Refine
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (5)
Language
- English (5)
Has Fulltext
- yes (5)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (5)
Keywords
- DEER (1)
- DNS (1)
- Elektronenspinresonanz (1)
- Elektronenspinresonanzspektroskopie (1)
- Nitroxylradikal (1)
- PELDOR (1)
Institute
- Biochemie und Chemie (5) (remove)
Pulsed electron–electron double resonance (PELDOR) spectroscopy is a powerful tool for measuring nanometer distances in spin-labeled systems and recently is increasingly applied to membrane proteins. However, after reconstitution of labeled proteins into liposomes, spin labels often exhibit a much faster transversal relaxation (Tm) than in detergent micelles, thus limiting application of the method in lipid bilayers. In the first part of the thesis, optimization of transversal relaxation in phospholipid membranes was systematically investigated by use of spin-labeled derivatives of stearic acid and phosphatidylcholine as well as spin-labeled derivatives of the channel-forming peptide gramicidin A under the conditions typically employed for PELDOR distance measurements. Our results clearly show that dephasing due to instantaneous diffusion that depends on dipolar interaction among electron spins is an important contributor to the fast echo decay in cases of high local concentrations of spin labels in membranes. The main difference between spin labels in detergent micelles and membranes is their local concentration. Consequently, avoiding spin aggregation and suppressing instantaneous diffusion is the key step for maximizing PELDOR sensitivity in lipid membranes. Even though proton spin diffusion is an important relaxation mechanism, only in samples with low local concentrations does deuteration of acyl chains and buffer significantly prolong Tm. In these cases, values of up to 7 μs have been achieved. Furthermore, our study revealed that membrane composition and labeling position in the membrane can also affect Tm, either by promoting the segregation of spin-labeled species or by altering their exposure to matrix protons. Effects of other experimental parameters including temperature (<50 K), presence of oxygen, and cryoprotectant type are negligible under our experimental conditions.
In the second part of the thesis, inhomogeneous distribution of spin-labels in detergent micelles has been studied. A common approach in PELDOR is measuring the distance between two covalently attached spin labels in a macromolecule or singly-labeled components of an oligomer. This situation has been described as a spin-cluster. The PELDOR signal, however, does not only contain the desired dipolar coupling between the spin-labels of the molecule or cluster under study. In samples of finite concentration the dipolar coupling between the spin-labels of the randomly distributed molecules or spin-clusters also contributes significantly. In homogeneous frozen solutions or lipid vesicle membranes this second contribution can be considered to be an exponential or stretched exponential decay, respectively. In this study, it is shown that this assumption is not valid in detergent micelles. Spin-labeled fatty acids that are randomly partitioned into different detergent micelles give rise to PELDOR time traces which clearly deviate from stretched exponential decays. As a main conclusion a PELDOR signal deviating from a stretched exponential decay does not necessarily prove the observation of specific distance information on the molecule or cluster. These results are important for the interpretation of PELDOR experiments on membrane proteins or lipophilic peptides solubilized in detergent micelles or small vesicles, which often do not show pronounced dipolar oscillations in their time traces.
In the third part, PELDOR has been utilized to study the structural flexibility of the Toc34 GTPase homodimer, a preprotein receptor of the translocon of the outer envelope of chloroplasts (TOC). Toc34 belongs to GAD subfamily of G-proteins that are regulated and activated by nucleotide-dependent dimerization. However, the function of Toc34 dimerization is not yet fully understood. Previous structural investigations of the Toc34 dimer yielded only marginal structural changes in response to different nucleotide loads. PELDOR revealed a nucleotide-dependent transition of the dimer flexibility from a tight GDP to a flexible GTP-loaded state. Substrate-binding stabilizes the dimer in the transition state mimicked by GDP-AlFx, but induces an opening in the GDP or GTP-loaded state. Thus, the structural dynamics of bona fide GTPases induced by GTP hydrolysis is replaced by substrate-dependent dimer flexibility, which represents the regulatory mode for dimerizing GTPases.
In the fourth part of the thesis, conformational flexibility and relative orientation of the N-terminal POTRA domains of a cyanobacterial Omp85 from Anabaena sp. PCC 7120, a key component of the outer membrane protein assembly machinery, were investigated by PELDOR spectroscopy. Membrane proteins of the Omp85-TpsB superfamily are composed of a C-terminal β-barrel and a different number of N-terminal POTRA domains, three in the case of cyanobacterial Omp85. It has been suggested that the N-terminal POTRA domains (P1 and P2) might have functions in substrate recognition. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations predicted a fixed orientation for P2 and P3 and a flexible hinge between P1 and P2. The PELDOR distances measured between the P2 and P3 POTRA domains are in good agreement with the structure determined by X-ray, and compatible with the MD simulations suggesting a fixed orientation between these domains. PELDOR constraints between the P1 and P2 POTRA domains imply a rather rigid structure with a slightly different relative orientation of these domains compared with the X-ray structure. Moreover, the large mobility predicted from MD is not observed in the frozen solution. The PELDOR results further highlight the restricted relative orientation of the POTRA domains of the Omp85-TpsB proteins as a conserved characteristic feature that might be important for the processive sliding of the unfolded substrate towards the membrane.
One of the most important tasks in chemistry and especially in structural biology has always been the elucidation of three-dimensional molecular structures - either of small molecules or large biopolymers. Among the (bio)physical methods to acquire structural data at atomic resolution electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy is the most valuable technique for obtaining structural information about many different kinds of paramagnetic species. In biological systems, either paramagnetic metal ions/clusters, transient paramagnetic intermediates in electron transfer processes or artificially attached stable spin labels can be found. The usual approach to interpret EPR spectra is to perform simulations based on the so-called spin Hamiltonian (SH). This means that the well-defined numerical parameters (tensors) in the SH representing different types of interaction are obtained by fitting the experimental data. The SH parameters include electronic g-values, hyperfine coupling (HFC) and quadrupole coupling (&C) constants, zero-field splittings and constants to describe exchange and dipolar interactions between electron spin systems. However, since the SH only contains spin degrees of freedom, a direct translation of the SH EPR parameters into structural information is not straightforward. Therefore, methods to predict such SH interaction parameters starting from molecular structures are required. In this thesis it was investigated whether quantum chemical calculations of EPR parameters based on density functional theory (DFT) methods may be employed to overcome these problems thus enabling a correlation of experimental EPR data with molecular structure. It was the central goal of this work to point out the potential of a fruitful interplay between quantum chemistry and experiment and to study how both can benefit from each other. For this purpose DFT methods were applied to a variety of organic radical or transition metal systems to calculate different EPR parameters. Using the 'broken symmetry' formalism it was possible to compute the exchange coupling constant for a nitroxide biradical and furthermore decompose the exchange mechanism in different through-bond and through-space interactions. Spin density distributions, 14N and 1H HFC constants as well as dipole moments and polarizabilities were computed for a number of aromatic nitroxides to examine their properties and select promising candidates which may serve as DNA-intercalating spin labels. Systematic investigations of the influence of hydrogen bond geometry on the 14N QC parameters for imidazole-water and methylimidazole-benzosemiquinone complexes lead to the conclusion that especially the imidazole amino nitrogen &C parameters are very sensitive probes of the bond geometry, in particular of the hydrogen bond length. The results of this study may be applied to biological systems, e.g. to gain structural information about quinone binding sites. Moreover, quantum chemical methods were applied to elucidate the structure of a nitrogen-centered radical intermediate in the inhibition process of ribonucleotide reductase (RNR). It was possible to find a molecular structure in accordance with all experimentally available data, thus revealing the longsought structure of the No radical and providing evidence for the trapping of a 3'-ketonucleotide in the reduction process catalyzed by RNR. To test the capability of modern DFT methods to predict g- and molybdenum HFC tensors for MoV complexes, validation studies were carried out. Comparison of computed EPR parameters of a number of MoV compounds with corresponding experimental values showed that g- and HFC tensors could be predicted in good accuracy, although some systematic errors of the computational methods have to be considered for such heavy 4d1 transition meta1 systems. Furthermore, DFT calculations on a Mn2+ binding site model of the hammerhead ribozyme allowed to conclude that the structure of the binding site as studied by EPR spectroscopy in frozen solution is very likely to be identical to the site found occupied by Mn2+ in crystals. Finally, computational methods were employed to aid in the structural characterization of the Mn2+ binding site in Ras (rat sarcoma protein) by providing accurate starting parameters for spectral simulations and furthermore helping to interpret the experimental data. In conclusion, it was demonstrated in this thesis that the combination of sophisticated experimental and quantum chemical methods represents a powerful approach in the field of EPR spectroscopy and that it may be essential to employ EPR parameter computations to extract the full information content from EPR spectra. Therefore, great potential lies in future applications of DFT methods to the large number of systems where detailed and reliable experimental data is available but where an unequivocal correlation of these data with structural information is still lacking.
Pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR), also called Double Electron-Electron Resonance, (DEER) is a pulsed EPR technique that can provide structural information of biomolecules, such as proteins or nucleic acids, complementary to other structure determination methods by measuring long distances (from 1.5 up to 10 nm) between two paramagnetic labels. Incorporation of the rigid Ç-label pairwise into DNA or RNA molecules enables the determination not only of the distance but also of the mutual orientation between the two Ç-labels by multi-frequency orientation-selective PELDOR data (X-, Q- and G-band frequencies). Thus, information about the orientation of secondary structure elements of nucleic acids can be revealed and used as additional angular information for structure determination. Since Ç does not have motion independent from the helix where it resides, the conformational flexibility of the nucleic acid molecule can be directly determined. This thesis demonstrates the advancement of PELDOR spectroscopy, beyond its original scope of distance measurements, to determine the mutual orientation between two rigid spin labels towards the characterization of the conformational space sampled by highly flexible nucleic acid molecules. Applications of the methodology are shown on two systems: a three-way junction, namely a cocaine aptamer in its bound-state, and a two-way junction, namely a bent DNA.
More in detail, the conformational changes of the cocaine aptamer upon cocaine binding were investigated by analysis of the distance distributions. The cocaine-bound and the unbound states could be differentiated by their conformational flexibility, which decreases in the presence of the ligand. Moreover, the obtained distance distributions revealed a small change in the mean distance between the two spin labels upon cocaine binding. This indicates a ligand-induced conformational change, which presumably originates at the junction where cocaine is known to bind. The investigation of the relative orientation between the two spin-labeled helices of the aptamer revealed further structural insights into the conformational dynamics of the cocaine-bound state. The angular information from the orientation-selective PELDOR data and the a priori knowledge about the secondary structure of the aptamer were helpful in obtaining a molecular model describing its global folding and flexibility. In spite of a large flexible aptamer, the kink angle between the Ç-labeled helices was found to be rather well-defined.
As for the bent DNA molecule, a two-step protocol was proposed to investigate the conformational flexibility. In the first step, a database with all the possible conformers was created, using available restraints from NMR and distance restraints derived from PELDOR. In a second step, a weighted ensemble of these conformers fitting the multi-frequency PELDOR data was built. The uniqueness of the obtained structural ensemble was checked by validation against an independent PELDOR data set recorded at a higher magnetic field strength. In addition, the kink and twist angle pairs were determined and the resulting structural ensemble was compared with the conformational space deduced both from FRET experiments and from the structure determined by the NMR restraints alone.
Overall, this thesis underlines the potential of using PELDOR spectroscopy combined with rigid spin labels in the context of structure determination of nucleic acids in order to determine the relative orientation between two helices, the conformational flexibility and the conformational changes of nucleic acid molecules upon ligand binding.
Pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR) is a pulsed EPR method that can reliably and precisely provide structural information regarding duplex RNAs and DNAs by measuring long-range distances (1.5-7 nm) utilizing distance-dependent magnetic dipole-dipole interaction between two nitroxide spin labels. In this thesis the application field of PELDOR spectroscopy has been expanded. For the first time the global architecture of tertiary folded RNA has been mapped in vitro. Moreover, the first application of PELDOR for determining structural aspects of RNA and DNA molecules inside cells has been presented. RNA has the central role in cellular processes and gene regulation. It can adopt complex three dimensional structures, which in combination with its conformational dynamics is essential for its function as biological catalyst, structural scaffold and regulator of gene expression. Riboswitches are cis-acting RNA segments that modulate gene expression by direct binding of small molecules with high affinity and specificity. Neomycin-responsive riboswitch is an engineered riboswitch developed by combination of in vitro selection and in vivo screening. Upon insertion into the 5‟ untranslated region of mRNA and binding the cognate ligand it is able to inhibit translational initiation in yeast. Using enzymatic probing the secondary structure had been postulated comprising global stem-loop architecture with a terminal and an internal loop. In the first part of this thesis, the global conformational arrangement of this 27 nucleotides long RNA element has been studied by means of site-directed spin labeling and PELDOR spectroscopy. Spin-labeled neomycin-responsive riboswitch mutants were synthesized via a Sonogashira cross-coupling reaction between 5-membered pyrroline ring based nitroxide radical (TPA) and 5-iodo-uridine. The labeling positions were chosen outside of the binding pocket and UV melting curves revealed that spin-labeling neither disturbs the secondary structure nor interferes with ligand binding. Efficient ligand binding was proven by thermal stabilization of 20.3±3.3 oC upon addition of neomycin, as well as by cw EPR spectra. PELDOR time traces with long observation time windows and with good signal to noise ratio and modulation depth were recorded for all double-labeled samples allowing a reliable data analysis. The fact that there were no shifts in the measured distances upon addition of neomycin implied the existence of a prearranged tertiary structure of the neomycin-sensing riboswitch without a significant global conformational change induced by ligand binding. Measured distances were in very good agreement with the NMR structure of the ligand-bound state of the riboswitch indicating the intrinsic propensity of the global RNA architecture toward its energetically favored ligand-bound form at low temperature. The results harvested in this work represent the first application of PELDOR for mapping the global structure of a tertiary folded RNA. In the second part of this thesis the possibility of applying PELDOR on nucleic acids (NAs) in cellular environment has been investigated. It was shown before that global NA structure depends on matrix conditions, such as concentration of ions and small molecules, molecular crowding, viscosity and interactions with proteins. Therefore, PELDOR spectroscopy on a double-labeled 12-base pair DNA duplex, the 14-mer cUUCGg tetraloop hairpin RNA and the 27-mer neomycin-sensing riboswitch has been used to obtain long-range distance constraints on such systems in Xenopus laevis oocytes and to compare them with in vitro measurements. The reduced lifetime of nitroxide spin labels under cellular conditions has been a major challenge in these measurements. Investigation of nitroxide reduction kinetics in-cell has revealed that the 5-membered pyrrolidine and pyrroline rings are significantly slower reduced compared to 6-membered piperidine ring based nitroxides. Due to prolonged lifetime of the TPA nitroxides covalently attached to NA molecules PELDOR signals could be measured with good signal-to-noise ratios up to 70 minutes of incubation time. The partial loss of coupled spin labels due to nitroxide reduction only led to a decrease in the modulation depth upon increasing the incubation time. No alterations in the measured distances between in vitro and in-cell experiments implies the existence of stable overall conformations of the 14-mer cUUCGg tetraloop hairpin RNA and the 27-mer neomycin-sensing riboswitch, whereas the 12-bp duplex DNA experiences stacking in-cell but retaining the secondary structure. Thus, for the first time nanometer distance measurements were performed inside cells, clearly laying a foundation for the application of PELDOR spectroscopy to study biological processes in cells, such as diffusion, interaction with proteins and other factors or chemical reactions.
This thesis demonstrates the advancement of PELDOR spectroscopy beyond its original design of distance measurements in order to disentangle a maximum amount of information additionally encoded in the PELDOR data. In particular, the successful synthesis of novel polynitroxide radicals is described as well as the extraction of the relative orientation of spin labels, conformational flexibility and the separation of dipolar and exchange coupling via orientation selective PELDOR measurements in combination with PESIM based simulations. Moreover, the method of PELDOR "Spin Counting" was experimentally validated.