-length receptor. Silver stained SDS-PAGE of the purified receptor-ligand complex indicated greater than 90% protein purity. Based on previous reports, we used the high affinity ligand (endothelin -1) binding to the receptor for co-crystallization of receptor-ligand complex by locking the receptor in the activated conformation. As a prerequisite for 3D crystallization trials, the stability of the detergent solubilized receptor-ligand complex was assessed with respect to pH, temperature and time. Receptor-ligand complex did not show any degradation and aggregation over 6 days at 4°C and 18°C. Interestingly, change of pH suggested that receptor-ligand complex is unstable at lower pH due to possible charge induced conformational changes. In our work, we introduced the idea of using fluorophore labeled ligand for simple visual recognition of the receptor-ligand complex during purification and crystallization. On the other hand, we alternatively used biotinylated endothelin-1 to produce an adequate amount of ligand bound receptor complex, thus ensuring homogeneity of the purified complex for use in structural studies. Thus far, preliminary crystals have been obtained for both the unlabelled ET-1 and fluorophore labeled ET-1 complexed with ETB receptor. Moreover, we performed the systematic investigation of the protein/peptide binding partner for the receptor-ligand complex with the chief aims of stabilizing structure and increasing the possibilities of 3D-crystal contacts. Thus subsequent to formation of receptor-ligand complex, the additional in vitro formation of a ternary arrestin-receptor-ligand complex was also attempted for use in structural studies. We successfully demonstrated that arrestin mutant (R169E) forms a tight complex with ETB receptor regardless of its phosphorylation state. A second approach to get insight into the ETB receptor ligand binding site relied on the use of spin isotope labeled ET-1 ligand peptide by employing solid state MAS NMR method. Preliminary data provided compelling evidence that the C-terminal region of the peptide is immobilized in an ordered environment and presumably bound to the receptor. This indicates that the approach is feasible, although there are difficulties in sample preparation for further spectral measurements and data collection which are currently being discussed in ongoing investigations. At this point of our research work, we initiated a collaborative effort to obtain high yields of pure, active receptor without post translational modifications, from an E. coli cell lysate based in vitro expression system. We successfully optimized the production of homogenous and monodisperse endothelin B receptor in mg amounts. Thus this could potentially provide an alternative source of high quality receptor production in large quantities for immediate crystallization trials. Thus we hope that the results from these investigations can be applied in a more general sense to the production and crystallization of other G protein-coupled receptors.