Journal of religious culture = Journal für Religionskultur
Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
- Part of Periodical (317)
Has Fulltext
- yes (317)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (317)
Keywords
- Islam (5)
- Tafsīr (3)
- Taṣawwuf (3)
- Islamic Mystical Exegesis (2)
- Moses (2)
- Qurʾān (2)
- Religion (2)
- at-Tafsīr al-išārī (2)
- Ḫiḍr (2)
- Addiction (1)
Institute
139
Grace in Sikhism
(2010)
As in all other religions there are two contrary streaming in Sikhism too. One teaches that meaning and value of human existence depends on the human works which we call the operative model. The other streaming preaches that the Holy’s grace is the substance of men’s ultimate destination, and it alone gives meaning to their existence; this position we call the receptive model. As the third streaming we can identify the doctrine of conditioned gratification which means that the humans get Divine support for achieving the salvation of their souls. This third one is obviously the predominant model in all religions. The religious books of the Sikhs have incorporated all positions. Therefore they are widespread and popular. Everybody finds what suits to him. We will reconstruct the receptive model as it is shown in Nitnem, where the daily prayers od the Sikhs are collected.
62
First, why I have avoided to use in this paper the expression ‘the Composite Culture’, which even is used in our Constitution of India to describe unified one culture of our country.1 It is because such a demand is not only against one of the basic realities of our Indian way of life, it also goes against the divine will, which was and is behind this created world with different shades and colours. In this regard the following observation made by Dr. Ram Singh is also noteworthy: It is debatable issue whether there is a separate entity called “composite culture” of India, or it is merely the interaction of various cultures which, instead of resulting into an integrated culture, are still in a position to maintain their separate identities. Beside what Dr. Ram Singh says, the reality is that multi or pluralism is part of our Indian or even Asian way of life. It is quite a different thing, if some of us are not willing to accept this truth. But it is still there, in the form of multi-cultures, multi-languages, multireligions and multiethnicities. Therefore the question of ‘composite culture’ is not only debatable, but also a doubtful principle, unless we are willing to take it as an eschatology reality. I do not intend to deal with this point in detail here, because of the time factor. But we may be able to come back to this question of ‘composite culture, in our discussion if you will wish to do so. ...
27-10
Disziplin kann man nicht in äußeren Dingen finden, wie in der Erde, den Steinen oder Bergen, sondern nur im Inneren fühlender Wesen. Als gewöhnliche Menschen — Frauen wie Männer — sind wir uns darin gleich, Fehler und Qualitäten zu haben. Unter dem Einfluß von Leidenschaften — sogenannten klesas (nyon mongs) — wie Begierde, Wut oder Zorn, Stolz und Neid schaden wir anderen durch die zehn unheilsamen Handlungen von Körper, Sprache und Geist: Töten, Stehlen, Sexuelles Fehlverhalten, Lügen, Verleumden, grobe Rede, unsinniges Geschwätz, Habgier, Übelwollen und verkehrte Ansichten. Ab und zu entwickeln wir Vertrauen, liebevolle Zuneigung oder Mitgefühl und führen, davon motiviert, einige heilsame Handlungen durch, stehen anderen hilfreich zur Seite und nützen sogar der Gesellschaft.
237
Strong imprints of Indian culture in various forms or modes of expressions are significantly found in Java. Sanskrit-Old Javanese texts, amongst those texts and traditions, were produced in the island in the periods between 9th to 15th cen. A.D. It covers various genres and subjects enriching indigenous culture in the archipelago. Tutur or tattva texts were one genre of them recorded the dynamic of Javanese intellectuals or poet-sages in pursuing the truth; they reveal metaphysical or theological aspects of Brahmanism, Saivism, Buddhism, Tantrism, Samkhya, Yoga, etc. This paper attempts to study ideas behind the Hindi transliteration and translation of those texts. This is a library reserach, the data were collected from Hindi translation of those texts. This attempt is of high scientific and cultural values as Indian scholars paid attention to Indian culture spreading in foreign lands. With this attempt Indian intellectuals/scholars/students got acquainted with their own culture flourished outside India in different forms, since the works were written and produced in Devanagari script and Hindi language. It creates nuances of being Indian. It can widen their understanding on philosophical point of view, religious elements, and culture of Java, that unity in diversity does not only exist in native land but also abroad.
59
Hindus in Deutschland
(2002)
Der Hinduismus galt in Deutschland in erster Linie als eine akademische oder exotische Angelegenheit. Die altindische Philologie hat ihn in einer mehr archaischen Gestalt bekannt gemacht, zugleich aber auch religiös neutralisiert. Diese Rezeption der Hindu Religiosität hat dann zu dem geführt, was man westliche Hinduismusideologie bezeichnen könnte. Aus dem Gefühl der globalen Überlegenheit heraus sah man den Hinduismus gleichsam als eine exotisch-buntscheckige Kuh an, die keine heute verwertbare Milch mehr liefert. Ihn für das tatsächliche Leben und dessen kulturellreligiöse Ausgestaltung zu verwenden, konnte und wollte ein sog. aufgeklärter Bürger nicht wagen. In existentieller Hinsicht war das Hindutum tabu. Erst der systematische Theologe Rudolf Otto hat in einer Phase des 20. Jahrhunderts, in dem die religiöse Intoleranz ganz besonders und gerade auch theologisch triumphierte, auf Grund persönlicher Erfahrung die reale religiöse Relevanz des Hindutums unüberhörbar zur Sprache gebracht. Indem er sich der existentiellen Konfrontation mit dem Hindutum stellte, entdeckte er als Angehöriger der westlichen Kultur dessen Wahrheitswürde. Er konnte den Hinduismus nicht mehr als bloß historisch interessantes, aber erledigtes Phänomen der menschlichen Geistesgeschichte betrachten und im übrigen zur christlichen Tagesordnung übergehen. Seine existentielle Erfahrung ließ ihm keine andere Wahl: Der Hinduismus ist eine gewaltige Symbolik des Heiligen. ...
20
Weekly "VIVEK" recently conducted a survey of the opinions of its readers. One of the readers wrote, 'I am a devotee of Shri Ram; I belong to a certain caste; the concept of Hindutva may be all right for you; but how is this Hindutva beneficial to my caste?" This question may be regarded as either very basic or childish. It is basic because its answer devolves on the proper concept of Hin-dutva and it is childish because it displays the ignorance of the reader of the fact that Hindutva encompasses the well-being of all the different section of people. A person like me, having imbibed the concept of Hindutva in its totality, would be quick to answer that different casts cannot have any special consideration for them. Hindutva is a casteless concept. In fact the removal of caste consciousness and caste identities is the raison d'etre of Hindutva. Since Hindutva incorporates the well-being of every single Hindu the question of any special consideration of any particular caste does not arise. Of course this is simple for a person like me who is steeped in the Hindutva concept. It may not be so simple for someone who has come up in the present political environment. Serious consideration must be given to Hindutva against the background of pre-sent atmosphere of caste consciousness. This would narrow and finally eliminate the chasm between ideals and practice. Such a chasm would be a great impedi-ment to the general acceptance of true nationalism.
57 b
Toplumumuza ve siyasetimize sadece sorulması gerekmeyen, aynı zamanda cevap da verilmesi gereken hayati önemdeki sorulardan biri, çeşitli kültürlerin yaşama imkanına sahip oldukları bir toplum ve farklı dinler de dahil olmak üzere farklı kültürlerin barış içinde bir arada yaşamalarını isteyen ve güvenceye alan bir devlet isteyip istemediğimizdir. Bu soru asla yeni bir soru değildir; tarihte ve her yerde tekrar tekrar sorulmuştur. Do-layısıyla insanlar bu sorunla ilgili tecrübelere sahip olmuştur. Yeni bir durumla karşı karşıya değiliz....
12b
That God has to become man in order to reveal the being of God to mankind is a belief not only held by Christianity. In Bhagavata Purana, one of the holy scriptures of Hinduism, God Vishnu speaks the sentence quoted above when he is incarnated as Krishna. In a world getting ever smaller, awareness of other religions gains more and more importance. It is my purpose to show what contribution the theological field I represent, ecclesiastical history or historical theology,1 may make towards getting to know other religions and seeking dialogue with them. I will use the worship of Krishna in the following text to exemplify my propositions. My explanations are set out in five parts: (I) two traditions of how God became man; (II) the problem and purpose of inter-religious encounter; (III) historical theology as history; (IV) historical theology as theology; (V) thoughts about dialogue with other religions as an encounter between two things of comparable significance.
12a
Daß Gott Mensch werden müsse, um den Menschen das Wesen Gottes zu offenbaren, ist kein ausschließlich im Christentum verbreiteter Gedanke. Im Bhagavata Purana, einer der heiligen Schriften der Hindus, spricht Gott Vishnu bei Gelegenheit seiner Menschwerdung als Krishna den oben zitierten Satz. In einer immer kleiner wer-denden Welt gewinnt die gegenseitige Wahrnehmung der Religionen immer größere Bedeutung. Meine Absicht ist es, mich im folgenden darüber zu äußern, welchen Beitrag die von mir vertretene theologische Disziplin, die Kirchengeschichte oder historische Theologie, dazu leisten kann, andere Religionen zur Kenntnis zu nehmen und das Gespräch mit ihnen zu suchen. Als Bezugspunkt dient mir im folgenden die Krishna-Verehrung. Meine Ausführungen gliedern sich in fünf Abschnitte: – Zwei Überlieferung, wie Gott Mensch wurde. – Problemstellung und Aufgabe der interreligiösen Begegnung. – Historische Theologie nach ihrer geschichtlichen Seite. – Historische Theologie nach ihrer theologischen Seite. – Überlegungen zum Gespräch mit anderen Religionen als Begegnung zwischen ähnlichen Größen.
41
Das Thema "Frauen und Islam" löst bei vielen Menschen in westlichen Gesellschaften eine Assoziationskette aus, in der unweigerlich Stichworte wie "Harem", "Patriarchat", "Verschleierung" und "Unterdrückung" vorkommen. Titelseiten von Romanen, reißerischen Berichten oder wissenschaftlichen Veröffentlichungen über muslimische Frauen werden stets mit denselben stereotypen Wort- und Bildkombinationen versehen, die Verschleierung und Abschließung als vorherrschende Merkmale weiblichen Lebens in islamischen Gesellschaften darstellen. Der Islam erscheint als eine ausgeprägt patriarchale Religion, die von Frauen nur erduldet und nicht gestaltet wird. Frauen werden als passive Objekte islamisch geprägter religiöser und gesellschaftlicher Normen, nicht als handelnde Subjekte aufgefaßt. Die Position von Frauen in islamischen Gesellschaften wird entweder an westlichen Gesellschaften oder an normativen Aussagen religiöser Schriften gemessen, was in beiden Fällen wenig Raum für die Ansichten der muslimischen Frauen selbst läßt.
234
Die Interpretation der Moses-Ḫiḍr-Erzählung in Ibn ʿArabīs Werken „al-Futūḥāt al-Makkīya“und „Fuṣūṣ al-ḥikam“
Die Moses-Ḫiḍr-Erzählung in den Versen 60-82 der Sura Kahf, der in der sufischen Tradition eine enorme Bedeutung zugemessen wird, wurde im Laufe der Geschichte zum Gegenstand unterschiedlicher Interpretationen. Es besteht somit kein Zweifel, dass eine der bemerkenswertesten dieser Interpretationen, die einen besonderen Platz in der Geschichte des Sufismus hat, von Ibn ʿArabī stammt. Er bewertete die Ereignisse zwischen Moses und der koranischen Figur, die er entsprechend der Tradition „Ḫiḍr” benannt hat, anders. Neben der literarischen Bedeutung der Personen und Ereignisse, die in der Erzählung vorkommen, etabliert Ibn Arabi dazu neue Zusammenhänge, indem er zu deren verborgenen Bedeutungen übergeht. Nach ihm ist nichts so, wie es scheint
281
87
Es besteht kein Zweifel daran, dass die einflussreichsten Persönlichkeiten der islamischen Gesellschaft die Gelehrten des Islam waren. Die Verhaltensweise dieser Persönlichkeiten war für die Individuen der Gesellschaft wegweisend. Die Gesellschaft strukturierte ihre Verhaltensnormen entsprechend der Haltung dieser Personen, und entsprechend der von ihnen gegebenen Fatwas (Rechtsentscheidungen). Dieser Umstand nahm seinen Platz proportional zur Steigerung oder Minderung der gesellschaftlichen Stellung und des Wertes der Gelehrten des Islam auf der Bühne der Geschichte ein. Imam Malik war einer der herausragenden Personen, die zu ihren Lebzeiten wichtige Einflüsse auf die Gesellschaft ausgeübt haben. Dieser Artikel versucht die Beziehung des Imam Malik zu den politischen Autoritäten, sowie die gesellschaftlichen Auswirkungen dieser Beziehungsform zu behandeln. Da Imam Malik in der Zeit der Umayyaden zu den politischen Autoritäten kaum Kontakt hatte, wird der Artikel nach einem kurzen Ausblick in diesen Zeitabschnitt sich auf die Zeit der Abbasiden konzentrieren.
10
As both time and space at hand for this presentation is limited, therefore instead of a longer introductory note, here a move is made to deal with the given subject straight. In the second section the background both historical and theological is discussed, which win state the position of the inter-religious dialogue in India. The third section will deal with the involvement and experiences of the Roman Catholic and Protestant churches in the field of inter-religious dialogue. The fourth section deals with other living religions specially Islam. Finally in section five concluding remarks are given in the form of reflections and in section six, the notes and references are listed.
27-02
Die Wissenschaftliche Irenik hat im klaren Gegensatz dazu eine ganz andere Aufgabe. Die Bezeichnung Irenik leitet sich von dem griechischen Wort "Eirene" her, das wir normalerweise mit Frieden übersetzen . Das ist in unserem Zusammenhang hier, jedoch im Zusammenhang der Wissenschaftlichen Irenik, als Übersetzung des hebräischen Wortes Shalom zu verstehen , meint also den positiven Zustand des Heils. Die Aufgabe der Irenik besteht also darin, das Heilsame der Religionen zu bewahren. Das heißt im Rahmen wissenschaftlicher Religionskritik, die für die Menschen notwendige aber relative Bedeutung der verschiedenen einzelnen Religionen heraus zuarbeiten .
68
As for the relation between Islam and pluralism, it seems a little bit complicated. There are some verses in The Koran for pluralism and at the same time we have some verses against. Among the sayings of Prophet Muhammad like the some Koranic verses, we came across with something good and bad for non-Muslims in special contexts. By another saying, we find both positive and negative statements for Jews and Christians in different circumstances. Muslim scholars the complexity still exists. We find both positive and negative stances. So it is difficult to see a standard or official view on this issue. However, we should point out that Islam recognizes all the sacred (Semitic) books and their messages. It accepts all prophets of that traditions. It defines itself as the last and perfect religion of Semitic tradition and states that no other religion will be accepted from anybody else other then itself. It criticizes both the Jews and Christians especially about their failure to uphold the Oneness of God, tawhid, and to preserve the authenticity of their scripture from interventions. This exclusivist aspect of Islam as many conservative scholars formed with putting together some evidences from the Koran is generally accepted by Muslims.
47
Hz. Meryem’in İslam tasavvufundaki yerini anlayabilmek için az da olsa tasavvuftan bahsetmemiz gerekecektir:
Yaygın bir anlayışa göre tasavvufun sözlük anlamı yün giymektir.[1] Çünkü yün elbise gösterişsiz bir kıyafet olup, avret yerlerini örtmek için giyilirdi.
Terim anlamı olarak Tasavvuf, kalben temiz olmak, Ashab-ı suffe gibi olmak; devamlı ibadet etmektir. Kötü huyları terketmek, güzel huylar edinmektir. Kimseden incinmemek, kimseyi incitmemek, herkesin yükünü çekmek, kimseye yük olmamaktır. Kâmil yani, olgun insan olmak, Allah ile beraber olmaktır. Kişinin nefsine karşı giriştiği barışı olmayan bir savaştır.[2] Bunlara benzer tasavvufun pek çok tanımı yapılmıştır. Bu tanımları bir cümlede toplamak mümkün değildir. Çünkü tasavvuf bir yaşama biçimidir, Allah’ın sevgisini ve onun hoşnutluğunu kazanma yarışıdır. Bunun yolları ve metotları sayılmayacak kadar çoktur.
Müslümanlar Allah’a ulaşma ve O’nun rızasını elde etme amacıyla örnekler aramışlardır. Örnek olarak en başta Hz. Muhammed (a.s.)i almaları tabi karşılanmalıydı. Öyle de olmuştur. Hz. Muhammed (a.s.), ümmeti için her yönüyle örnek olduğu gibi sûfî hayat tarzı için de çok önemli bir örnektir.
Nitekim O şöyle buyurmuştur: “İhsan, Allah’ı görüyormuş gibi ibadet etmektir, zira sen O’nu görmüyorsan da O seni görüyor.”[3] Bu hadisten anlaşılan hedef ibadet esnasında Yaratıcı ile kul arasında tam bir iletişimin kurulması gerektiğidir. Başka bir hadiste yine Peygamber buyurmuştur ki; “Allah Teâla buyuruyor: Bir Allah dostuna düşmanlık edene karşı, ben savaş açarım. Kul bana en çok kendisine farz kıldığım şeyleri yapmakla yaklaşır. Nafile ibadetlerle de bana yaklaşmaya devam eder. Sonuçta o derece yaklaşır ki, ben onu severim. Ben onu seversem onun işiten kulağı, gören gözü, tutan eli, yürüyen ayağı olurum. Benimle işitir, benimle görür, benimle tutar, benimle yürür.”[4] İslam’ın genel prensipleri çerçevesinde bu hadisten panteist bir anlayış çıkaramayacağımıza göre bir müslümanın bu hadisten anlayacağı şeyı, çok heyecan verici bir dînî coşkunluk olması gayet doğaldır.
Müslüman bir mistiğe ufuk ve yön veren hadisler ve sünnet örnekleri sayılmayacak kadar çoktur. Engin bir kültür ve zengin bir yaşam tarzına sahip olan İslam Tasavvufunun mensupları sadece Peygamber ve sahabe örneği ile yetinmemişlerdir. Kur’an-ı Kerimde övülen her insanı arınma modeli olarak kabul etmişlerdir. Çünkü Kur’an bir Müslüman için Allah’ın ezeli ve ebedi olan kelam sıfatından süzülüp gelen bir Kelâm-ı Kadîm’dir, yani kutsal bir kitaptır.
78
In this article we dealt with the relations between the state and religion / Islam and its interpreters i.e., the ulama, their needs each other. As a case, with an original source, we focused on the time of the Mahmud II (1808-1839) The Ottoman reforms of the nineteenth century is reconciliation between Islam and Western civili-sation. In this process the ulama played key role by commenting Islam accordance with the need of the age or of the Ottoman Empire. The reformers, chiefly the Sultan and his close friends needed the support of the ulama to legitimate their reform programmes In this crucial stage the head of the ulama the Shaykhulislam, used his own religious knowledge and influence, derived from his office by writing a treatise to persuade the masses to accept the reforms. Applying the traditional virtue literature on the Ottoman dynasty he presented in this pamphlet one of the Western-minded Ottoman sultans as an ideal caliph-sultan. This attitude helped to transform the middle-aged Ottoman political structure and society into modern ages in Western line.
222
İşârî Tefsirlerin Işığında Hz. Zekeriya'nın Vesâyeti Altındaki Meryem ve Onun Kur’ân’daki Mucizes
(2016)
The purpose of this article is to explore the Qurʾānic verses that mention Mary and the miraculous events that occured in particular during the guardianship of Zacharia. In this context commentators from the Islamic mystical tradition underline the link between the aspects of asceticism (riyāḍa) and miracles (karāmāt) with the Sufi tradition. They emphasise on the superior status of Mary in the sight of Allah Who has raised and protected her with great care. Commentators agree that Mary is not a Prophet, but can be seen as a serveant who became a friend of Allah (walī). Moreover, they highlight that Allah will always protect and support those who have obtained this superior status just as He did with Mary.
240
The thesis John Calvin has been the religious initiator of modern capitalist mentality is not in accordance with his doctrine, just the opposite is true. Calvin had a very traditional will say non- or even ant-capitalist in view of economic behaviour.
275
The thesis John Calvin (1509-1564) was the religious initiator of modern capitalist mentality is inconsistent with his teaching; just the opposite is true. Calvin represented a very traditional i.e. non- or even ant-capitalist socio-economic position. There one does not find on his doctrine what could have fostered and prepared a so-called spirit of capitalism
194
Jubiläen haben es in sich! In diesem Jahr werden wir vor allem an den großen Philosophen Immanuel Kant erinnert, der am 12.2.1804 in Königsberg in Preußen gestorben ist. Sein Denkmal am Königsberger Dom hat den Krieg und auch die Russen überstanden. Am populärsten ist bis heute Kants Erläuterung von „Aufklärung“: „Aufklärung ist der Ausgang des Menschen aus seiner selbst verschuldeten Unmündigkeit. Unmündigkeit ist das Unvermögen, sich seines Verstandes ohne Leitung eines anderen zu bedienen. Sapere aude! Habe Mut, dich deines eigenen Verstandes zu bedienen! ist also der Wahlspruch der Aufklärung!“1 Nicht nur, daß die 1784 niedergeschriebene Abhandlung Kants nicht am Anfang der deutschen Aufklärung steht, sondern eher ihr Schwanengesang ist: In der Regel wird auch verschwiegen, daß der Autor selbst die prinzipielle Gültigkeit dieser Sätze entscheidend einschränkte, wenn er am Schluß seiner Abhandlung alle radikalen Konsequenzen ausdrücklich verwarf und das Grundgesetz des friderizianischen Preußen pries: „Räsonniert, soviel als ihr wollt, und worüber ihr wollt, nur gehorcht!“ Kant hat den Angriff Napoleons auf Europa, den Zusammenbruch Preußens und Österreichs nicht mehr erlebt. So ist ihm die bittere Erfahrung erspart geblieben, daß von den Idealen einer Revolution meistens nur verwirklicht wird, was machtpolitisch brauchbar ist...
183
One memorable quote from Karl Marx’s conception of religion is, “religion is the opium of the masses.” By this, he critiqued religion as an analgesic that dulls the senses, thus inducing a false sense of satisfaction, and preventing the oppressed from revolting against the grubby socio-economic system. As the sigh of the oppressed, religion makes them to resign to fate since it only gives an unrealistic eschatological hope. Rather than conceive religion from this prismatic way, contemporary events have shown that religion has become an amphetamine or a catalyst for revolt, not only at the global but also national level. This work argues that religion is used as an amphetamine, an energizing pill, to pursue other goals than religious as depicted in the activities of Boko Haram sect, which has raised security challenges in contemporary Nigeria.
185
In der Hindu Tradition zeigen sich zwei grundsätzlich unterschiedliche Strömungen. Einmal gibt es die Richtungen, die sich die Befreiung vom Joch des durch das eigene Werk, Karma, bestimmten Rads der Wiedergeburten, Samsara, aufs Panier geschrieben haben. Zum anderen gibt es die karmistische Religion, die genau das eigene Werk zum entscheidenden, wenn nicht gar alleinigen Kriterium menschlicher Existenz erhebt. Diese karmistische Religion bildete und bildet den geistigen Hintergrund der indo-asiatischen Kultur so sehr, daß sich ihre Gegner immer noch vor ihr rechtfertigen müssen. Während die karmistische Existenzdeutung besonders unter den Buddhisten und Jainas in voller Blüte steht, haben die großen Religionen der Shaivas, Vaishnavas und Shaktas schon früh in ihren zahllosen Bewegungen massiv gegen den Karmismus Front gemacht. Dennoch gilt die Karma-Samsara-Lehre als Beschreibung des Normalfalls der Existenzgestaltung. Die ist die stets vorausgesetzte Mechanik des Existenzprozesses. Aber als ein unaufhebbares Schicksal wird sie nicht mehr so ohne Weiters im Hindutum anerkannt. Die o.g. Bewegungen sind denn auch religiöse Revolten, die auf höchst unterschiedliche Weise gegen die absolute und allgemeine Geltung der Karma-Samsara-Lehre durchaus erfolgreich Widerstand leisten. Wie in den anderen Kulturen auch ist der Kampf zwischen beiden Religionen im Hindutum das zentrale Thema der geistigen Auseinandersetzung mit der eigenen Existenz. Diese so konträre Sichtsweisen der Existenz im Hindutum, d.h. die karmistische und antikarmistische Religion, sollen im Folgenden an je einem Fallbeispiel aus noch immer gültigen heiligen Schriften vorgestellt werden.
221
This article is concerned with the mystical exegesis of the journey between Moses and Ḫiḍr mentioned in the Qurʾān in Sūrah al-Kahf (18/60-82). The verses are viewed and analysed by the commentaries of classic commentators (mufassirūn) aṭ-Ṭabarī, az-Zamaḫšarī and ar-Razī. The emphasis is set on the content-related description of Moses and Ḫiḍr which are found in Sūrah al-Kahf. The supreme allegory of the journey is that divinely-inspired knowledge (al-ʿilm al-ladunnī) may be received in the form of revelation (as Moses did) or as mystical, intuitive knowledge (as was given to Ḫiḍr). Classic commentators suggest, despite the distinguished position of Moses as a prophet, that the knowledge given to Ḫiḍr is superior and described as a secret or hidden knowledge. For this reason, Ḫiḍr holds an essential position in Islamic mystical tradition (taṣawwuf), in which Sūrah al-Kahf is considered as a legitimation for the mystical dimension in Islam.
190
24 b
Castes still determine the social reality of India in many fields and affect politics more and more by functioning as vote banks which are decisive in elections. Thus it is small wonder that there is an ongoing discussion about this social phe-nomenon. The controversies in the course of this discussion not only relate to academic theories concerning the origin, the evolution and the mode of opera-tion of the caste system but also determine the discussion about reform models for the Indian society. Such models either strive for the complete abolition of the caste system or at least call for a comprehensive reform of it. Especially the Dalit movement blames the caste system for the oppression and discrimination of the Dalits in society and tries to withdraw them from this system.[1] Yet the Dalit movement does not develop any alternative social draft. The Hindutva movement makes a strong effort to establish a modern (Hindu) nation which is only possible by overcoming the caste system that totally divides the society. Thus Hindutva is against the caste system though the antagonists of this move-ment usually maintain the contrary.[2] Swami Vivekananda holds that the only way to overcome the caste system is the Brahmanization of the whole society. For this he gives a religious explanation as he announces the end of the Kali-Yuga.[3] The Hare Krishna movement wants to turn away from a hereditary caste system towards a system where every individual is classified according to his skills and performance. Such a system should be based on Vedic traditions and especially on the fourfold varna system which is described in the ancient Rigveda.[4] Gandhi’s social draft and above all its attitude towards the caste system are often part of the current discussion but the interpretations differ according to the inter-preter’s ideological direction. Thus some charge Gandhi with having defended the caste system unconditionally, while others consider him a sharp critic of the system. This large spectrum is hardly surprising, since Gandhi’s comments are very reserved and can only become understandable by a comparative analysis of different statements on the caste system made by him during his political career. This article intends to provide such an analysis without neglecting the historical context which is vital to make Gandhi’s ideas clear. ...
63
In den mystischen Kommentarschulen, die einen wichtigen Teil der Korankommentarliteratur hervorgebracht haben, stützt man sich bei der Erstellung von Kommentaren außer auf bestimmte exegetische Regeln und Methoden auch auf die Intuition. Neben dem Wissen, das man durch die normale intellektuelle Arbeit erwirbt, gibt es nach dem Islam ein Wissen, das von Gott unmittelbar vermittelt wird und das man Ledünni Bilgi, d.h. unmittelbares intuitives Wissen nennt. Diese Art von Wissen, das man in allen Religionen der Welt findet, erwirbt man durch strenge Askese und intensive Gottesverehrung: Dies ist das mystische Wissen. Jede Religion und Philosophie hat ihre eigenen Auffassungs-, Interpretations- und Ausdrucksweisen. Das gilt auch für die Religion des Islam. Jedoch ist islamische Mystik nicht nur Wissen in Gedanke und Wort, sondern zugleich auch ein Wissen vom Handeln. [Die mystischen Korankommentare müssen, da sie das Ergebnis eines ekstatischen Zustandes sind, unabhängig von der empfangenden Person, nicht unbedingt akzeptiert werden, besonders dann nicht, wenn sie nicht mit dem Koran, der islamischen Tradition, Verstand und Logik übereinstimmen.] ...